![]() |
|
Starmer to talk sense? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Starmer to talk sense? (/showthread.php?tid=35483) |
RE: Starmer to talk sense? - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-28-2024 (10-28-2024, 04:26 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Can someone draw me a diagram of how "raising taxes is going to prevent austerity"? Well it certainly isn't going to grow the economy. In 4 years time FGK and the Deputy PM will still be blaming the previous Government. RE: Starmer to talk sense? - baggy1 - 10-28-2024 A subtle difference between raising bus fairs and raising the cap therefore reducing the amount bus companies are subsidised. And it doesn’t appear you’ll be taxed any more than you are now. RE: Starmer to talk sense? - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-28-2024 (10-28-2024, 04:43 PM)baggy1 Wrote: A subtle difference between raising bus fairs and raising the cap therefore reducing the amount bus companies are subsidised. And it doesn’t appear you’ll be taxed any more than you are now. It will still cost anyone using a bus 50% more. They aren't bothered who pays for it. I will be taxed more. There is fiscal drag on allowances (critiscised by Thieves previously), Fuel duty is going up for the first time in 14.5 years (Tories actually reduced it), CGT will go up (I'm sorry I've accumulated some assets through hard work), Employers NI is going up, and there will be the usual sting on booze and fags. I'm sure there will be a gouge on pensions as well. Please explain to me how this means I won't be taxed any more than I am now? RE: Starmer to talk sense? - Protheroe - 10-28-2024 (10-28-2024, 03:51 PM)baggy1 Wrote: As will be confirmed by the OBR the facts of how big the hole is was not known. Hunt claiming interference is laughable when he’s basically going to be shown up for the lies he tells this week. No inclusion of so many items including nothing for the Post Office or the blood infection scandals, let alone the real spending items will be telling. I like "Grown Ups" to be consistent in their messaging. The only thing consistent about Starmer is his inconsistency. The "fully costed " Manifesto has been completely jettisoned in favour of a fully costed Autumn Statement calling for 4 times as much in tax increases and / or spending cuts. A policy agenda that was "laser-focused" on growth has cut many projects, reannounced a few and seems set to apply growth killing tax increases. A Chancellor who said in March that "The UK has changed its fiscal rules more frequently than any other OECD economy, with the average lifespan of less than four years. That has contributed to instability and uncertainty. So I will end the practice of the Chancellor being able to scrap the rules at any time" is immediately changing the Fiscal Rules. Forgive me, but if a grown up adopted that headspinning approach to parenting you might well be on the phone to Social Services. RE: Starmer to talk sense? - baggy1 - 10-28-2024 BB has explained to you enough times and the OBR will be spelling it out this week, the basis for the manifesto was flawed because Hunt simply lied about the black hole. They’ve got that used to lying that they think they could just keep doing it without consequence. RE: Starmer to talk sense? - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-28-2024 (10-28-2024, 05:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: BB has explained to you enough times and the OBR will be spelling it out this week, the basis for the manifesto was flawed because Hunt simply lied about the black hole. They’ve got that used to lying that they think they could just keep doing it without consequence. And they all lived happily ever after. The OBR numbers were available before the election, and the wage rises given created £10bn of the so called hole. I'll believe my own view, not this jackanory, thank you very much. RE: Starmer to talk sense? - Protheroe - 10-28-2024 (10-28-2024, 05:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: BB has explained to you enough times and the OBR will be spelling it out this week, the basis for the manifesto was flawed because Hunt simply lied about the black hole. They’ve got that used to lying that they think they could just keep doing it without consequence. Yet the IFS highlighted that £19bn tax increases / spending cuts baked into the Tories published spending plans to anyone who'd listen over and over again. Neither party engaged with this at all during the election campaign - Labour were asked time after time on Radio 4 about this. Of the Hunt Black Hole we've already done this to death FFS. I have no issue with paying £9.4bn in pay rises / back pay if you secure something in return, yet the table is bare. It's an insult to the employers you're going to lean on to be more efficient to load the public sectors' mouths with gold when productivity in the public sector has been flatlining for years (and plunging in the NHS). Labour will crow about the latter in an attempt to cover up their duplicity in the former. We all knew about the former (apart from you apparently) so there's no debate about it. It amply demonstrates the Manifesto was a work of fiction. RE: Starmer to talk sense? - man in the corner shop - 10-28-2024 (10-28-2024, 05:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: BB has explained to you enough times and the OBR will be spelling it out this week, the basis for the manifesto was flawed because Hunt simply lied about the black hole. They’ve got that used to lying that they think they could just keep doing it without consequence. Tbh it would be hard to spot the truths that they told during those 14 years RE: Starmer to talk sense? - Borin' Baggie - 10-28-2024 (10-28-2024, 04:26 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Can someone draw me a diagram of how "raising taxes is going to prevent austerity"? It is austerity, they're just being dishonest in defining it. Austerity is the raising of taxes and/or (emphasis on the or) cutting of spending for the purpose of reducing the deficit. RE: Starmer to talk sense? - Everything Zin - 10-28-2024 (10-28-2024, 04:26 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Can someone draw me a diagram of how "raising taxes is going to prevent austerity"? Starmer's just creating another economic miracle to match Brown's "elimination of boom and bust". To be fair, when he talked about growth pre-election, he never actually said what was going to grow. People assumed he meant the economy rather than tax, unemployment, business closures..... |