![]() |
|
Looking back on last night's match - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Looking back on last night's match (/showthread.php?tid=36361) Pages:
1
2
|
RE: Looking back on last night's match - TartanRug - 01-22-2025 Got to admit I find it baffling that anyone would prefer Holgate in the team ahead of Bartley as seems to be what some are implying RE: Looking back on last night's match - sneekydevil - 01-22-2025 (01-22-2025, 01:23 PM)TartanRug Wrote: Got to admit I find it baffling that anyone would prefer Holgate in the team ahead of Bartley as seems to be what some are implying Yeah same for me too, Holgate never instills confidence and in true Mardon fashion always seems to have at least one catastrophic error in him a game. I would always have Bartley and Heggem as my CB pairing if both were available . RE: Looking back on last night's match - Sliced - 01-22-2025 Bartley's one of those players that gets better every game he doesn't play. Then he comes back and we concede more goals with him in the team than out of it, he does his little finger pointing thing after he fucks up or is out of position and it's mistaken for leadership. He's probably the best header of the ball in the Championship, which is a massive asset, but outside of that he's poor, and the reason why managers like to play Ajayi or Holgate alongside him is because his ball playing ability is limited to short passes to the other centre back that will then attempt to play more ambitious passes to drive us because it's not something that Bartley is capable of doing. Another reason is because unfortunately both Bartley and Heggem aren't blessed with pace, so it drastically limits the way we can play (as illustrated immediately when they were put together v Sheffield Wednesday and hit on the counter attack within the first 3 minutes of their partnership). RE: Looking back on last night's match - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-22-2025 (01-22-2025, 01:59 PM)Sliced Wrote: Bartley's one of those players that gets better every game he doesn't play. Then he comes back and we concede more goals with him in the team than out of it, he does his little finger pointing thing after he fucks up or is out of position and it's mistaken for leadership. It seems that some posters are looking for reasons to diss Holgate, while cutting other players rather more slack. CC didn't pick Ajayi when he had alternatives, but preferred him to Holgate this season. Both have the pace that Bartley lacks and have forged workable partnerships with him. Two things about Barts, firstly he is getting old and nursing injuries that won't ever be better. Secondly, he and Heggem have never looked a good pairing. I just find the space-goating of Holgate a bit tedious. It's rarely true that one player lost a game on his own, that one wrong team selection cost us the points. Holgate's doing OK and anyway there's only Taylor waiting in the wings at the moment. It's ironic that Barts gets better every game he misses. Anyone remember how he was reviled after some very expensive howlers a couple of seasons ago? Short memories, eh? RE: Looking back on last night's match - Sliced - 01-22-2025 (01-22-2025, 02:13 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:(01-22-2025, 01:59 PM)Sliced Wrote: Bartley's one of those players that gets better every game he doesn't play. Then he comes back and we concede more goals with him in the team than out of it, he does his little finger pointing thing after he fucks up or is out of position and it's mistaken for leadership. Absolutely spot on. I appreciate the effort that he (and the other defenders that got regularly shat on like Townsend and Furlong) have made since being here but he's not improved us on the pitch. People earlier in the season worrying about our defence because Bartley got injured, then we had 3 clean sheets in the first 4 games without him. If we actually knew how to take corners then he might be a miss, but we really haven't missed him at all. RE: Looking back on last night's match - Jacko - 01-22-2025 Someone use their gavel and bring the Mason Holgate appreciation society inaugural meeting to a close. All 2 members must have something better to do.
RE: Looking back on last night's match - B68Baggy - 01-22-2025 (01-22-2025, 11:27 AM)Sliced Wrote: Good summary. I thought Devante Cole was fine when he came on and agree that Holgate outperformed Heggem again. Unfortunately some posters have decided how players are going to play before kickoff. I think overall we have a strong squad but one gaping hole up front if Maja is injured. Agree on Cole. From what I've seem the least he gives you is a bit of nuisance value. Surely you just give him a run out leading the line. How can we be any more impotent by playing him. Also takes Grant away from doing a job he must hate. Holgate had a good game, but then seemed to have z complete brain fart on the second goal which opened us right up. Some seem to disagree and have pointed the finger at TF so I need to look at the highlights (but dont want to cause we lost). |