WBAUnofficial
"He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" (/showthread.php?tid=35604)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - SW4Baggie - 11-09-2024

(11-09-2024, 01:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I see this argument quite a lot, not just by our fans, but across the footballing community. In all leagues and at most levels. 

Not sure why, though, we changed shape at least twice on Thursday night in that game alone. 

We started with a 433 with 2 wide men high and wide trying to get in behind, with Swift playing that deeper role that he did so well the first few games. Then when Luton starting dropping deeper we moved to a a 442/352 type shape when we made the subs with KG going high and narrow as an almost wide forward and MJ going narrow on the left. 

We then went 3421 when Grady and MJ played as 2 #10s behind Maja/Cole for the last 10/15 mins. 

I know people want to see the sub board go up and a clear and almost telegraphed change of shape with 2 strikers coming on for a midfielder and fullback. But i don't think that really happens untill the final frows of a game as all team structure and tactical work out in goes out the window. Not there's not a time for chucking the kitchen white good at a game of course. 

I've seen it on a post on another Fred today and it is bob on. We are still short of different options. We lack a CM who is a goal threat/runner and we lack a CF option. That does hamstring a coach somewhat, but the job of restructuring the squad was a tough one. Let's hope Cole is finding his fitness and starting to earn CCs trust a little more as a second CF option is vital.

This is an excellent post Lurker, and one which outlines why I’m still very pro-Carlos.

As a team there are very few better set up than us, and very few better prepared to change in game. We are incredibly well drilled and the vast majority of players have seen their game improve with time working with him and his team. This does not happen accidentally.

However I’m starting to feel CC prefers to focus on how he prevents the opposition playing rather than how to impose his style on the opposition. His time as a manager both with us and Huddersfield has seen him working with limited options and having to make the best of what’s available. This season is arguably the first time he’s had a squad he’s had a big say in the assembly of and has some real quality and is struggling to get the best out of it. 

If anything we just look “over coached” - CC reduces the margin of error in games
To the absolute minimum and relies on one or two moments to snatch a win. This has served him very well until now, and he seems torn between sticking to what he believes and loosening the reins a little.

He has all the ability to make this side successful, but this is a huge test for him.

…if this post is a little rambling I’ve drank quite a lot of vermouth


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Birdman1811 - 11-09-2024

(11-09-2024, 08:49 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-09-2024, 01:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I see this argument quite a lot, not just by our fans, but across the footballing community. In all leagues and at most levels. 

Not sure why, though, we changed shape at least twice on Thursday night in that game alone. 

We started with a 433 with 2 wide men high and wide trying to get in behind, with Swift playing that deeper role that he did so well the first few games. Then when Luton starting dropping deeper we moved to a a 442/352 type shape when we made the subs with KG going high and narrow as an almost wide forward and MJ going narrow on the left. 

We then went 3421 when Grady and MJ played as 2 #10s behind Maja/Cole for the last 10/15 mins. 

I know people want to see the sub board go up and a clear and almost telegraphed change of shape with 2 strikers coming on for a midfielder and fullback. But i don't think that really happens untill the final frows of a game as all team structure and tactical work out in goes out the window. Not there's not a time for chucking the kitchen white good at a game of course. 

I've seen it on a post on another Fred today and it is bob on. We are still short of different options. We lack a CM who is a goal threat/runner and we lack a CF option. That does hamstring a coach somewhat, but the job of restructuring the squad was a tough one. Let's hope Cole is finding his fitness and starting to earn CCs trust a little more as a second CF option is vital.

This is an excellent post Lurker, and one which outlines why I’m still very pro-Carlos.

As a team there are very few better set up than us, and very few better prepared to change in game. We are incredibly well drilled and the vast majority of players have seen their game improve with time working with him and his team. This does not happen accidentally.

However I’m starting to feel CC prefers to focus on how he prevents the opposition playing rather than how to impose his style on the opposition. His time as a manager both with us and Huddersfield has seen him working with limited options and having to make the best of what’s available. This season is arguably the first time he’s had a squad he’s had a big say in the assembly of and has some real quality and is struggling to get the best out of it. 

If anything we just look “over coached” - CC reduces the margin of error in games
To the absolute minimum and relies on one or two moments to snatch a win. This has served him very well until now, and he seems torn between sticking to what he believes and loosening the reins a little.

He has all the ability to make this side successful, but this is a huge test for him.

…if this post is a little rambling I’ve drank quite a lot of vermouth

After several beers, I understand and agree with you.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Lurker#3 - 11-10-2024

[attachment=976]

Clear change of shape today, with the 442/433 hybrid. Think there could be value in that Grant/Maja combo. 

Especially if MJ can carry that first half performance into the games after the break. We just need Swift/Grady/Fellows to conjure up some form now and we won't be too far away from getting some consistency.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Sliced - 11-10-2024

I think the main difference today was Mikey being able to beat a man, which he hasn’t done at all since he came back. Happy with the result. It’s always good to win when confidence is low


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - BurleyBaggie - 11-10-2024

As per my other posts I never thought the shape of the team was the issue, it was more having attacking players out of form.

I advocated for Cole in the 9 but moving Grant centrally and Mikey left made a big difference first half.

I believed one win would change the whole dynamic and I believe that even more today. Hull had 2 extra days prep and recovery but we stayed immensely strong was a makeshift back 4. That can’t be sniffed at.

We finished the game with a defensive midfielder and a right back in a 3, but hung on. That kinda character and effort gets you a long way in the championship.

(11-10-2024, 04:54 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Clear change of shape today, with the 442/433 hybrid. Think there could be value in that Grant/Maja combo. 

Especially if MJ can carry that first half performance into the games after the break. We just need Swift/Grady/Fellows to conjure up some form now and we won't be too far away from getting some consistency.

Not really as Maja played the 10 and Grant the 9. There was interchange between Mikey and Grant but there was nothing really new.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Lurker#3 - 11-10-2024

(11-10-2024, 06:30 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: As per my other posts I never thought the shape of the team was the issue, it was more having attacking players out of form.

I advocated for Cole in the 9 but moving Grant centrally and Mikey left made a big difference first half.

I believed one win would change the whole dynamic and I believe that even more today. Hull had 2 extra days prep and recovery but we stayed immensely strong was a makeshift back 4. That can’t be sniffed at.

We finished the game with a defensive midfielder and a right back in a 3, but hung on. That kinda character and effort gets you a long way in the championship.

(11-10-2024, 04:54 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Clear change of shape today, with the 442/433 hybrid. Think there could be value in that Grant/Maja combo. 

Especially if MJ can carry that first half performance into the games after the break. We just need Swift/Grady/Fellows to conjure up some form now and we won't be too far away from getting some consistency.

Not really as Maja played the 10 and Grant the 9. There was interchange between Mikey and Grant but there was nothing really new.

As the average positions show, you could throw a blanket over Maja and Grant. They were very much a front 2. Styles also had a much higher average position on the left hand side with Furlong tucked in. MJ also played and picked the ball up much deeper and narrower than he has so far in his career with us. 

There was a clear shape/approach shift, mate. 

I agree the link up play between MJ and the front players was much better than we've seen in recent weeks, though.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - BurleyBaggie - 11-10-2024

I get your point to a degree. It’s still a 4231 and we do adjust average positions game to game.

My point is more that we don’t need to make wholesale change but more adapt personnel and play to their strengths.

From my view on the half way line (I was in their ‘hospitality’) the big change was going 5 at the back in the last 10 minutes with Diakite dropping in.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Lurker#3 - 11-10-2024

(11-10-2024, 07:11 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: I get your point to a degree. It’s still a 4231 and we do adjust average positions game to game.

My point is more that we don’t need to make wholesale change but more adapt personnel and play to their strengths.

From my view on the half way line (I was in their ‘hospitality’) the big change was going 5 at the back in the last 10 minutes with Diakite dropping in.

To be honest I think it was a back 8 in the last 10 mins  Big Grin

But after our winless run, it had to be by any means necessary!


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Stillclem4england - 11-10-2024

(11-09-2024, 01:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I see this argument quite a lot, not just by our fans, but across the footballing community. In all leagues and at most levels. 

Not sure why, though, we changed shape at least twice on Thursday night in that game alone. 

We started with a 433 with 2 wide men high and wide trying to get in behind, with Swift playing that deeper role that he did so well the first few games. Then when Luton starting dropping deeper we moved to a a 442/352 type shape when we made the subs with KG going high and narrow as an almost wide forward and MJ going narrow on the left. 

We then went 3421 when Grady and MJ played as 2 #10s behind Maja/Cole for the last 10/15 mins. 

I know people want to see the sub board go up and a clear and almost telegraphed change of shape with 2 strikers coming on for a midfielder and fullback. But i don't think that really happens untill the final frows of a game as all team structure and tactical work out in goes out the window. Not there's not a time for chucking the kitchen white good at a game of course. 

I've seen it on a post on another Fred today and it is bob on. We are still short of different options. We lack a CM who is a goal threat/runner and we lack a CF option. That does hamstring a coach somewhat, but the job of restructuring the squad was a tough one. Let's hope Cole is finding his fitness and starting to earn CCs trust a little more as a second CF option is vital.
Not taking the piss here Lurker or having a go, but how on earth can you deduce that from TV? If I’m in the stadium I can unless low down but on TV?


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - CA Baggie - 11-10-2024

(11-10-2024, 06:46 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-10-2024, 06:30 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: As per my other posts I never thought the shape of the team was the issue, it was more having attacking players out of form.

I advocated for Cole in the 9 but moving Grant centrally and Mikey left made a big difference first half.

I believed one win would change the whole dynamic and I believe that even more today. Hull had 2 extra days prep and recovery but we stayed immensely strong was a makeshift back 4. That can’t be sniffed at.

We finished the game with a defensive midfielder and a right back in a 3, but hung on. That kinda character and effort gets you a long way in the championship.

(11-10-2024, 04:54 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Clear change of shape today, with the 442/433 hybrid. Think there could be value in that Grant/Maja combo. 

Especially if MJ can carry that first half performance into the games after the break. We just need Swift/Grady/Fellows to conjure up some form now and we won't be too far away from getting some consistency.

Not really as Maja played the 10 and Grant the 9. There was interchange between Mikey and Grant but there was nothing really new.

As the average positions show, you could throw a blanket over Maja and Grant. They were very much a front 2. Styles also had a much higher average position on the left hand side with Furlong tucked in. MJ also played and picked the ball up much deeper and narrower than he has so far in his career with us. 

There was a clear shape/approach shift, mate. 

I agree the link up play between MJ and the front players was much better than we've seen in recent weeks, though.
Furlong often does the pushed up role, in particular when Fellows played, he rarely seems to do it with Wallace in front of him.

I guess that CC has swapped it on the basis that Furlong is better in the remaining defensive 3, whereas when Heggem played he was more than comfortable tucked in.  It’s important as that stops us getting overrun with just 2 in midfield.

It was nice to see something slightly different from he off,  it sure if that unsettled Hull as they wouldn’t have expected that.