RE: Syria - Mr Nimbus - 12-08-2024
(12-08-2024, 08:51 AM)Squid Wrote: (12-07-2024, 10:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Oh Dear. Something terrible is about to fill a vacuum.
More terrible than a narco-state regime which set fire to the country on purpose (Assad or we burn the country), caused the greatest refugee crisis this century (which had major consequences for Europe) and imprisoned, tortured and executed tens of thousands of its citizens, while also bombing schools and hospitals?
It's not my description, but 'East Germany with Hummus' was an apt description of Syrian life under Assad. Already there have been footage from some of the former intelligence buildings, stuffed full of files on Syria's citizens.
If you've been paying attention to what Syrians have been saying, one of the most notable things was the celebration of Syria's notorious prisons/gulags being opened. There are people who have been in there for 40 years. Others who have been kept so isolated they didn't even know that Hefez Al Assad (who died in 2000).
The opposition forces seized the opportunity to act while Russia and Iran were otherwise occupied. There had already been a massive deployment of Russian troops to Ukraine. That does not mean this is Western-backed. As for saying this was Western backed, especially considering the West under Obama left Assad in place. The West were trying to do deals with Assad to get him to break away from Iran and Hezbollah. Italy was actively trying to normalise with Assad.
The regime was widely despised. Some of the most persistent protests were by the Druze population in Suwayda.
Syria is a country with a lot of problems, but none of those problems would have been solved by the Assad regime. Tomorrow is uncertain, but today is a good day for Syrians.
Thanks Squid. Very useful perspective in trying to understand the situation.
RE: Syria - Gzbaggy - 12-08-2024
Will the Assad family be moving back to Acton?
RE: Syria - man in the corner shop - 12-08-2024
(12-08-2024, 10:37 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Will the Assad family be moving back to Acton?
Assad it before and I'll say it again. No.
RE: Syria - tHEgLASSdOORS - 12-08-2024
Great post squid. Good to see some real debate and knowledge rather than a superficial poke at Islam for the issue at hand.
RE: Syria - CarlosCorbewrong - 12-08-2024
(12-08-2024, 08:51 AM)Squid Wrote: (12-07-2024, 10:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Oh Dear. Something terrible is about to fill a vacuum.
More terrible than a narco-state regime which set fire to the country on purpose (Assad or we burn the country), caused the greatest refugee crisis this century (which had major consequences for Europe) and imprisoned, tortured and executed tens of thousands of its citizens, while also bombing schools and hospitals?
It's not my description, but 'East Germany with Hummus' was an apt description of Syrian life under Assad. Already there have been footage from some of the former intelligence buildings, stuffed full of files on Syria's citizens.
If you've been paying attention to what Syrians have been saying, one of the most notable things was the celebration of Syria's notorious prisons/gulags being opened. There are people who have been in there for 40 years. Others who have been kept so isolated they didn't even know that Hefez Al Assad (who died in 2000).
The opposition forces seized the opportunity to act while Russia and Iran were otherwise occupied. There had already been a massive deployment of Russian troops to Ukraine. That does not mean this is Western-backed. As for saying this was Western backed, especially considering the West under Obama left Assad in place. The West were trying to do deals with Assad to get him to break away from Iran and Hezbollah. Italy was actively trying to normalise with Assad.
The regime was widely despised. Some of the most persistent protests were by the Druze population in Suwayda.
Syria is a country with a lot of problems, but none of those problems would have been solved by the Assad regime. Tomorrow is uncertain, but today is a good day for Syrians.
Whilst you no doubt have offered more insight into the situation that others, I don't think you can ignore that this is highly likely to be a Western coup. Strategically it makes sense:
Weaken two enemies by distracting their forces
Install a puppet government through bribery leading to
Control of ports etc
Interesting what happens in Lebanon next...
RE: Syria - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-08-2024
The loss of naval bases will cause problems for Russia
RE: Syria - SW4Baggie - 12-08-2024
(12-08-2024, 08:51 AM)Squid Wrote: (12-07-2024, 10:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Oh Dear. Something terrible is about to fill a vacuum.
More terrible than a narco-state regime which set fire to the country on purpose (Assad or we burn the country), caused the greatest refugee crisis this century (which had major consequences for Europe) and imprisoned, tortured and executed tens of thousands of its citizens, while also bombing schools and hospitals?
It's not my description, but 'East Germany with Hummus' was an apt description of Syrian life under Assad. Already there have been footage from some of the former intelligence buildings, stuffed full of files on Syria's citizens.
If you've been paying attention to what Syrians have been saying, one of the most notable things was the celebration of Syria's notorious prisons/gulags being opened. There are people who have been in there for 40 years. Others who have been kept so isolated they didn't even know that Hefez Al Assad (who died in 2000).
The opposition forces seized the opportunity to act while Russia and Iran were otherwise occupied. There had already been a massive deployment of Russian troops to Ukraine. That does not mean this is Western-backed. As for saying this was Western backed, especially considering the West under Obama left Assad in place. The West were trying to do deals with Assad to get him to break away from Iran and Hezbollah. Italy was actively trying to normalise with Assad.
The regime was widely despised. Some of the most persistent protests were by the Druze population in Suwayda.
Syria is a country with a lot of problems, but none of those problems would have been solved by the Assad regime. Tomorrow is uncertain, but today is a good day for Syrians.
Excellent summary Squid - would also add that the ceasefire between Hezbollah and Israel (who’ve both been far from blameless in this whole sorry mess) was the natural opportunity for the rebels to strike.
Like so many nation states in that region, there will always be cultural, linguistic, religious and ethnocentric factors and identities that unite populations more strongly than a whole country and these groups all need representing in any government to have a chance of success, however democracy has rarely worked in the region, and Islamic communities prefer a strong leader over a coalition, so whilst the removal of Assad should be beneficial for Syrians given the decades of abuse the family have wrecked across the country, I fear it will only be a matter of time before all groups begin fighting again, separatist claims and speculative groups take hold whilst Western countries bury their heads in the sand and implement the kind of weak, puppet democracy that benefits no one but the contractors paid handsomely to rebuild the country.
RE: Syria - CarlosCorbewrong - 12-08-2024
War is an economy. Some people would rather invest in war machinery than bitcoin.
RE: Syria - man in the corner shop - 12-08-2024
(12-08-2024, 11:34 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: War is an economy. Some people would rather invest in war machinery than bitcoin.
War is good for capitalism
https://news.sky.com/story/ukraine-war-how-weapons-makers-are-profiting-from-the-conflict-12624574
RE: Syria - Protheroe - 12-08-2024
(12-08-2024, 11:07 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Great post squid. Good to see some real debate and knowledge rather than a superficial poke at Islam for the issue at hand.
Just watch what actually happens now. Syria is about to experience a new and exciting jackboot. There is no optimal outcome here. See Egypt, Iraq, Libya etc…
Think Lebanon, but bigger and nastier.
|