WBAUnofficial
Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? (/showthread.php?tid=35748)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - richbaggie - 11-27-2024

(11-27-2024, 11:27 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-27-2024, 11:03 AM)Any of our matches become richbaggie Wrote: Most of the negative opinions I see on social media are rarely backed up with any logic or thought.

"The recruitment is shocking" without taking into consideration that we are having to shop with a heavily reduced budget.

"We need to make better substitutions" despite the better players started the match and options are limited on the bench beyond those 1st 11.

"We need to sack the manager and coaching staff", who are all on pretty long contracts and we are still in danger of breaching financial rules.

The logic of making five subs at the same time every week regardless of what’s occurring on the pitch is a justified criticism of not only ourselves but most clubs in the Championship. If it’s about keeping players fit it is failing, if it’s about offering something different not necessarily better then it’s also failing. If it’s about keeping players from losing form / being jaded it’s failing. Many of our matches become completely disjointed non-events from 70 mins on. The logic behind this are the results we are currently achieving, injuries and form of players. 

Our squad is decent for the Championship not on a par perhaps with some recently relegated teams but the vast majority it stands up to comparison with. 

If performances, tactics and results were associated with say Pulis the clamour for him to be sacked on here would be a lot higher. Judge a manager by results and resources, currently I think CC is just about breaking even, certainly not over achieving as the now double digit run of draws started before our catalogue of injuries is testament to. 

I’m not calling for CC to be sacked it would be the wrong decision currently but no manager should have a free hit and I doubt the owners would agree either, there is room to question the orthodoxy of narrative on here that anyone who dares question CC is an idiotic heretic with a pitch fork in hand.

Nothing wrong in questioning things that clearly aren't right. Our passing, in general, is pretty poor. So many times last night we passed to players behind them meaning we got closed down too easily, our set plays are awful but overall he's got a squad that lacks guile and pace without a budget to make improvements.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - tHEgLASSdOORS - 11-27-2024

Aye, ball retention at times let’s us down very badly. As does picking the critical pass after a patient spell


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Mr Nimbus - 11-27-2024

He simply has a lot of credit in the bank with me, and has shown himself to be an outstanding organisational coach, still young in coaching years, learning and adapting to new situations.

This year, surely only a relegation fight would have put him at risk. We have turned around players for minimal fees whilst reducing the wage bill and his team remainins competitive. Players that some fans would gave discarded are now mainstays and he has two academy graduates in his first eleven.

There are questions. The reluctance to use Coal. Set piece goals. The use of 70 minute subs (although I get the logic) etc but there are much more positives than negatives.

All footballing relationships come to an end. But it doesnt feel anywhere near that with Carlos. There was lazy journalistic talk this week linking him with Leicester but I don't think he's there yet and they've just got rid of a pragmatic manager.

I think we get to the end of this year and review. My gut is that both he and the board will give it one more year.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - richbaggie - 11-27-2024

(11-27-2024, 11:57 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Aye, ball retention at times let’s us down very badly. As does picking the critical pass after a patient spell

We do create some of that problem by not breaking as a unit, good passing needs movement and we are very rigid.

However, sloppy passing, when under little pressure, is unforgivable and that's become too common of late.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - PatelsPlatoon - 11-27-2024

(11-27-2024, 10:55 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-27-2024, 10:41 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: That's how I'd sum us up at the minute.

Too many getting frustrated, but think we are weakened since last season and until we can open the wallet again this is as it is.

Get the home form improved slightly and still think we can make top 6, but if we do as well as last season we've done well.

The moaners who want CC out need to give their heads a wobble in light of our restrictions due to FFP, but they really don't get it.
Genuine question here PP, I don't necessarily disagree, other than I think you have justified the frustration highlighted in sentence 2 in sentence 3, whereby we need to improve at home and that is the frustration.

Question is though, regarding your final statement, does CC have a free hit this season, regardless, due to the circumstances you describe? If not, what would prompt a rethink?

1 win in 15 / 20 / 25? Flirting with relegation? 

As I said, this is a genuine question, to all those, including myself, who think that CC has something a bit different and we need to stick with him or regret it.
I don't even know my own answer. I would like to think I could offer the free-hit, but I'm not sure I have the patience for a long winless run, or a painful drop down the table.

I think only those at the top of the club really understand the constraints and it's also whether they believe CC has the capability of succeeding given the right tools.

I think he has a lot of good will in the bank and only a total collapse leading to a relegation struggle could see him in any threat, and that seems highly unlikely.

In short, we have to put up with it.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - BurleyBaggie - 11-27-2024

I think though you only have to look at who is missing:
- Diangana
- Bartley
- McNair
- Ajayi
- Dike

Three of those players are first XI, a forth Dike, who if ever was fit would walk into the the number 9 role.

If you add those players to the matchday squad it changes a lot. It enables Styles to potentially play more centrally or a wide forward (he is doing well where he is but it gives options), Having Heggem left back with Ajayi central enables us to have a much higher line and get more ball recoveries up the pitch (like at the start of the season) as three players in the 4 have recovery pace. Diangana gives options to carry the ball, his pace pushes defences back and creates space for others. Dike would free up Maja for the 10, add more presence and a different threat to say Grant. Dike being fit enales options for Grant to play across the front.

They are all significant contributions being lost which with our squad is having a huge offensive impact.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - HugeHons - 11-27-2024

In many of these draws we have created plenty but failed to hit the target. We have a strong front line Grant, Johnston, Maja and Fellows but aren’t sticking many chances away. We didn’t attack much at all last night but could have won it if Dobbin had hit the target. We are defending well and are well organised. For me is just a lack of clinical finishing. We’re not far away.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Tom Joad - 11-27-2024

(11-27-2024, 12:52 PM)HugeHons Wrote: In many of these draws we have created plenty but failed to hit the target. We have a strong front line Grant, Johnston, Maja and Fellows but aren’t sticking many chances away. We didn’t attack much at all last night but could have won it if Dobbin had hit the target. We are defending well and are well organised. For me is just a lack of clinical finishing. We’re not far away.

Exactly. In almost every home game we have started like a runaway train, except, the chances are either missed, the ball is given an extra pass and the move fizzles out. Against Norwich we scored two (ought to have been 3) before HT yet we didn't really do a lot different. No doubt if a few more go in our confidence will bloom.
Further and more in line with the OP.  we were bottom of the table when CC came so being pragmatic was the necessity. Then we had the turnover of staff during which once more, pragmatics is the short term aim. I enjoy watching an organised defence so appear to have far less of a problem than many.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Stillclem4england - 11-28-2024

(11-27-2024, 12:08 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-27-2024, 11:57 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Aye, ball retention at times let’s us down very badly. As does picking the critical pass after a patient spell

We do create some of that problem by not breaking as a unit, good passing needs movement and we are very rigid.

However, sloppy passing, when under little pressure, is unforgivable and that's become too common of late.
This is right Rich - we are too slow in getting bodies forward and by being obsessed with shape when it breaks down but the main issue is lack of pace. We have nobody other than Dobbin in the front six with any form of pace. We did superbly to get the average age down but didn’t address the lack of pace.

This is why teams find it easy to defend against us: double up on Tom and Mikey and, with Swift and Diangana badly off form, we will never threaten as we have no change of pace to break the low block.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - tHEgLASSdOORS - 11-28-2024

Agree with you both on all of that