WBAUnofficial
Non tinker 11 - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Non tinker 11 (/showthread.php?tid=36676)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Non tinker 11 - SausEggBaton - 02-17-2025

(02-17-2025, 11:44 AM)MrBater Wrote: No Dike?

Indeed - however this is non-tinker, I would look at the complete historical non-tinker 11 as:

Griffiths

Furlong - Holgate - Heggem - Styles

Fellows - Mowatt - Molumby - Grant

Grady

Maja

I think Styles is capabe but needs assistance, Grant or Fellows will come back to help out, but Grady or Johnston won't effectively - they'll just be a body in a defence line / structure.

For me, Holgate has stepped up quite a lot. You can't disregard his couple of brain fart moments, but again I saw in the Millwall game making blocks, challenging balls and putting himself about. Diakite, unfortunately again showed his minor lapses in concentration by being out jumped for Millwall's goal, where Holgate was doing an effible job tracking the back post threats. Barts has been nothing but admirable in his service to the Albion, but just think he's ran out of steam.

As for a newboys or reclaimed players non-tinker 11 I do see it as this:

---------------- Wildsmith
Furlong - Holgate - Heggem - Stlyes
----------------- Mowatt ------------ 
Fellows ----------- Price ----------- Grant
------------ Maja - Armstrong


RE: Non tinker 11 - Wednesburybaggie - 02-17-2025

(02-17-2025, 11:15 AM)Peachy Wrote: Much had been made of Mogga's chopping and changing the starting 11 and scattergun subs. I'd like to see us settle on a firm first 11 soon. For me it would be as follows assuming all fit and well.

--------------Griffiths--------------
Furlong-------Ajayi-----Barts--------Heggem
---------Price-------Molumby--------
Fellows-------Armstrong (10)--------Mikey
--------------Maja-----------------

Griffiths in sticks. Personally feel he commands his area better and his size is imposing.

We need to tighten up at the back and as much as I like Styles I still don't think he is a full back and he gets targeted. I think Heggem will give us solidity and physicality at the back which we need in a team that is more front foot now.

Price in the 8 role alongside Molumby. His range of forward passing is good and his dead balls could be a major weapon with both Semi and Bart's in the side.

Two wide options are a no brainer for me. Both can create and have pace and skill. I've put Armstrong in the 10 and Maja at 9 but they could easily swap as both are comfortable in the 10. (Lankshear and Dike to battle for the 9 on the bench).

I think this side looks formidable to me.

Onions?
I would go with that, except I would put Maja at 10 and Armstrong up top. Maja was excellent pre injury,  at dropping deep and bringing others into play. Plus I think that Armstrong has a bit more pace about him.


RE: Non tinker 11 - MrBater - 02-17-2025

I don't get how any of these suggestions are a non tinker 11... They're just suggestions on what people think is our best team, caveated with all being fit and well, which we don't have the luxury of.

I'm not sure how many times we've started with the exact same 11 all season, sone statto will no doubt tell me, but I'm guessing at 5 games...


RE: Non tinker 11 - WorcsWBA - 02-17-2025

I don't think there's such a thing as a non-tinker XI in modern football, particularly in a 46 match season. Rightly or wrongly, quite a few players these days start to look jaded quite quickly so it's probably asking for trouble to play the same side 3 times in a week. Some believe that Heggem has been looking tired of as he's been having to play every game, so he might not be up to the extra rigours of playing at left-back at the moment. I hope people aren't up in arms when he eventually is rested.

Mowbray has been here 4 weeks with there being 2 midweek games in that period, so I think match XI changes are inevitable and he'll also want to see players in action to evaluate them in actual games rather than just training. Obviously he can watch old match videos, but they'll be of a different style of play.

Before anyone says he shouldn't be changing the style of play, remember that he's been brought in with the remit from the Board of generating more attacking excitement. That largely hasn't happened yet, but I believe that's because the players aren't implementing what he wants them to. Watching the goals Armstrong scored during his Blackburn days, there's a fair few from through balls, so I hope that we'll be seeing more of that before long. I'm actually struggling to remember the last time we scored as a result of a through ball!


RE: Non tinker 11 - BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine - 02-17-2025

Griffiths

Furlong Bartley Ajayi Heggem

         Price  Molumby

  Fellows Mowatt Grant

             Armstrong

That leaves Maja, Johnston, Dike, Bany, Grady, Styles, Holgate, Diakite and Lankshear as back-up. We've got so many options now though, it's almost ridiculous.


RE: Non tinker 11 - sickParrot - 02-17-2025

Until Bartley, Ajayi and Heggem are all available, surely Frambotta is better defensively than Styles?


RE: Non tinker 11 - Lightnin - 02-17-2025

(02-17-2025, 11:15 AM)Peachy Wrote: Much had been made of Mogga's chopping and changing the starting 11 and scattergun subs. I'd like to see us settle on a firm first 11 soon. For me it would be as follows assuming all fit and well.

--------------Griffiths--------------
Furlong-------Ajayi-----Barts--------Heggem
---------Price-------Molumby--------
Fellows-------Armstrong (10)--------Mikey
--------------Maja-----------------

Griffiths in sticks. Personally feel he commands his area better and his size is imposing.

We need to tighten up at the back and as much as I like Styles I still don't think he is a full back and he gets targeted. I think Heggem will give us solidity and physicality at the back which we need in a team that is more front foot now.

Price in the 8 role alongside Molumby. His range of forward passing is good and his dead balls could be a major weapon with both Semi and Bart's in the side.

Two wide options are a no brainer for me. Both can create and have pace and skill. I've put Armstrong in the 10 and Maja at 9 but they could easily swap as both are comfortable in the 10. (Lankshear and Dike to battle for the 9 on the bench).

I think this side looks formidable to me.

Onions?

Swap Maja and Armstrong around. The midfield 2 are still a bit up in the air, haven’t seen Price in a midfield 2 yet.


RE: Non tinker 11 - Shabby Russian - 02-17-2025

Said it all season but we should be playing 433

I don't believe there is any combination of players in this squad that play together effectively in a central midfield 2.

This means that you can't play Armstrong and Maja together, unless you want to play one out wide.

I know it is very tempting to try and get Maja, Armstrong, Johnstone and Fellows into the same team, but I don't think it would be successful.


RE: Non tinker 11 - Man from delmonte - 02-17-2025

(02-17-2025, 11:44 AM)MrBater Wrote: No Dike?

IF he stays fit, it will still take him a long while to get up to speed before the end of the season. Given the options we have in Armstrong and Maja I can’t see Dike being anything other than potential impact sub for the time being.


RE: Non tinker 11 - MrBater - 02-17-2025

(02-17-2025, 04:34 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Until Bartley, Ajayi and Heggem are all available, surely Frambotta is better defensively than Styles?

Absolutely nobody knows, but since neither CC or TM pick him one must assume not!