WBAUnofficial
Heading back - today - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Heading back - today (/showthread.php?tid=36818)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Heading back - today - tHEgLASSdOORS - 03-02-2025

It staggers me how anyone could have watched us and not see how far and away better our entire backline is when Bartley is playing. If we are to have any chance of winning the play offs it will be critical he’s available


RE: Heading back - today - Ted Maul - 03-02-2025

(03-02-2025, 07:54 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It staggers me how anyone could have watched us and not see how far and away better our entire backline is when Bartley is playing. If we are to have any chance of winning the play offs it will be critical he’s available

That would involve either admitting you're wrong or having half a clue what you're on about.


RE: Heading back - today - Josh1873 - 03-02-2025

Throw all the meaningless stats around you want, you simply can't deny or argue that he was partly to blame for the Leeds goal yesterday. He regularly loses his attacker through poor positioning and reading of the game. You don't need stats to understand and see that!

He did, however, redeem himself with an excellent block late on in the second half. That's his strength - putting his body on the line with blocks, tackles and heading. He's good at the very basics, but is liable to switching off and leaving us open. But then again, most defenders at this level won't be at it for 90 mins.

Let's not pretend he's some sort of Messiah that we can't do without, eh.

Does he improve us when he plays? Not for me, no. He's average, at best. He has good games, he has bad games. He does a job 90% of the time, and has been a decent servant for the club. Nothing more, nothing less.


RE: Heading back - today - Lurker#3 - 03-02-2025

(03-02-2025, 08:23 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Throw all the meaningless stats around you want, you simply can't deny or argue that he was partly to blame for the Leeds goal yesterday. He regularly loses his attacker through poor positioning and reading of the game. You don't need stats to understand and see that!

He did, however, redeem himself with an excellent block late on in the second half. That's his strength - putting his body on the line with blocks, tackles and heading. He's good at the very basics, but is liable to switching off and leaving us open. But then again, most defenders at this level won't be at it for 90 mins.

Let's not pretend he's some sort of Messiah that we can't do without, eh.

Does he improve us when he plays? Not for me, no. He's average, at best. He has good games, he has bad games. He does a job 90% of the time, and has been a decent servant for the club. Nothing more, nothing less.

He wasn't, mate. 

The ball in was a good pass that dropped perfectly between Bartley who was marking, correctly the art kerbin front of his. Heggem then started his press to the goal scorer who flicked a hopeful header goalward which only went in because the keeper went on one of his little walk abouts. 

The keeper was soley to blame for their goal. He should have stayed at home and we would have been fine. 

Bartley is Objectively the best we've got. He has weaknesses like all players do, but when he's not in the team our vulnerabilities tend to get exposed. If he fit and healthy he should continue getting 12 month deals, and we need to try and replace Semi and Holgate with another Heggem type.


RE: Heading back - today - Josh1873 - 03-02-2025

Wildsmith gets the majority of the blame, I'm not denying that. But watch Bartley's movement when the cross comes in. He's no where near the attacker, whom he was touch tight to seconds earlier. He was caught switching off, lost his man, and allowed him to get the header in.

It was more a GK error, and that should lead to Griffiths coming in, I'd hope, but Bartley should be doing better in that situation.


RE: Heading back - today - tHEgLASSdOORS - 03-02-2025

(03-02-2025, 08:23 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Throw all the meaningless stats around you want, you simply can't deny or argue that he was partly to blame for the Leeds goal yesterday. He regularly loses his attacker through poor positioning and reading of the game. You don't need stats to understand and see that!

He did, however, redeem himself with an excellent block late on in the second half. That's his strength - putting his body on the line with blocks, tackles and heading. He's good at the very basics, but is liable to switching off and leaving us open. But then again, most defenders at this level won't be at it for 90 mins.

Let's not pretend he's some sort of Messiah that we can't do without, eh.

Does he improve us when he plays? Not for me, no. He's average, at best. He has good games, he has bad games. He does a job 90% of the time, and has been a decent servant for the club. Nothing more, nothing less.

This just isn’t true Josh. Respect your views and posts but miles, miles off with this.


RE: Heading back - today - Stillclem4england - 03-02-2025

Just seen the goal back. Wildsmith - dear oh dear. I thought that it stemmed from him scuffing his kick to Solomon but the video didn’t go that far back.


RE: Heading back - today - Josh1873 - 03-02-2025

(03-02-2025, 08:44 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 08:23 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Throw all the meaningless stats around you want, you simply can't deny or argue that he was partly to blame for the Leeds goal yesterday. He regularly loses his attacker through poor positioning and reading of the game. You don't need stats to understand and see that!

He did, however, redeem himself with an excellent block late on in the second half. That's his strength - putting his body on the line with blocks, tackles and heading. He's good at the very basics, but is liable to switching off and leaving us open. But then again, most defenders at this level won't be at it for 90 mins.

Let's not pretend he's some sort of Messiah that we can't do without, eh.

Does he improve us when he plays? Not for me, no. He's average, at best. He has good games, he has bad games. He does a job 90% of the time, and has been a decent servant for the club. Nothing more, nothing less.

This just isn’t true Josh. Respect your views and posts but miles, miles off with this.

That's fair enough, agree to disagree! It was overall a really good performance, and a top point. That's the main thing.


RE: Heading back - today - tHEgLASSdOORS - 03-02-2025

ThassitR. UTY


RE: Heading back - today - richbaggie - 03-02-2025

(03-02-2025, 08:23 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Throw all the meaningless stats around you want, you simply can't deny or argue that he was partly to blame for the Leeds goal yesterday. He regularly loses his attacker through poor positioning and reading of the game. You don't need stats to understand and see that!

He did, however, redeem himself with an excellent block late on in the second half. That's his strength - putting his body on the line with blocks, tackles and heading. He's good at the very basics, but is liable to switching off and leaving us open. But then again, most defenders at this level won't be at it for 90 mins.

Let's not pretend he's some sort of Messiah that we can't do without, eh.

Does he improve us when he plays? Not for me, no. He's average, at best.
He has good games, he has bad games. He does a job 90% of the time, and has been a decent servant for the club. Nothing more, nothing less.

Pretty much everyone I spoke to after the game spoke about how important Bartley is to us now and how much he improves us as a defensive unit when he plays. Our stats over the last couple years of how we do with him in the team to how we do without him also back this up.

It's wildly wrong to say we aren't better with him in the team.