![]() |
|
xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? (/showthread.php?tid=35493) |
RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-29-2024 (10-29-2024, 12:21 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's useful for analysing the proportion of chances a team is creating but ultimately if you focus too much on it you will obsess over trying to create the "perfect chance" instead of just shooting, and other than Maja (and even he missed a high-xG chance on Saturday) I don't think we have anyone clinical or decisive enough to put the ball in the net from high-xG chances. Teams that do well always outperform their xG, you can see that in the table for us this season. That's exactly what I said in the ground when he missed it. Let the players play, and give them some freedom to express themselves. Our play is too laboured by the framework they have to work within. RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Derek Hardballs - 10-29-2024 It’s just one statistic that cannot be used in isolation from a wider understanding of the game including the cautionary use of stats. I do find the preoccupation with stats a very binary way of judging a game played by humans and the randomness that, that brings to any situation. I think it has perpetuated a almost algorithmic approach to the game, where teams play the same way, don’t adapt in real time and instead stick to plans no matter what is happening in front of them. Stats have their place as does sports science, medicine, psychology etc but they have to be used holistically and no amount of pointing to ‘look at our xG stats’ as some kind of vindication when the team has been on a poor run is going to make the points table look any better. A decent coach/manager will know the strengths and weakness of his players, they may use stats to confirm it’s not bias on their part, but when it stats start to dictate tactics and distill the game down to getting the ball into certain areas as quickly as possible or holding onto the ball as long as possible so as to not concede, you may as well let AI have a roight gud goo! RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Lurker#3 - 10-29-2024 (10-29-2024, 11:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(10-29-2024, 11:15 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like all stats, it's useful when used with other stats properly to build up a picture, on its own it's not worth a lot. First 6 - We had 14 chances above 0.2xG and scored 11 goals. Total xG - 10.4 Following 6 - We had 4 chances above 0.2xg and scored 3 goals. Total xG - 5.8 Not really Shabby - In fact we probably missed a few good chances in the first few games according to the xG ratings for each shot. But by and large we were about on the mark. Our average xG/goal this year is 0.28. RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Derek Hardballs - 10-29-2024 (10-29-2024, 12:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(10-29-2024, 11:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(10-29-2024, 11:15 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like all stats, it's useful when used with other stats properly to build up a picture, on its own it's not worth a lot. Well when you say it like that, I am left wondering who gives a shit
RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-29-2024 (10-29-2024, 12:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(10-29-2024, 11:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(10-29-2024, 11:15 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like all stats, it's useful when used with other stats properly to build up a picture, on its own it's not worth a lot. Well it's written in English, but I can't say I understand it
RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - yeoman lai - 10-29-2024 I know what Cloughie would have done with xg.
RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-29-2024 (10-29-2024, 12:56 PM)yeoman lai Wrote: I know what Cloughie would have done with xg. Ain't that the truth of modern football.
RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Lurker#3 - 10-29-2024 (10-29-2024, 12:21 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Teams that do well always outperform their xG, you can see that in the table for us this season. Not necessarily BB. Teams who have outscored their xG this year are (and position in the league): Sunderland (1st) Burnley (3rd) Blackburn (6th) Norwich (8th) Derby (12th) Oxford (14th) Plymouth (21st) Last season the three promotes teams; Leicester, Southampton and Ipswich. Only Ipswich massive outscored their xG and we're top in that metric. Leicester were 11th and Southampton were 9th, both with marginal goals/xG outscores. The best teams tend to have high xG scores but score when they should. RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Borin' Baggie - 10-29-2024 (10-29-2024, 01:02 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(10-29-2024, 12:21 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Teams that do well always outperform their xG, you can see that in the table for us this season. I'd counter that by saying that besides all of those teams, aside from Burnley, are higher than their pre-season expectations. And last season Ipswich were the ones who did well relative to where they were expected, Southampton and Leicester met expectations (and Leeds fell below theirs). RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Lurker#3 - 10-29-2024 (10-29-2024, 12:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s just one statistic that cannot be used in isolation from a wider understanding of the game including the cautionary use of stats. I do find the preoccupation with stats a very binary way of judging a game played by humans and the randomness that, that brings to any situation. I think it has perpetuated a almost algorithmic approach to the game, where teams play the same way, don’t adapt in real time and instead stick to plans no matter what is happening in front of them. FWIW - I completely agree with most of that. Apart from the bit in bold. Sometimes the stats can point to performances being consistently better than results, as a team. However it is vital to then hammer down in the finer details as to why the team performances are not translating to results. In these cases it is usually personnel on the pitch not doing their jobs right. What I do love looking for in the stats is logic and reason to explain sequences of results. As I try to avoid the mindless clichés that many parrott. For us, our form has taken a bit of a nose dive. But it has been a very managed decline which is typical of CC. We had 2 games where defensively we were not dominant (Sheff Wed and Boro) and we lost both. So we went back to basics and got that sorted and our expected xG against has been back under 1 since we've been 4 games unbeaten. Now the challenge is to start creating more of those good (xG>0.2) chances. Signs were positive against Blackburn in terms of our attacking stats away from the penalty area and final pass. Then against Cardiff the stats were much more akin to those at the start of year. Now we just need to start taking good chances again. (10-29-2024, 01:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(10-29-2024, 01:02 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(10-29-2024, 12:21 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Teams that do well always outperform their xG, you can see that in the table for us this season. Completely agree, BB. The teams that tend to shock everyone tend to out perform their xG. Luton did the year before also. Its just not sustainable, and I wouldn't take any great comfort from us being one of those teams because 9/10 it falls away. |