RE: Reginald D Hunter - PatelsPlatoon - 08-27-2024
(08-27-2024, 04:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-21-2024, 02:31 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Saw David Baddiel apologising profusely, in a quite uncomfortable way, recently for blacking his face for doing an impression of Jason Lee back in the Fantasy Football League days.
Maybe I've got it wrong, but wasn't it to do so he looks like a black footballer, in the same way if he was doing an impression of Ed Sheeran he'd don a ginger wig?
It's clear a 30 year old comedy sketch got twisted to find a new level of sinister insult to do with black oppression, by some overly sensitive types-probably white Guardian readers.
Only a complete moron who is looking to take offence could see it in such a twisted light.
This is what we are dealing with now.
Black, white, Jewish- it's comedy and poking fun. Sadly common sense isn't that common.
Sorry but you can’t compare poking fun at ginger people in the same way you do Jews and persons or colour. The historical treatment of these groups is entirely different to that of having ginger hair, so yes, you have got it completely wrong lad.
What Baddiel did was as wrong 30 years ago as it is now, however the people who would have been offended then now have more channels through which to feel comfortable and empowered to call out the wrongdoing.
I don’t think comedians or celebrities should be cancelled now due to something they’ve done 30 years ago which within the context of the time wasn’t called out as wrong, but there’s no harm in acknowledging you did something wrong and saying you’re sorry for it.
I beg to differ. Yes you can do what he did and it's all about intent. Dressing up singing Mammy like Al Jolson in character as an oppressed American black cotton picker is a completely different thing to pretending to be a rich footballer in a different country in a different time and who just shares in common that he is black. It's all about context.
I would doubt that the vast majority of black people laughing at that sketch in the mid 90s had an idea of the blacking up row. It was an innocent joke and seeing it any other way is bizarre and a little bit aloof. The only thing his impression has in common with racially segregated America is its an impression of someone of a different skin colour.
No offence was intended and the intolerant 25 years after reframe it and make him apologise for the good of his career. It's a very strange train of thought, by overly serious well-meaning people.
It is all very odd and oh so Guardian, yet it's now the way it is and why we can't actually debate serious issues intelligently as some called it 'racism.' That kind of ends most conversations.
RE: Reginald D Hunter - CarlosCorbewrong - 08-27-2024
I'm going to break character here: Baddiel has been forced into an apology by Corbynista Internet bullies. They hated DB calling out antisemitism and, to a very large degree did some classic whataboutery. I wholeheartedly believe that to be the case...
RE: Reginald D Hunter - SW4Baggie - 08-28-2024
(08-27-2024, 08:21 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: (08-27-2024, 04:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-21-2024, 02:31 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Saw David Baddiel apologising profusely, in a quite uncomfortable way, recently for blacking his face for doing an impression of Jason Lee back in the Fantasy Football League days.
Maybe I've got it wrong, but wasn't it to do so he looks like a black footballer, in the same way if he was doing an impression of Ed Sheeran he'd don a ginger wig?
It's clear a 30 year old comedy sketch got twisted to find a new level of sinister insult to do with black oppression, by some overly sensitive types-probably white Guardian readers.
Only a complete moron who is looking to take offence could see it in such a twisted light.
This is what we are dealing with now.
Black, white, Jewish- it's comedy and poking fun. Sadly common sense isn't that common.
Sorry but you can’t compare poking fun at ginger people in the same way you do Jews and persons or colour. The historical treatment of these groups is entirely different to that of having ginger hair, so yes, you have got it completely wrong lad.
What Baddiel did was as wrong 30 years ago as it is now, however the people who would have been offended then now have more channels through which to feel comfortable and empowered to call out the wrongdoing.
I don’t think comedians or celebrities should be cancelled now due to something they’ve done 30 years ago which within the context of the time wasn’t called out as wrong, but there’s no harm in acknowledging you did something wrong and saying you’re sorry for it.
I beg to differ. Yes you can do what he did and it's all about intent. Dressing up singing Mammy like Al Jolson in character as an oppressed American black cotton picker is a completely different thing to pretending to be a rich footballer in a different country in a different time and who just shares in common that he is black. It's all about context.
I would doubt that the vast majority of black people laughing at that sketch in the mid 90s had an idea of the blacking up row. It was an innocent joke and seeing it any other way is bizarre and a little bit aloof. The only thing his impression has in common with racially segregated America is its an impression of someone of a different skin colour.
No offence was intended and the intolerant 25 years after reframe it and make him apologise for the good of his career. It's a very strange train of thought, by overly serious well-meaning people.
It is all very odd and oh so Guardian, yet it's now the way it is and why we can't actually debate serious issues intelligently as some called it 'racism.' That kind of ends most conversations.
So, let me start by saying I don’t disagree with everything you write. I don’t want us to exist in a world where we cannot laugh at each other, and everybody share the same level of humour. Unfortunately, we do not live in a place where sensitivities can be ignored.
The comparison with Al Jolson isn’t necessarily a fair one, with Joelson similarly a successful and famous person of the time. Indeed, the problem with the sketch is not whether or not Jason Lee was offended by it, but by the practice itself and the offence that can cause to people of colour,
Without going into massive amounts of detail, the practice of black face originated from black actors not being able to perform and white actors taking their place. This then developed into caricatures which would visibly mock exaggerated physical characteristics associated with black people and often portray them as childlike, stupid, evil and/or generally inferior and as such, the performances and practice became heavily racist. The practice of any white man going into black face and performing can therefore not be disassociated with this history, so it’s not merely a case of whether or not a professional footballer was offended by the impersonation, but moreso what it stands for.
Now I do not think Baddiel’s sketch was intended to trigger any of the above, it’s done in an amusing way only poking fun at Jason Lee, and I’m sure he found it amusing, but his approval does not offset all of the above. Baddiel was silly to do it, but as I’ve said, I’m confident intended no offense, and had no overt racial tone, hence why a straightforward “it was a silly decision, we didn’t think it through, sorry for any offence caused” is more than sufficient.
As has been said on the other thread on here around racism and society, being able to have a more open dialogue and people not being so fast to accuse of racism and the defensiveness and fear caused by such accusations would be hugely helpful but if anything we are going in the wrong direction.
RE: Reginald D Hunter - PatelsPlatoon - 08-28-2024
(08-28-2024, 01:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-27-2024, 08:21 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: (08-27-2024, 04:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-21-2024, 02:31 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Saw David Baddiel apologising profusely, in a quite uncomfortable way, recently for blacking his face for doing an impression of Jason Lee back in the Fantasy Football League days.
Maybe I've got it wrong, but wasn't it to do so he looks like a black footballer, in the same way if he was doing an impression of Ed Sheeran he'd don a ginger wig?
It's clear a 30 year old comedy sketch got twisted to find a new level of sinister insult to do with black oppression, by some overly sensitive types-probably white Guardian readers.
Only a complete moron who is looking to take offence could see it in such a twisted light.
This is what we are dealing with now.
Black, white, Jewish- it's comedy and poking fun. Sadly common sense isn't that common.
Sorry but you can’t compare poking fun at ginger people in the same way you do Jews and persons or colour. The historical treatment of these groups is entirely different to that of having ginger hair, so yes, you have got it completely wrong lad.
What Baddiel did was as wrong 30 years ago as it is now, however the people who would have been offended then now have more channels through which to feel comfortable and empowered to call out the wrongdoing.
I don’t think comedians or celebrities should be cancelled now due to something they’ve done 30 years ago which within the context of the time wasn’t called out as wrong, but there’s no harm in acknowledging you did something wrong and saying you’re sorry for it.
I beg to differ. Yes you can do what he did and it's all about intent. Dressing up singing Mammy like Al Jolson in character as an oppressed American black cotton picker is a completely different thing to pretending to be a rich footballer in a different country in a different time and who just shares in common that he is black. It's all about context.
I would doubt that the vast majority of black people laughing at that sketch in the mid 90s had an idea of the blacking up row. It was an innocent joke and seeing it any other way is bizarre and a little bit aloof. The only thing his impression has in common with racially segregated America is its an impression of someone of a different skin colour.
No offence was intended and the intolerant 25 years after reframe it and make him apologise for the good of his career. It's a very strange train of thought, by overly serious well-meaning people.
It is all very odd and oh so Guardian, yet it's now the way it is and why we can't actually debate serious issues intelligently as some called it 'racism.' That kind of ends most conversations.
So, let me start by saying I don’t disagree with everything you write. I don’t want us to exist in a world where we cannot laugh at each other, and everybody share the same level of humour. Unfortunately, we do not live in a place where sensitivities can be ignored.
The comparison with Al Jolson isn’t necessarily a fair one, with Joelson similarly a successful and famous person of the time. Indeed, the problem with the sketch is not whether or not Jason Lee was offended by it, but by the practice itself and the offence that can cause to people of colour,
Without going into massive amounts of detail, the practice of black face originated from black actors not being able to perform and white actors taking their place. This then developed into caricatures which would visibly mock exaggerated physical characteristics associated with black people and often portray them as childlike, stupid, evil and/or generally inferior and as such, the performances and practice became heavily racist. The practice of any white man going into black face and performing can therefore not be disassociated with this history, so it’s not merely a case of whether or not a professional footballer was offended by the impersonation, but moreso what it stands for.
Now I do not think Baddiel’s sketch was intended to trigger any of the above, it’s done in an amusing way only poking fun at Jason Lee, and I’m sure he found it amusing, but his approval does not offset all of the above. Baddiel was silly to do it, but as I’ve said, I’m confident intended no offense, and had no overt racial tone, hence why a straightforward “it was a silly decision, we didn’t think it through, sorry for any offence caused” is more than sufficient.
As has been said on the other thread on here around racism and society, being able to have a more open dialogue and people not being so fast to accuse of racism and the defensiveness and fear caused by such accusations would be hugely helpful but if anything we are going in the wrong direction.
A decent reply, but simply it's all about context, as I said and also about the propensity to look for offence, which is what today's world is about.
It took something like 25 years for this joke to be deemed offensive, which kind of explains it all. It was not done in any kind of racial way so looking for offence is just overly sensitive and going off on a mad tangent.
After all black face, this was a problem from another country with a very different set of racial issues in a different time. Should every white man feel compelled to apologise for American slavery even if they've never had any connection with that country- none of my relations have had any more to do with that that the holocaust.
Look hard enough for offence and you'll find it, even if it takes a generation for a joke to be deemed offensive because some prickly academic has told us so, which is generally how such madness starts. I would hope you'll take a second to realise how completely bonkers this is.
RE: Reginald D Hunter - SW4Baggie - 08-28-2024
(08-28-2024, 09:03 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: (08-28-2024, 01:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-27-2024, 08:21 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: (08-27-2024, 04:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-21-2024, 02:31 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Saw David Baddiel apologising profusely, in a quite uncomfortable way, recently for blacking his face for doing an impression of Jason Lee back in the Fantasy Football League days.
Maybe I've got it wrong, but wasn't it to do so he looks like a black footballer, in the same way if he was doing an impression of Ed Sheeran he'd don a ginger wig?
It's clear a 30 year old comedy sketch got twisted to find a new level of sinister insult to do with black oppression, by some overly sensitive types-probably white Guardian readers.
Only a complete moron who is looking to take offence could see it in such a twisted light.
This is what we are dealing with now.
Black, white, Jewish- it's comedy and poking fun. Sadly common sense isn't that common.
Sorry but you can’t compare poking fun at ginger people in the same way you do Jews and persons or colour. The historical treatment of these groups is entirely different to that of having ginger hair, so yes, you have got it completely wrong lad.
What Baddiel did was as wrong 30 years ago as it is now, however the people who would have been offended then now have more channels through which to feel comfortable and empowered to call out the wrongdoing.
I don’t think comedians or celebrities should be cancelled now due to something they’ve done 30 years ago which within the context of the time wasn’t called out as wrong, but there’s no harm in acknowledging you did something wrong and saying you’re sorry for it.
I beg to differ. Yes you can do what he did and it's all about intent. Dressing up singing Mammy like Al Jolson in character as an oppressed American black cotton picker is a completely different thing to pretending to be a rich footballer in a different country in a different time and who just shares in common that he is black. It's all about context.
I would doubt that the vast majority of black people laughing at that sketch in the mid 90s had an idea of the blacking up row. It was an innocent joke and seeing it any other way is bizarre and a little bit aloof. The only thing his impression has in common with racially segregated America is its an impression of someone of a different skin colour.
No offence was intended and the intolerant 25 years after reframe it and make him apologise for the good of his career. It's a very strange train of thought, by overly serious well-meaning people.
It is all very odd and oh so Guardian, yet it's now the way it is and why we can't actually debate serious issues intelligently as some called it 'racism.' That kind of ends most conversations.
So, let me start by saying I don’t disagree with everything you write. I don’t want us to exist in a world where we cannot laugh at each other, and everybody share the same level of humour. Unfortunately, we do not live in a place where sensitivities can be ignored.
The comparison with Al Jolson isn’t necessarily a fair one, with Joelson similarly a successful and famous person of the time. Indeed, the problem with the sketch is not whether or not Jason Lee was offended by it, but by the practice itself and the offence that can cause to people of colour,
Without going into massive amounts of detail, the practice of black face originated from black actors not being able to perform and white actors taking their place. This then developed into caricatures which would visibly mock exaggerated physical characteristics associated with black people and often portray them as childlike, stupid, evil and/or generally inferior and as such, the performances and practice became heavily racist. The practice of any white man going into black face and performing can therefore not be disassociated with this history, so it’s not merely a case of whether or not a professional footballer was offended by the impersonation, but moreso what it stands for.
Now I do not think Baddiel’s sketch was intended to trigger any of the above, it’s done in an amusing way only poking fun at Jason Lee, and I’m sure he found it amusing, but his approval does not offset all of the above. Baddiel was silly to do it, but as I’ve said, I’m confident intended no offense, and had no overt racial tone, hence why a straightforward “it was a silly decision, we didn’t think it through, sorry for any offence caused” is more than sufficient.
As has been said on the other thread on here around racism and society, being able to have a more open dialogue and people not being so fast to accuse of racism and the defensiveness and fear caused by such accusations would be hugely helpful but if anything we are going in the wrong direction.
A decent reply, but simply it's all about context, as I said and also about the propensity to look for offence, which is what today's world is about.
It took something like 25 years for this joke to be deemed offensive, which kind of explains it all. It was not done in any kind of racial way so looking for offence is just overly sensitive and going off on a mad tangent.
After all black face, this was a problem from another country with a very different set of racial issues in a different time. Should every white man feel compelled to apologise for American slavery even if they've never had any connection with that country- none of my relations have had any more to do with that that the holocaust.
Look hard enough for offence and you'll find it, even if it takes a generation for a joke to be deemed offensive because some prickly academic has told us so, which is generally how such madness starts. I would hope you'll take a second to realise how completely bonkers this is.
Not sure the context argument flies here mate, and my point is not that it’s taken 25 years for it to become offensive. It was offensive at the time, but the larger white audience were unaware it was offensive, and those who found it offensive did not have the means nor channels to complain about it. The Black and White Minstrels was incredibly offensive, but wrongly accepted, along with the Robinson’s jam adverts, but it’s taken time for those offended to educate people on why it is/was wrong. I don’t believe Robinson’s should be cancelled and shut down, and again much like Baddiel’s situation, a simple “we now realise this was offensive and we are sorry” is all it needs.
It’s not about “looking for reasons to be offended” - it’s about calling out racist gestures that may be hidden or unrealised. I’m not sure the sketch would have been any less amusing had he still worn the wig, pineapple and Forest tracksuit. People have a choice, they can either understand history and realise “actually yes, that was a bit too far” and appreciate how we have progessed as a society, or they can become defensive and start claiming “you can’t say anything these days…” and just inflame the situation/division even more.
Really struggling with the sudden link to slavery - and let’s face it, the UK was hardly an innocent party within the Slave trade. FWIW though, I do not believe any white man should feel compelled to apologise for the Slave Trade, nor do I think there’s much pressure to do so... Again, this whole period of history is so often poorly understood and reported and it’s completely wrong to claim there is only collective guilt on “the white side.” There were plenty of non-white agents who profited from slavery. At the point of capture it was just as much black people facilitating, trading and profiting from the trade, generally tribal chiefs selling prisoners or trading their own people for Western artifacts (and often weapons to catch greater numbers) was at the root. These practices had been going on for centuries before white people landed in Africa.
As for apologies and reparations, if someone’s ancestors have made huge financial spoils from this period there should be some recompense but I don’t believe writing cheques to descendants many decades later is as much the answer as collective white guilt. It is yet another topic that emotion clouds fact and closes discussion but that’s for a whole other thread.
RE: Reginald D Hunter - PatelsPlatoon - 08-28-2024
(08-28-2024, 09:59 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-28-2024, 09:03 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: (08-28-2024, 01:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-27-2024, 08:21 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: (08-27-2024, 04:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Sorry but you can’t compare poking fun at ginger people in the same way you do Jews and persons or colour. The historical treatment of these groups is entirely different to that of having ginger hair, so yes, you have got it completely wrong lad.
What Baddiel did was as wrong 30 years ago as it is now, however the people who would have been offended then now have more channels through which to feel comfortable and empowered to call out the wrongdoing.
I don’t think comedians or celebrities should be cancelled now due to something they’ve done 30 years ago which within the context of the time wasn’t called out as wrong, but there’s no harm in acknowledging you did something wrong and saying you’re sorry for it.
I beg to differ. Yes you can do what he did and it's all about intent. Dressing up singing Mammy like Al Jolson in character as an oppressed American black cotton picker is a completely different thing to pretending to be a rich footballer in a different country in a different time and who just shares in common that he is black. It's all about context.
I would doubt that the vast majority of black people laughing at that sketch in the mid 90s had an idea of the blacking up row. It was an innocent joke and seeing it any other way is bizarre and a little bit aloof. The only thing his impression has in common with racially segregated America is its an impression of someone of a different skin colour.
No offence was intended and the intolerant 25 years after reframe it and make him apologise for the good of his career. It's a very strange train of thought, by overly serious well-meaning people.
It is all very odd and oh so Guardian, yet it's now the way it is and why we can't actually debate serious issues intelligently as some called it 'racism.' That kind of ends most conversations.
So, let me start by saying I don’t disagree with everything you write. I don’t want us to exist in a world where we cannot laugh at each other, and everybody share the same level of humour. Unfortunately, we do not live in a place where sensitivities can be ignored.
The comparison with Al Jolson isn’t necessarily a fair one, with Joelson similarly a successful and famous person of the time. Indeed, the problem with the sketch is not whether or not Jason Lee was offended by it, but by the practice itself and the offence that can cause to people of colour,
Without going into massive amounts of detail, the practice of black face originated from black actors not being able to perform and white actors taking their place. This then developed into caricatures which would visibly mock exaggerated physical characteristics associated with black people and often portray them as childlike, stupid, evil and/or generally inferior and as such, the performances and practice became heavily racist. The practice of any white man going into black face and performing can therefore not be disassociated with this history, so it’s not merely a case of whether or not a professional footballer was offended by the impersonation, but moreso what it stands for.
Now I do not think Baddiel’s sketch was intended to trigger any of the above, it’s done in an amusing way only poking fun at Jason Lee, and I’m sure he found it amusing, but his approval does not offset all of the above. Baddiel was silly to do it, but as I’ve said, I’m confident intended no offense, and had no overt racial tone, hence why a straightforward “it was a silly decision, we didn’t think it through, sorry for any offence caused” is more than sufficient.
As has been said on the other thread on here around racism and society, being able to have a more open dialogue and people not being so fast to accuse of racism and the defensiveness and fear caused by such accusations would be hugely helpful but if anything we are going in the wrong direction.
A decent reply, but simply it's all about context, as I said and also about the propensity to look for offence, which is what today's world is about.
It took something like 25 years for this joke to be deemed offensive, which kind of explains it all. It was not done in any kind of racial way so looking for offence is just overly sensitive and going off on a mad tangent.
After all black face, this was a problem from another country with a very different set of racial issues in a different time. Should every white man feel compelled to apologise for American slavery even if they've never had any connection with that country- none of my relations have had any more to do with that that the holocaust.
Look hard enough for offence and you'll find it, even if it takes a generation for a joke to be deemed offensive because some prickly academic has told us so, which is generally how such madness starts. I would hope you'll take a second to realise how completely bonkers this is.
Not sure the context argument flies here mate, and my point is not that it’s taken 25 years for it to become offensive. It was offensive at the time, but the larger white audience were unaware it was offensive, and those who found it offensive did not have the means nor channels to complain about it. The Black and White Minstrels was incredibly offensive, but wrongly accepted, along with the Robinson’s jam adverts, but it’s taken time for those offended to educate people on why it is/was wrong. I don’t believe Robinson’s should be cancelled and shut down, and again much like Baddiel’s situation, a simple “we now realise this was offensive and we are sorry” is all it needs.
It’s not about “looking for reasons to be offended” - it’s about calling out racist gestures that may be hidden or unrealised. I’m not sure the sketch would have been any less amusing had he still worn the wig, pineapple and Forest tracksuit. People have a choice, they can either understand history and realise “actually yes, that was a bit too far” and appreciate how we have progessed as a society, or they can become defensive and start claiming “you can’t say anything these days…” and just inflame the situation/division even more.
Really struggling with the sudden link to slavery - and let’s face it, the UK was hardly an innocent party within the Slave trade. FWIW though, I do not believe any white man should feel compelled to apologise for the Slave Trade, nor do I think there’s much pressure to do so... Again, this whole period of history is so often poorly understood and reported and it’s completely wrong to claim there is only collective guilt on “the white side.” There were plenty of non-white agents who profited from slavery. At the point of capture it was just as much black people facilitating, trading and profiting from the trade, generally tribal chiefs selling prisoners or trading their own people for Western artifacts (and often weapons to catch greater numbers) was at the root. These practices had been going on for centuries before white people landed in Africa.
As for apologies and reparations, if someone’s ancestors have made huge financial spoils from this period there should be some recompense but I don’t believe writing cheques to descendants many decades later is as much the answer as collective white guilt. It is yet another topic that emotion clouds fact and closes discussion but that’s for a whole other thread. You've eloquently explained your point, but we have to agree to disagree. I doubt most black people 30 years ago found what he did racially offensive. Ignorance is bliss, in that this was seen by the uneducated masses as a joke about a footballer. Clearly some academics might have found offence, but they are like that anyhow, and they have supposedly educated us as to why we should be offended. Maybe if we all siad, it wasn't meant that way so wind your neck in the world would be a better place.
However, I agree with your last paragraph regards those who profited.
RE: Reginald D Hunter - Baggybenny - 08-28-2024
Bizarrely compensation was paid by the UK government at the time. To the slave traders for their loss of income !!!!
|