WBAUnofficial
Labour 25 days in - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Labour 25 days in (/showthread.php?tid=34558)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Labour 25 days in - Protheroe - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 12:01 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: If you can afford to spare greater than the average UK salary to send your kids to a school that makes you feel better about yourself, then don't expect too much sympathy from the masses, and if you've pushed yourself to the brink in order to pay for it then you're just plain stupid.

Mealy mouthed response #1


RE: Labour 25 days in - Ted Maul - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 12:14 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 12:01 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: If you can afford to spare greater than the average UK salary to send your kids to a school that makes you feel better about yourself, then don't expect too much sympathy from the masses, and if you've pushed yourself to the brink in order to pay for it then you're just plain stupid.

Mealy mouthed response #1

How is it mealy mouthed? If you're wealthy enough to afford private school without sacrificing anything then I doubt that VAT is going to be too much of an imposition. Anyone who is putting themselves at risk financially to send their kids to private schools is an idiot.


RE: Labour 25 days in - Hudds1 - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 11:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 11:01 AM)Hudds1 Wrote: 7 is OK in logic to remove the exemption from VAT for private school fees but it won't bring in much - schools (they are businesses in effect now, not charitable status) will be able to make input tax deductions. There will be other knock-ons to make effective taxation nowhere near the 20% output tax payment collected.

It also looks bad IMO.  Optics. (I wear glasses for it).

It looks great to those who care about the issue; primarily the grasping middle classes who bought into the right catchment or hothoused their kids through the 11 plus but still feel some vindictiveness towards the undoubted social advantages granted by attendance at a actual fee-paying school. Living where I do I know many of these people, some of whom are taking delight in that their "friends" and neighbours face a 20% increase in costs or withdrawing their kids.

A mate of mine has two kids at RGS. He's just had to shell out £10,000 on a new roof and now faces an increase of the same again in school fees next year. Whether you agree with private education or not, there is a human cost to it. Though I expect plenty of mealy-mouthed responses to that point.

As to the point about input VAT, it'll be interesting to see how the government manages that - particularly for retrospective input VAT claims which could effectively mean the policy doesn't raise much, if anything initially.

All this for an extra third of a teacher per school over five years demonstrates a triumph of poverty of ambition funded by simple politics of envy.
I'd move.  Anywhere.

(08-01-2024, 11:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 11:01 AM)Hudds1 Wrote: 7 is OK in logic to remove the exemption from VAT for private school fees but it won't bring in much - schools (they are businesses in effect now, not charitable status) will be able to make input tax deductions. There will be other knock-ons to make effective taxation nowhere near the 20% output tax payment collected.

It also looks bad IMO.  Optics. (I wear glasses for it).

It looks great to those who care about the issue; primarily the grasping middle classes who bought into the right catchment or hothoused their kids through the 11 plus but still feel some vindictiveness towards the undoubted social advantages granted by attendance at a actual fee-paying school. Living where I do I know many of these people, some of whom are taking delight in that their "friends" and neighbours face a 20% increase in costs or withdrawing their kids.

A mate of mine has two kids at RGS. He's just had to shell out £10,000 on a new roof and now faces an increase of the same again in school fees next year. Whether you agree with private education or not, there is a human cost to it. Though I expect plenty of mealy-mouthed responses to that point.

As to the point about input VAT, it'll be interesting to see how the government manages that - particularly for retrospective input VAT claims which could effectively mean the policy doesn't raise much, if anything initially.

All this for an extra third of a teacher per school over five years demonstrates a triumph of poverty of ambition funded by simple politics of envy.
I'd move.  Anywhere.

(The passing on element to parents won't be anywhere 20% in fees, mind unless the schools want to shake down their customers).


RE: Labour 25 days in - Protheroe - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 12:18 PM)Hudds1 Wrote: I'd move.  Anywhere.

As soon as they're finished at school that's exactly what I plan to do.

It's toss up between this sort of parent and the coke-snorting 50 something bores in West One for those I'll miss the least.


RE: Labour 25 days in - Baggybenny - 08-01-2024

The Government should be promoting the private fee-paying schools by giving them huge subsidies. We can then hope for more Boris types to be in the pipeline.


RE: Labour 25 days in - man in the corner shop - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 12:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 12:18 PM)Hudds1 Wrote: I'd move.  Anywhere.

As soon as they're finished at school that's exactly what I plan to do.

It's toss up between this sort of parent and the coke-snorting 50 something bores in West One for those I'll miss the least.

THE FLIGHT OF CAPITAL AND BRAIN DRAIN IS BEGINNING. Big Grin


RE: Labour 25 days in - Protheroe - 08-01-2024

Probably only to Shropshire MITCS


RE: Labour 25 days in - man in the corner shop - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 06:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Probably only to Shropshire MITCS

You'll be sneaking over the border for some cheap Welsh cakes.


RE: Labour 25 days in - Tom Joad - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 04:55 PM)Baggybenny Wrote: The Government should be promoting the private fee-paying schools by giving them huge subsidies. We can then hope for more Boris types to be in the pipeline.

Boris, Reece Mogg, Cameron eh? They should get their money back. Darius Guppy has probably already asked to have his fees refunding.


RE: Labour 25 days in - Malcolm Tucker - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 11:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 11:01 AM)Hudds1 Wrote: 7 is OK in logic to remove the exemption from VAT for private school fees but it won't bring in much - schools (they are businesses in effect now, not charitable status) will be able to make input tax deductions. There will be other knock-ons to make effective taxation nowhere near the 20% output tax payment collected.

It also looks bad IMO.  Optics. (I wear glasses for it).

It looks great to those who care about the issue; primarily the grasping middle classes who bought into the right catchment or hothoused their kids through the 11 plus but still feel some vindictiveness towards the undoubted social advantages granted by attendance at a actual fee-paying school. Living where I do I know many of these people, some of whom are taking delight in that their "friends" and neighbours face a 20% increase in costs or withdrawing their kids.

A mate of mine has two kids at RGS. He's just had to shell out £10,000 on a new roof and now faces an increase of the same again in school fees next year. Whether you agree with private education or not, there is a human cost to it. Though I expect plenty of mealy-mouthed responses to that point.

As to the point about input VAT, it'll be interesting to see how the government manages that - particularly for retrospective input VAT claims which could effectively mean the policy doesn't raise much, if anything initially.

All this for an extra third of a teacher per school over five years demonstrates a triumph of poverty of ambition funded by simple politics of envy.

How’s your luck eh? They’ll probably add duty to polo mallets when he needs his most cleaning next.