RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - Spandaubaggie - 07-15-2024
(07-15-2024, 09:18 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:11 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: We're not a big nation. We're bang average. I don't understand the arrogance.
But compared to other nations, we are in terms of resources and population. We have one of the best funded FAs globally, and with our population of 60M+ we should be competing with Italy, France, Spain, Germany etc far more regularly.
I think it was Gianluca Vialli who wrote that England are at a natural disadvantage when it comes to international football as our weather is so bad. Too many of our kids grow up playing football in the wind and the rain and it makes us less technically proficient. There's probably something in it, when you travel to Spain or Italy, you see kids out playing football every night of the week, whereas in the UK it's nowhere near as feasible. With the temperatures in these countries too it's not possible to kick, rush and chase the ball, you learn from an early age to let the ball do the running for you, we have to chase after it to keep warm for over half the year!!
German winters are similar to ours. Your argument makes sense, to an extent. But other nations also play in bad weather.
We're producing talent that can play a winning style, but the mentality isn't there. Bottle jobs is the wrong phrase, but there's certainly a lack of winning mentality and a frailty about England sides that no other Nation suffers with.
(07-15-2024, 09:16 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: We're not a big nation. We're bang average. I don't understand the arrogance.
What a very strange answer. There's no arrogance and it's a world apart from subjective club nonsense.
This is based on population mainly, as well as a very successful world leading club league. There's a 60m population here, which is bigger than Italy and Spain and marginally smaller than France.
This country has also got to the last 8 of competitions regularly and gets to all the finals, pretty much. Do you want to compare us to Greece or Bulgaria instead.
So the conclusion seems we are a big country, but one that has historically underperformed.
Let's compare us to Greece since '66.
Major trophies won:
England - 0
Greece - 1 I already have- Denmark too.
Let's try again - there are 5 leading European leagues which hoover up all the European competitions. This country is one of them, yet the other 4 are more successful. We have one of the biggest populations in Europe too. However, we don't do as well. NB We have a bigger population than Estonia!
I'm using population and league standing as the parameters. You are just using the word big without context.
RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - Bob Fossil - 07-15-2024
Yet again we were beaten by the “better team”. The question therefore, yet again, has to be why were they a better team. I think would argue that they don’t necessarily have the better play re, so it has to come down to other factors like coaching, mentality etc.
Southgate has done part of the job, in that he has instilled belief in the players that they can compete right through to the latter stages.
The next man needs to let them play in a way that can win it. We talk about arrogance but I don’t think we are arrogant enough. We need to start believing we can win on the front foot and not playing in fear of the opposition.
RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - SuperBob2002 - 07-15-2024
(07-15-2024, 09:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:18 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:11 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: We're not a big nation. We're bang average. I don't understand the arrogance.
But compared to other nations, we are in terms of resources and population. We have one of the best funded FAs globally, and with our population of 60M+ we should be competing with Italy, France, Spain, Germany etc far more regularly.
I think it was Gianluca Vialli who wrote that England are at a natural disadvantage when it comes to international football as our weather is so bad. Too many of our kids grow up playing football in the wind and the rain and it makes us less technically proficient. There's probably something in it, when you travel to Spain or Italy, you see kids out playing football every night of the week, whereas in the UK it's nowhere near as feasible. With the temperatures in these countries too it's not possible to kick, rush and chase the ball, you learn from an early age to let the ball do the running for you, we have to chase after it to keep warm for over half the year!!
German winters are similar to ours. Your argument makes sense, to an extent. But other nations also play in bad weather.
We're producing talent that can play a winning style, but the mentality isn't there. Bottle jobs is the wrong phrase, but there's certainly a lack of winning mentality and a frailty about England sides that no other Nation suffers with.
(07-15-2024, 09:16 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: We're not a big nation. We're bang average. I don't understand the arrogance.
What a very strange answer. There's no arrogance and it's a world apart from subjective club nonsense.
This is based on population mainly, as well as a very successful world leading club league. There's a 60m population here, which is bigger than Italy and Spain and marginally smaller than France.
This country has also got to the last 8 of competitions regularly and gets to all the finals, pretty much. Do you want to compare us to Greece or Bulgaria instead.
So the conclusion seems we are a big country, but one that has historically underperformed.
Let's compare us to Greece since '66.
Major trophies won:
England - 0
Greece - 1 I already have.
Let's try again there are 5 leading European leagues which hoover up all the European competitions. This country is one of them, yet the other 4 are more successful. We have one of the biggest populations in Europe too. However, we don't do as well.
I'm using population and league standing as the parameters. You are just using the word big without context.
How many English born players represent City and Liverpool (the only two clubs to have success in Europe in recent years).
RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - Fido - 07-15-2024
(07-15-2024, 09:33 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Yet again we were beaten by the “better team”. The question therefore, yet again, has to be why were they a better team. I think would argue that they don’t necessarily have the better play re, so it has to come down to other factors like coaching, mentality etc.
Southgate has done part of the job, in that he has instilled belief in the players that they can compete right through to the latter stages.
The next man needs to let them play in a way that can win it. We talk about arrogance but I don’t think we are arrogant enough. We need to start believing we can win on the front foot and not playing in fear of the opposition.
+1 yet again, Bob
RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - Spandaubaggie - 07-15-2024
(07-15-2024, 09:35 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:18 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:11 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: We're not a big nation. We're bang average. I don't understand the arrogance.
But compared to other nations, we are in terms of resources and population. We have one of the best funded FAs globally, and with our population of 60M+ we should be competing with Italy, France, Spain, Germany etc far more regularly.
I think it was Gianluca Vialli who wrote that England are at a natural disadvantage when it comes to international football as our weather is so bad. Too many of our kids grow up playing football in the wind and the rain and it makes us less technically proficient. There's probably something in it, when you travel to Spain or Italy, you see kids out playing football every night of the week, whereas in the UK it's nowhere near as feasible. With the temperatures in these countries too it's not possible to kick, rush and chase the ball, you learn from an early age to let the ball do the running for you, we have to chase after it to keep warm for over half the year!!
German winters are similar to ours. Your argument makes sense, to an extent. But other nations also play in bad weather.
We're producing talent that can play a winning style, but the mentality isn't there. Bottle jobs is the wrong phrase, but there's certainly a lack of winning mentality and a frailty about England sides that no other Nation suffers with.
(07-15-2024, 09:16 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-15-2024, 09:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: We're not a big nation. We're bang average. I don't understand the arrogance.
What a very strange answer. There's no arrogance and it's a world apart from subjective club nonsense.
This is based on population mainly, as well as a very successful world leading club league. There's a 60m population here, which is bigger than Italy and Spain and marginally smaller than France.
This country has also got to the last 8 of competitions regularly and gets to all the finals, pretty much. Do you want to compare us to Greece or Bulgaria instead.
So the conclusion seems we are a big country, but one that has historically underperformed.
Let's compare us to Greece since '66.
Major trophies won:
England - 0
Greece - 1 I already have.
Let's try again there are 5 leading European leagues which hoover up all the European competitions. This country is one of them, yet the other 4 are more successful. We have one of the biggest populations in Europe too. However, we don't do as well.
I'm using population and league standing as the parameters. You are just using the word big without context.
How many English born players represent City and Liverpool (the only two clubs to have success in Europe in recent years).
Here you go. Have fun! https://www.englandfootball.com/england/mens-senior-team/squad
RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - SW4Baggie - 07-15-2024
(07-15-2024, 09:33 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Yet again we were beaten by the “better team”. The question therefore, yet again, has to be why were they a better team. I think would argue that they don’t necessarily have the better play re, so it has to come down to other factors like coaching, mentality etc.
Southgate has done part of the job, in that he has instilled belief in the players that they can compete right through to the latter stages.
The next man needs to let them play in a way that can win it. We talk about arrogance but I don’t think we are arrogant enough. We need to start believing we can win on the front foot and not playing in fear of the opposition.
I’m not sure how else we could or should have played to win that game, or what style any incoming manager should be playing to enable us to win things. We’ve made a semi and 2 finals in the last 4 tournaments so our style of play clearly isn’t holding us back.
We have quality gaps in defensive areas. We have as good a strike force, wide players and number 10s as anyone in the world but we don’t have a quality defensive partner for Stones, we have a shortage of quality left backs, and we don’t have a true defensive midfielder. If you took Rodri out of Spain’s team, I doubt they make the final, France and Germany went out due to not having a clinical striker… Spain had arguably the best balanced squad in the tournament and they ended up winning it.
On this thread thereve been suggestions we should have been even more defensive and tried to stifle Spain, and then others saying we should have attacked more, but to do that with our MC options would have seen us overrun.
At 1-1 we needed to be bolder. Spain had made substations to be more defensive, and we’d gone more open to chase the equaliser, however without Mainoo it felt GS panicked and pulled is back another 10 yards and Spain capitalised, I think we should have had more confidence. I’d have brought Toney 10 mins earlier and given them a right test in their box.
RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 07-15-2024
Consider not just European teams, since 1966, Argentina have won the World Cup 3 times, runners up twice, constantly produce skilfull players who can also be nasty if needs be,( Claudio Yacob, ace defensive midfielder for us, who wouldn`t have got in Argentinas midfield ) Uruguay, a population the size of Yorkshire, get to semi/ quarter finals at the World Cup
RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - Spandaubaggie - 07-15-2024
(07-15-2024, 11:33 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: Consider not just European teams, since 1966, Argentina have won the World Cup 3 times, runners up twice, constantly produce skilfull players who can also be nasty if needs be,( Claudio Yacob, ace defensive midfielder for us, who wouldn`t have got in Argentinas midfield ) Uruguay, a population the size of Yorkshire, get to semi/ quarter finals at the World Cup
That as may be Ministry, but really it's all about us comparing England to the European teams as they get the same two yearly chance.
Simply the nation is now all about winning a trophy, but now we instead focus on the failure of finals and semis like we used to losing at the traditional last 8 stage.
We only know the result of the years of Southgate's work, which has now meant more success than in the previous 50 years, in the last 6, but manager after manager with some who had great club success like Robson, Venables and Capello couldn't get us to lift a trophy.
We have had 29 attempts at silverware since 66. Using the World Cup for example, before 2018 we hadn't got to a semi final for the previous 7 world cups.
Southgate has certainly transformed our results positively, but this tournament has been the poorest in performance in games of the 4 tournaments he's overseen.
However, my hunch is the FA will allow Southgate to stay if he wishes, and he has earned that right, more than all those big name managers from Don Revie onwards.
The FA big wigs have solid KPIs to show the level of improvement.
RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - Duffers - 07-16-2024
My youngest son is six weeks old and has already seen the same amount of England success as Inhave in 42 years.
RE: The big European nations since it’s come home - GunsOfNavarone - 07-16-2024
Anyone know which pot we're in for the UEFA Nations League, how we got there and whether we're likely to face the 'big boys' should we get out of Group B........ ?
|