WBAUnofficial
Griffiths in goal - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Griffiths in goal (/showthread.php?tid=36917)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: Griffiths in goal - Sliced - 03-12-2025

(03-12-2025, 10:37 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: A player makes a mistake. The manager sticks with him...is good management.

There were plenty on here telling us that Button was a better GK than Johnston not long ago.... till he started playing.

In the long term it's Griffiths, but let's not denigrate Wildsmith's abilities. Unless we're looking for a scapegoat of course.

Absolutely this. He made a mistake yesterday but he's had mainly good games, and a couple of poor ones. The vast majority of the fans (myself included) would prefer to see Griffiths in goal because he's younger, an exciting long term prospect and 'one of our own', but they were also waiting for a Wildsmith fuck up to jump on him at the earliest opportunity.

If he plays next game he should get everyones support, and I think he probably will play the next game, but I'd rather see Griffiths.


RE: Griffiths in goal - MrBater - 03-12-2025

Button was the worst keeper I think we've ever had.


RE: Griffiths in goal - Ted Maul - 03-12-2025

(03-12-2025, 10:40 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(03-12-2025, 10:37 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: A player makes a mistake. The manager sticks with him...is good management.

There were plenty on here telling us that Button was a better GK than Johnston not long ago.... till he started playing.

In the long term it's Griffiths, but let's not denigrate Wildsmith's abilities. Unless we're looking for a scapegoat of course.

Absolutely this. He made a mistake yesterday but he's had mainly good games, and a couple of poor ones. The vast majority of the fans (myself included) would prefer to see Griffiths in goal because he's younger, an exciting long term prospect and 'one of our own', but they were also waiting for a Wildsmith fuck up to jump on him at the earliest opportunity.

If he plays next game he should get everyones support, and I think he probably will play the next game, but I'd rather see Griffiths.

Wildsmith has been very obliging in that regard though. He's made errors leading to goals against Sheffield Wednesday, Blackburn x2, Leeds and now Burnley - that's five goals in seven games.


RE: Griffiths in goal - wba13 - 03-12-2025

(03-12-2025, 10:31 AM)wbamitch Wrote:
(03-12-2025, 10:21 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: There isn't a decision to make. Anyone with half a brain cell can understand Wildsmith isn't the right choice.

We all questioned the decision to make him no.1, he's done nothing to justify that selection. I really do believe in patience and giving players time, but it's clear that it just isn't working, and it's got to the point now where he's putting us in positions to concede 2 or more goals a game due to his incompetence.

Obviously the goal we conceded was an inexcusable mistake, and then there was that ridiculous half arsed punch we were lucky to get away with, in the second half.

We just can't carry on with a GK who is clearly a liability.

Unfortunately Mowbray has history with sticking with awful 'keepers longer than necessary. See Pascal Zuberhowler. Who was somehow worse than Button!

Yeah Mowbray pretty much confirmed in the interview with Steve Hermon post match that he won’t drop him. Frustrating
Yes your right Mowbray said keepers are allowed mistakes, but for me last night was two to many with the goal conceded and a pathetic punch. Don’t care about the kicking he’s there to save goals and he’s not doing it. Has to be Josh but it won’t be as Mowbray will stick with Wildsmith. Angry

(03-12-2025, 10:47 AM)MrBater Wrote: Button was the worst keeper I think we've ever had.

Fulop God rest his soul helped his old side out by throwing in goals.


RE: Griffiths in goal - Bob Fossil - 03-12-2025

A spacegoat is someone who is blamed for the failings of others, so this cannot be the case with Wildsmith as he is being targeted for his own mistakes only.
He has been given a chance and, whilst not being anywhere near Fulop or Button territory, he has made costly mistakes so can have no complaints if a highly rated keeper is now given his chance as a result.


RE: Griffiths in goal - Man from delmonte - 03-12-2025

(03-12-2025, 10:51 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-12-2025, 10:40 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(03-12-2025, 10:37 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: A player makes a mistake. The manager sticks with him...is good management.

There were plenty on here telling us that Button was a better GK than Johnston not long ago.... till he started playing.

In the long term it's Griffiths, but let's not denigrate Wildsmith's abilities. Unless we're looking for a scapegoat of course.

Absolutely this. He made a mistake yesterday but he's had mainly good games, and a couple of poor ones. The vast majority of the fans (myself included) would prefer to see Griffiths in goal because he's younger, an exciting long term prospect and 'one of our own', but they were also waiting for a Wildsmith fuck up to jump on him at the earliest opportunity.

If he plays next game he should get everyones support, and I think he probably will play the next game, but I'd rather see Griffiths.

Wildsmith has been very obliging in that regard though. He's made errors leading to goals against Sheffield Wednesday, Blackburn x2, Leeds and now Burnley - that's five goals in seven games.

It's not just the individual errors leading to goals. He doesn't command his box at all and the defence simply won't have the same confidence with him behind them. I would say they've performed really well despite that.

I don't want to see any kind of pile-on to Wildsmith from the crowd. In that situation on-one wins. In Wildsmith's defence I would say he did ok after that early howler last night. However, he is looking a liability. It's not just a case of Griffiths being 'one of our own' and the younger, more attractive option. He's come off a first half of the season where he's been outstanding by all accounts and should be brimming with confidence. That makes a big difference with a goalkeeper.


RE: Griffiths in goal - SausEggBaton - 03-12-2025

(03-12-2025, 10:19 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Tough one for Mowbray now as the majority of the fans are gone on Wildsmith. He probably will want to show a bit of loyalty to the keeper he backed, but the last thing he needs before a big game on Saturday is groans around the ground the second the team is read out.

Mogga can avoid those groans, by just puting Griffths in goal.


RE: Griffiths in goal - Shabby Russian - 03-12-2025

(03-12-2025, 10:37 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Let's not get too hard on Wildsmith for what was really the first proper mistake that has led to a goal, which is pretty-much beyond argument. A couple of others v Sheff W and Blackburn he possibly could have done better with, but this is the first howler.

Button was altogether a far worse keeper, whose confidence has gone and the defence was all over the place knowing he couldn't be relied on. Comparing Wildsmith to him in terms of where we are now is farcical. If we didn't have Griffiths waiting in the wings I don't think there'd be many calls for change at all.

Personally, having said all that I'd still want Griffiths, but will be supportive of JW as long as he's between the sticks and also measured in my judgement of him.

Good post.

The headline is that he/we are conceding less than 1 goal a game with him in goal....it doesn’t scream Goalkeeping crisis.

Think in the very short term[this weekend), Mowbray would be right to stick by him. Let's see how it goes from there.

On a selfish note I want Griffiths to be picked. I fear every goal we concede whilst Wildsmith is in goal will be scrutinised until some fault can be attributed to him. It never makes for great reading.


RE: Griffiths in goal - MGalea - 03-12-2025

To be fair to Fulop RIP - he wasn't helping his old team - his "mistakes" that day cost Spurs (the team he was at for years without playing) a champions league spot.


RE: Griffiths in goal - Ted Maul - 03-12-2025

(03-12-2025, 11:23 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(03-12-2025, 10:19 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Tough one for Mowbray now as the majority of the fans are gone on Wildsmith. He probably will want to show a bit of loyalty to the keeper he backed, but the last thing he needs before a big game on Saturday is groans around the ground the second the team is read out.

Mogga can avoid those groans, by just puting Griffths in goal.

Well obviously, but he's pretty much said he isn't going to do that for some strange reason.