WBAUnofficial
FFP - the future? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: FFP - the future? (/showthread.php?tid=3490)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: FFP - the future? - GMBaggie - 04-26-2019

Ask Derek he'll explain it to you.


RE: FFP - the future? - Tom Joad - 04-27-2019

Great post Prag. So it seems FFP is toothless. That must leave Blues and QPR seething. It certainly should be either scrapped or enforced. It is as though there is a return to the days when anyone with money could put as much as they wanted into a club (i.e. Blackburn, Leeds, Pompey), and walk away when it goes wrong. There are still plenty of clubs getting into problems so FFP hasn't prevented that. The exception only kicks in when the top 6 are threatened with an upstart buying their way in.


RE: FFP - the future? - steviedm - 04-27-2019

(04-27-2019, 09:29 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Great post Prag.   So it seems FFP is toothless. That must leave Blues and QPR seething. It certainly should be either scrapped or enforced. It is as though there is a return to the days when anyone with money could put as much as they wanted into a club (i.e. Blackburn, Leeds, Pompey), and walk away when it goes wrong. There are still plenty of clubs getting into problems so FFP hasn't prevented that. The exception only kicks in when the top 6 are threatened with an upstart buying their way in.

This is an interesting article regarding the top six: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/26/sports/premier-league-liverpool-manchester-city.html

I find it disappointing and it's an articulate way of explaining why I can't get excited about the play-offs and nowadays feel empty generally about professional football.

Anyway, I'm off to watch Havant and Waterlooville in a bit - that'll cheer me up. Relegated games ago but a bunch of hard-working, part-time lads who give their all. Up the Hawks.


RE: FFP - the future? - Stig of the Dump - 04-30-2019

More cash injected into the vile

https://twitter.com/kieranmaguire/status/1123201700700073984?s=12

It looks as if the Aston Villa owners have injected another £22 million of cash into the club’s parent company Recon Group UK via a share issue


RE: FFP - the future? - Pipkins - 04-30-2019

(04-26-2019, 01:48 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
(04-26-2019, 01:07 PM)Black penny Wrote: For us the future looks bleak, under the current regime we will receive NO backing from our owner. Most Championship clubs get £20 million on average to keep them afloat - some of which is generated via sales. Other clubs rely on wealthy owners. Where does that leave us?

I've said for years FFP rules are rubbish and us abiding by them was an excuse not to spend money. We don't need any excuses now because we ain't got any.

Exactly, that was a great excuse for not investing or showing any long term ambitions.
Hence why many of us were so critical of the Peace regime as the club seemed to have no ambition or goals only Peace’s ambition and goals - no surprise then we have almost ended up where we began 20 years ago.
Failure to get up this season really dooms us to a pretty poor future.

What really annoys is the we never really had a positive go at that Prem level; never really had a great season to remember - no Final appearances, no Euro trips and no real forward momentum.
Never allowed to dream like most similar clubs of our size after take overs.
Incredibly, the fan base slightly diminished as did the stadium in those years ! Incredible!

Excellent post 
Have been saying this for years
We had our chance & Peace decided on his interests & not the clubs


RE: FFP - the future? - fuzzbox - 04-30-2019

I got into a nasty argument with someone about FFP last season, so chose to steer clear of the debate ever since. (I notice the other person involved is also no longer commenting, I wonder why...)

My view hasn't changed. unless there is a real will to enforce FFP, then it was always bound to fail. From the very start the language was left 'loose' and the punishments 'open to negotiation'. I believe this was because there was never really a 100% commitment to enforce the rules if it was vociferously challenged or the consequences of a strict interpretation were too dire for a club.

This has led to continual compromises and 'interpretations' which have continually watered down the value of the rule.

I like  the OP idea. It safeguards 'smaller' clubs and gives aspiring clubs a chance to rise in the leagues. Of course, its debatable whether the established clubs would want this change as it will mean they would also have to spend money to keep up with the 'new money'


RE: FFP - the future? - Baggiejacko - 04-30-2019

(04-30-2019, 01:47 PM)Pipkins Wrote:
(04-26-2019, 01:48 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
(04-26-2019, 01:07 PM)Black penny Wrote: For us the future looks bleak, under the current regime we will receive NO backing from our owner. Most Championship clubs get £20 million on average to keep them afloat - some of which is generated via sales. Other clubs rely on wealthy owners. Where does that leave us?

I've said for years FFP rules are rubbish and us abiding by them was an excuse not to spend money. We don't need any excuses now because we ain't got any.

Exactly, that was a great excuse for not investing or showing any long term ambitions.
Hence why many of us were so critical of the Peace regime as the club seemed to have no ambition or goals only Peace’s ambition and goals - no surprise then we have almost ended up where we began 20 years ago.
Failure to get up this season really dooms us to a pretty poor future.

What really annoys is the we never really had a positive go at that Prem level; never really had a great season to remember - no Final appearances, no Euro trips and no real forward momentum.
Never allowed to dream like most similar clubs of our size after take overs.
Incredibly, the fan base slightly diminished as did the stadium in those years ! Incredible!

Excellent post 
Have been saying this for years
We had our chance & Peace decided on his interests & not the clubs
Then you've been talking nonsense for years. Peace didn't make any big money till he sold the club. Majority of the earnings went into transfer fees and salaries.


RE: FFP - the future? - fuzzbox - 04-30-2019

(04-30-2019, 02:18 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Then you've been talking nonsense for years. Peace didn't make any big money till he sold the club. Majority of the earnings went into transfer fees and salaries.

I'm pretty sure he did. He took a fair amount for salary and more importantly, due to his own management 'initiatives', he increased his shareholding significantly for a very reasonable price!


RE: FFP - the future? - Baggiejacko - 04-30-2019

(04-30-2019, 02:23 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-30-2019, 02:18 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Then you've been talking nonsense for years. Peace didn't make any big money till he sold the club. Majority of the earnings went into transfer fees and salaries.

I'm pretty sure he did. He took a fair amount for salary and more importantly, due to his own management 'initiatives', he increased his shareholding significantly for a very reasonable price!
He earned less salary than some of the players. Did you expect him to work for free and give it away at the end? You can demonise him all you like but he took the club forward light years. He reaped his rewards at the end but who can blame him?


RE: FFP - the future? - fuzzbox - 05-01-2019

(04-30-2019, 02:44 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(04-30-2019, 02:23 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-30-2019, 02:18 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Then you've been talking nonsense for years. Peace didn't make any big money till he sold the club. Majority of the earnings went into transfer fees and salaries.

I'm pretty sure he did. He took a fair amount for salary and more importantly, due to his own management 'initiatives', he increased his shareholding significantly for a very reasonable price!
He earned less salary than some of the players. Did you expect him to work for free and give it away at the end? You can demonise him all you like but he took the club forward light years. He reaped his rewards at the end but who can blame him?

I'm not demonising him. I'm just pointing out that he did, in fact, make big money (and far more than any of our players, as it happens..) out of the club before he sold it.

FWIW, I met him and his wife, purely coincidentally, on holiday. I only spoke to him for about 5 minutes, but he seemed nice enough and very open. It was around the time of the first chinese 'sale'. Having said that, I must have bored the tits off him, because he went upstairs to bed and left his wife dancing by herself!