WBAUnofficial
Assisted dying legislation. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Assisted dying legislation. (/showthread.php?tid=35636)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - Squid - 11-12-2024

I get why people want it, but a right to die will swiftly become a duty to die. There are some very worrying stories emerging from Canada.

This website is a worthwhile read:

https://notdeadyetuk.co.uk/


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - Pontificator - 11-12-2024

The psychopath Harold Shipman has a lot to answer for. DRs would hasten the death of a terminally ill patient in terrible pain not with the intention of killing them but in the full knowledge that relieving suffering with drugs would shorten life. I believe they still do this btw, I think I have witnesssed it. I can't imagine the discussion that would take place beween two doctors, the relatives, a judge and the patient. Absurd. I asked the Dr how long will she live when I was told she was dying - he said I don't know but she's dying, she lived another 4 months.
I just can't go along with this. "Barbara Rich, a well-known lawyer stated “Assisted dying” is a euphemism which puts one person’s role in intentionally ending another’s life in a benign and positive light. It obscures the truth that a law enabling it would profoundly shift the boundary of exculpation for responsibility for the death of another person”


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - tHEgLASSdOORS - 11-12-2024

We’ve created a society where people are kept alive often well beyond what nature would’ve ordinarily enabled and alongside that come many complications, burdens, misery and stress that goes well beyond just the individual concerned. We have to be brave enough to evolve what goes alongside that and as many have said it is long overdue


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - Morley - 11-12-2024

(11-12-2024, 09:51 AM)Squid Wrote: I get why people want it, but a right to die will swiftly become a duty to die. There are some very worrying stories emerging from Canada.

This website is a worthwhile read:

https://notdeadyetuk.co.uk/

Agree with this, while the idea is noble we all know that people find ways around rules and things get twisted into something that was never intended.  
Some people will be pressured into ending their lives when they don't want to if this legislation is passed.


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - Borin' Baggie - 11-12-2024

Having watched my nan suffer for absolutely no reason for 6 months after breast cancer spread to her bones before spending another month being a vegetable in hospital I'm in favour.

My childhood dog had more dignity when she passed away.


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - Vinebaggie - 11-12-2024

This is all a bit raw for me given the horrendous painful end of life experience my Mom had, sufficient to say I really hope this bill is passed.


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - man in the corner shop - 11-12-2024

We treat dying cats and dogs better than we do humans- said Esther Rantzen. I'm with her 100%. People should be given the dignity to be able to decide when they want to go.


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - Fido - 11-12-2024

(11-12-2024, 10:13 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: We’ve created a society where people are kept alive often well beyond what nature would’ve ordinarily enabled and alongside that come many complications, burdens, misery and stress that goes well beyond just the individual concerned. We have to be brave enough to evolve what goes alongside that and as many have said it is long overdue

I agree. 

I would also say that at some point in the future, with ever aging populations and slow birth rates that nations won't be able to afford to look after everyone. It probably will happen. I'm definitely one who thinks that if my life eventually becomes worthless by my reckoning and I've just had enough I would want the plug pulled to alleviate people having to care for me be it financially or otherwise. This is definitely a leap on from those who are "end of life" but it's something that will need to be considered.


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - Josh1873 - 11-12-2024

(11-12-2024, 09:56 AM)Pontificator Wrote: The psychopath Harold Shipman has a lot to answer for. DRs would hasten the death of a terminally ill patient in terrible pain not with the intention of killing them but in the full knowledge that relieving suffering with drugs would shorten life. I believe they still do this btw, I think I have witnesssed it. I can't imagine the discussion that would take place beween two doctors, the relatives, a judge and the patient. Absurd. I asked the Dr how long will she live when I was told she was dying - he said I don't know but she's dying, she lived another 4 months.
I just can't go along with this. "Barbara Rich, a well-known lawyer stated “Assisted dying” is a euphemism which puts one person’s role in intentionally ending another’s life in a benign and positive light. It obscures the truth that a law enabling it would profoundly shift the boundary of exculpation for responsibility for the death of another person”

I don't know the ins and outs of it, but the Mrs' nan wasn't terminally ill, but was into her 90's and was basically at the end of life. She was in so much pain, the Drs pumped her with so much morphine which is what ultimately ended her life. But Mr's mom and the nan had to beg and beg for more pain relief. I'm not sure if that's the kind of thing that you're referring to. 

The nan was in pain for weeks, btw. Once it came clear she didn't have long left all parties wanted it to end. But instead she had to continue suffering in immense pain. She was sound of mind despite her condition and age. 

The process of ending life will always be a grey area with no easy solution, but the situation I saw my GF and her mom go through, as well as her nan, should never be allowed to happen. I was sent WhatsApp voice notes of her nan screaming in pain for minutes on end, constantly. It was absolutely harrowing. 

You wouldn't, rightfully so, put a dog or pet through that. Why the hell do we accept it with humans? 

Sorry, I went off on a bit of a rant there.


RE: Assisted dying legislation. - MrBater - 11-12-2024

I'm totally for it as long as the person has signed something to make their agreement clear when they had the faculties to do do

For the avoidance of any doubt, this is me signing to say I want it if I should end up relying on machines etc... just to 'live'