WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=34696)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Ratings - Majas magic - 08-10-2024

Palmer 6 - Not convincing on corners.

Furlong 7 - Excellent defensive headers.
Ajayi 7 - switched on
Bartley 8 Marshalled the defence
Heggem 8 Fantastic debut.

Molumby 7 pest
Mowatt 7 Pulled the strings
Swift 7 improved as the game went on.

Fellows 7 improved after slow start
Maja 9 As per my username
Grant 8 Set the bar


RE: Ratings - Peachy - 08-10-2024

I thought Swift was outstanding today. 9 for me. Maja a 10. A centre forward who scores a hat trick to win us a game is an automatic 10 for me.


RE: Ratings - SW4Baggie - 08-10-2024

(08-10-2024, 03:15 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Palmer - 7

Furlong - 7
Bartley - 8
Ajayi - 6
Heggem - 8

Molumby - 6
Mowatt - 8

Fellows - 8
Swift - 8
Grant - 8

Maja - 9

Not far off this Lurker!

Palmer - 7 - not a lot to do, one big save but otherwise QPRs shots were from distance/poor quality

Furlong - 6.5 - 8 second half, but first half he was wasteful and played us into trouble.
Bartley - 8 - what he does best 
Ajayi - 6.5 - thought he went AWOL for the goal, not sure he’s right alongside Heggem as both seemed a bit iffy positionally, 
Heggem - 7 - think he will be a fan favourite, but one huge error and was flat footed for their goal. 

Molumby - 6.5 - brought legs but outshone by Mowatt
Mowatt - 8 - picked up exactly where he left off last year, such an important renewal, probably the hardest of all the players we could have potentially lost to replace, 

Fellows - 8 - two (ish) assists, and QPR couldn’t deal with him. Showed a better defensive side to his game when Furlong kept playing him into trouble first half.
Swift - 8.5 - best he’s looked in months, everything good came through him - looks a bit trimmer.
Grant - 8 - worked hard, stuck to his task, and fluffed his best chance!

Maja - 10 - three chances and bagged them all, and gave a really solid all round display. BTA scores one of those chances at most, let’s hope this is a sign of what’s to come!

I liked the pace of Diakite and Dobbin, and Cole looks like he’s willing to run. Promising starts all round.


RE: Ratings - Berthe of a Nation - 08-10-2024

(08-10-2024, 03:18 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-10-2024, 03:11 PM)Fido Wrote:
(08-10-2024, 02:52 PM)lesley Wrote: Darnell and Swift both 8’s for me.

Darnell did some great work defensively second half, I agree.

Had a great game.
No-one less than 7. 
Unexpected not gonna lie but that was not just a great result it was a great performance.
All 8s apart from Heggem a 9, Maja a 10 (if you can't get a 10 for getting a hat trick with 100% of chances covered when can you?), and Swift 7 and Zabrotta a 6 (but had little time to adjust & impress tbf) and Ajayi a 6 too.


RE: Ratings - Jacko - 08-10-2024

Palmer 7

Furlong 7.5
Bartley 8
Ajayi 7
Heggem 8

Molumby 7
Mowatt 8

Fellows 8
Swift 8.5
Grant 7.5

Maja 10

Subs all 6.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 08-10-2024

It looked to me like Corberan has made Swift the focal point of the team. He gave him the number 10 and today Swift was running around like a captain. Barking orders at people, calling for the ball; not something we’ve seen that much of in the past.


RE: Ratings - sickParrot - 08-10-2024

Grant at least a 7, Swift an 8


RE: Ratings - SW4Baggie - 08-10-2024

(08-10-2024, 04:31 PM)Sliced Wrote: It looked to me like Corberan has made Swift the focal point of the team. He gave him the number 10 and today Swift was running around like a captain. Barking orders at people, calling for the ball; not something we’ve seen that much of in the past.

Good shout, looked like the Swift that carried Reading for several years


RE: Ratings - Vinebaggie - 08-10-2024

New Grant upgrade on old Grant
Maja upgrade on BTA
Heggem upgrade on Townsend
New Swift upgrade on Grady
Furlong just a great performance
Molumby more energy than Okay
Palmer, Ajay, Bartley, Mowatt, Molumby all good

Fellows off his usual pace , but great assists

The only player from last year I’d like to get back is Kipre


RE: Ratings - Tiptonmon - 08-10-2024

(08-10-2024, 03:38 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-10-2024, 03:15 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Palmer - 7

Furlong - 7
Bartley - 8
Ajayi - 6
Heggem - 8

Molumby - 6
Mowatt - 8

Fellows - 8
Swift - 8
Grant - 8

Maja - 9

Not far off this Lurker!

Palmer - 7 - not a lot to do, one big save but otherwise QPRs shots were from distance/poor quality

Furlong - 6.5 - 8 second half, but first half he was wasteful and played us into trouble.
Bartley - 8 - what he does best 
Ajayi - 6.5 - thought he went AWOL for the goal, not sure he’s right alongside Heggem as both seemed a bit iffy positionally, 
Heggem - 7 - think he will be a fan favourite, but one huge error and was flat footed for their goal. 

Molumby - 6.5 - brought legs but outshone by Mowatt
Mowatt - 8 - picked up exactly where he left off last year, such an important renewal, probably the hardest of all the players we could have potentially lost to replace, 

Fellows - 8 - two (ish) assists, and QPR couldn’t deal with him. Showed a better defensive side to his game when Furlong kept playing him into trouble first half.
Swift - 8.5 - best he’s looked in months, everything good came through him - looks a bit trimmer.
Grant - 8 - worked hard, stuck to his task, and fluffed his best chance!

Maja - 10 - three chances and bagged them all, and gave a really solid all round display. BTA scores one of those chances at most, let’s hope this is a sign of what’s to come!

I liked the pace of Diakite and Dobbin, and Cole looks like he’s willing to run. Promising starts all round.

Very harsh, mate. He connected well and the goalie pulled off a great save. Perhaps he might have scored, but I wouldn't call it a 'fluff'. Anyway, I still think an 8 is about right.