RE: The three stooges - Vinebaggie - 02-13-2025
I would love, I mean really love these three stooges to be brilliant committed footballers, I’d eat a humble pie the size of a bus with a big smile on my face were it to be true. But no amount of selected stats will convince me that they should be in the team, they see some of the ball last night but only because Blackburn were playing rope-a-dope comfortable in a 2-0 lead.
RE: The three stooges - aj21 - 02-13-2025
(02-13-2025, 06:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Grady has just won Championship POTM for January and I think we're a more dangerous side with him playing in the 10 role. Likewise I think Swift can do a job there. Jed is behind Fellows, Johnston and was behind Grant in the pecking order but if Mowbray fancies him then he's got to give him a go in his strongest position which is wide right.
That was a fan vote - it’s not an accurate guide. He only started 3 matches in January
RE: The three stooges - Sliced - 02-13-2025
(02-13-2025, 08:59 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (02-13-2025, 08:16 AM)Sliced Wrote: (02-13-2025, 08:01 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (02-13-2025, 07:46 AM)Sliced Wrote: I appreciate that you're bringing stats into this, but there's got to be some context.
A key pass is a pass that results in a shot afterwards, so firstly that's most likely to come from someone playing in the role that Swift/Price played.
Secondly 'most key passes' was 2, for both Price and Swift. Two. Twice they kicked the ball to someone else who then had a shot.
Grady had 3 tackles, and Wallace had 5 shots but only one was on target. I wouldn't say having aimless shots on goal is an indication of a good performance.
We had 2 shots in goal until the subs. After that we had 11, 8 of which were after Jed and swift came on.
Now fwiw. I think the subs were the wrong ones. Not the players coming on. But the tactical shift and players off.
But it doesn't get around the players that came on improved us. Swift and Wallace played 20 odd minutes and did more than the rest of the team combined in transition and in offensive areas. Jed had a couple of really sharp shits and almost got an assist for Furlongs header. Swift, as always got us going and out us in areas to get shots off. Key passes are important of course. But Swift is usually the man who plays the pre assist. He picks good, intelligent passes to forward players in dangerous areas. Not simple, predictable passes out to a wide player where the opposition can double up and control things.
They also came on when we were 2 down so Blackburn were defending their lead. If the above is how you saw it then that's fine, but Wallace having 5 shots with 1 on target and Swift having 2 key passes doesn't mean it's a good performance. We needed a goal, and we brought on two players that don't usually lead to us scoring, and they didn't again yesterday. As I've said in another thread, Wallace was less poor than Fellows, but he still wasn't good.
It feels a little bit like you were picking and choosing on the stats, and you could probably pick a stat which flatters or every player on the pitch.
Grady had the worst pass percentage of any outfield player in our team, but you didn't mention that when saying we should look at what actually happens on the pitch. I would say that's a more revealing stat than Grady having 3 tackles, although I didn't think he was bad yesterday.
Fwiw, I don't think Wallace and Swift played brilliantly. I was just pointing out that some people seem to have their ability to objectively look at the game blinded by their preconceptions.
It would be like me never giving praise to Holgate or Molumby who I struggle with at times, or regardless of the game blaming them or bringing them up.
Players like Grady never really have a particularly high pass completion percentage as they play high risk passes. Usually in attacking areas when it's congested and difficult to operate. Pass completion is a better indication of a holding players performance who's job it is to recycle possession. A Mowatt, Molumby, Furlong, Styles etc.
I mean its more valid than him having 3 tackles
RE: The three stooges - Cheshire East Baggie - 02-13-2025
I'm not going to argue about stats. I thought Wallace put himself about and things were working for him when he came on last night. Maybe it's time to start him wide right occasionally and save Fellows for later in the game..
Grady always frustrates because so much of what he does fizzles out. Starting him wide on the right against Sheff Wed didn't work because he didn't stay out there. With him drifting in all the time it reduced our attacking options and squeezed Price over to the left. Last night we saw what Price can do as no 10 and it wasn't much tbh. So Grady is still our best bet at no 10 until Bany comes along.
Swift can't compete with any of the other options for a centre midfield place - we're weak enough defensively and he seems to have less defensive nous than them. Last night he got stuck in, on a night when too many of the starting eleven were drifting through the game. No reason to criticise his effort or achievement.
RE: The three stooges - Lurker#3 - 02-13-2025
(02-13-2025, 09:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: (02-13-2025, 08:59 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (02-13-2025, 08:16 AM)Sliced Wrote: (02-13-2025, 08:01 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (02-13-2025, 07:46 AM)Sliced Wrote: I appreciate that you're bringing stats into this, but there's got to be some context.
A key pass is a pass that results in a shot afterwards, so firstly that's most likely to come from someone playing in the role that Swift/Price played.
Secondly 'most key passes' was 2, for both Price and Swift. Two. Twice they kicked the ball to someone else who then had a shot.
Grady had 3 tackles, and Wallace had 5 shots but only one was on target. I wouldn't say having aimless shots on goal is an indication of a good performance.
We had 2 shots in goal until the subs. After that we had 11, 8 of which were after Jed and swift came on.
Now fwiw. I think the subs were the wrong ones. Not the players coming on. But the tactical shift and players off.
But it doesn't get around the players that came on improved us. Swift and Wallace played 20 odd minutes and did more than the rest of the team combined in transition and in offensive areas. Jed had a couple of really sharp shits and almost got an assist for Furlongs header. Swift, as always got us going and out us in areas to get shots off. Key passes are important of course. But Swift is usually the man who plays the pre assist. He picks good, intelligent passes to forward players in dangerous areas. Not simple, predictable passes out to a wide player where the opposition can double up and control things.
They also came on when we were 2 down so Blackburn were defending their lead. If the above is how you saw it then that's fine, but Wallace having 5 shots with 1 on target and Swift having 2 key passes doesn't mean it's a good performance. We needed a goal, and we brought on two players that don't usually lead to us scoring, and they didn't again yesterday. As I've said in another thread, Wallace was less poor than Fellows, but he still wasn't good.
It feels a little bit like you were picking and choosing on the stats, and you could probably pick a stat which flatters or every player on the pitch.
Grady had the worst pass percentage of any outfield player in our team, but you didn't mention that when saying we should look at what actually happens on the pitch. I would say that's a more revealing stat than Grady having 3 tackles, although I didn't think he was bad yesterday.
Fwiw, I don't think Wallace and Swift played brilliantly. I was just pointing out that some people seem to have their ability to objectively look at the game blinded by their preconceptions.
It would be like me never giving praise to Holgate or Molumby who I struggle with at times, or regardless of the game blaming them or bringing them up.
Players like Grady never really have a particularly high pass completion percentage as they play high risk passes. Usually in attacking areas when it's congested and difficult to operate. Pass completion is a better indication of a holding players performance who's job it is to recycle possession. A Mowatt, Molumby, Furlong, Styles etc.
I mean its more valid than him having 3 tackles
I am not sure it is, but that's just how people view the game differently. I want my forwards counter pressing hard and then playing hurtful passes. So that's why I probably value Gradys defensive contributions higher than pass completion . But as I say, it's each to their own.
RE: The three stooges - Jerry - 02-13-2025
For me, when Wallace comes on as sub he seems off the pace, no ball control and easily dispossessed. The view his legs have gone sums it up. But when he started the game recently he looked his old self (5-1 game), he had everything I thought had gone. So it may be that Wallace needs rotating with Fellows for starts as and when the tactics require rather than playing him from sub.
RE: The three stooges - Tom Joad - 02-13-2025
FWIW there was one obvious sub last night for me. HT, Molumby for Lankshear with Price dropping back. Then maybe tinker with the wings, Jed for Tom, or Grady for Tom but inside and central. What always makes my heart sink is when all the subs are introduced in double quick time with no apparent notice taken of how the flow is going.
RE: The three stooges - Jacko - 02-13-2025
Not the greatest evidence to rock up with Lurker. Wallace for example NEVER looked like he might score, taking long range potshots including one woeful freekick. Swift was neat and tidy but the number is 2. Presumably both short passes to Wallace for the aforementioned.
Grady inexplicably played wide right again, but agree his counter press was good.
I do look forward to the clamour for Lankshear to end as it dawns on others he's bobbins.
RE: The three stooges - B68baggy2 - 02-13-2025
Furlong's performance was of the kind that used to have him a regular for spacegoating.
RE: The three stooges - Jacko - 02-13-2025
(02-13-2025, 09:09 PM)B68baggy2 Wrote: Furlong's performance was of the kind that used to have him a regular for spacegoating.
Agree looked well off it. Anticipation zero.
|