WBAUnofficial
What did Southgate ever do for us? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: What did Southgate ever do for us? (/showthread.php?tid=34359)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - HawkingsHalfpint - 07-11-2024

(07-11-2024, 08:26 AM)Duffers Wrote: I'm still ashamed at myself for losing faith in him just as the tournament started.

Six years I'd been fighting his corner too.

I think anybody could be forgiven for that, TBH. We were dogshit after the first 45 minutes of the competition, until we found ourselves trailing in a knockout game. 

It's a complex debate, also, which many don't get all angles and/or have short memories of the history of. In terms of restoring pride, professional integrity and national faith in the effort/endeavour and therefore enthusiasm for supporting the players, Southgate has been second to none. However at times in recent tournaments, you do have to wonder why we haven't gone for it more, scored more goals, seen certain players replicate their week-in, week-out incredible club form and ask why. It's a spectator sport, we all want to be entertained as well as win (Pulisball did get tiresome even during its most efficient days), and there has been bad to go with the good.

Worth mentioning here, however, that throughout his reign - for all of our (at times) inexplicable bashfulness in attack - we have in the main defended brilliantly, which has if anything been the bedrock for the consistency of 'going deep' (hate that in-phrase TBF) in recent tournaments. We may not make it easy for ourselves to beat sides with the way we often set-up, but we remain difficult to beat ourselves. 

I also think that - qualifiers aside (because we generally tend to fair well in the draw, and there is always a chance to put this right in subsequent games, which doesn't occur as much/at all early/late during) - in the tournament environment we do seem to struggle against weaker sides we are expected to beat, and do tend to up our game against better opposition. Perhaps it is a bit of nonchalance and stage fright all at the same time; who knows. 

We have, however, made another final, and for that he deserves immense credit. It doesn't make him a footballing genius nor demigod because it took an almost enforced change in formation to see any improvement at all in performances, and one or two are still yet to really turn it on as well as we know they can. 

The other aspect in all if this - which muddies the debate further still - is the embarrassing fact that we haven't won anything in so long. Which adds desperation to the emotion behind all of this.

But for all that is written and said about it - which truly means fuck all really - I'd have taken this scenario at the start.


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - Birdman1811 - 07-11-2024

(07-11-2024, 08:26 AM)Duffers Wrote: I'm still ashamed at myself for losing faith in him just as the tournament started.

Six years I'd been fighting his corner too.

Same.... Same


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - richbaggie - 07-11-2024

(07-11-2024, 08:50 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(07-11-2024, 08:26 AM)Duffers Wrote: I'm still ashamed at myself for losing faith in him just as the tournament started.

Six years I'd been fighting his corner too.

I think anybody could be forgiven for that, TBH. We were dogshit after the first 45 minutes of the competition, until we found ourselves trailing in a knockout game. 

It's a complex debate, also, which many don't get all angles and/or have short memories of the history of. In terms of restoring pride, professional integrity and national faith in the effort/endeavour and therefore enthusiasm for supporting the players, Southgate has been second to none. However at times in recent tournaments, you do have to wonder why we haven't gone for it more, scored more goals, seen certain players replicate their week-in, week-out incredible club form and ask why. It's a spectator sport, we all want to be entertained as well as win (Pulisball did get tiresome even during its most efficient days), and there has been bad to go with the good.

Worth mentioning here, however, that throughout his reign - for all of our (at times) inexplicable bashfulness in attack - we have in the main defended brilliantly, which has if anything been the bedrock for the consistency of 'going deep' (hate that in-phrase TBF) in recent tournaments. We may not make it easy for ourselves to beat sides with the way we often set-up, but we remain difficult to beat ourselves. 

I also think that - qualifiers aside (because we generally tend to fair well in the draw, and there is always a chance to put this right in subsequent games, which doesn't occur as much/at all early/late during) - in the tournament environment we do seem to struggle against weaker sides we are expected to beat, and do tend to up our game against better opposition. Perhaps it is a bit of nonchalance and stage fright all at the same time; who knows. 

We have, however, made another final, and for that he deserves immense credit. It doesn't make him a footballing genius nor demigod because it took an almost enforced change in formation to see any improvement at all in performances, and one or two are still yet to really turn it on as well as we know they can. 

The other aspect in all if this - which muddies the debate further still - is the embarrassing fact that we haven't won anything in so long. Which adds desperation to the emotion behind all of this.

But for all that is written and said about it - which truly means fuck all really - I'd have taken this scenario at the start.

A perfect and balanced summary Hawks.


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - Birdman1811 - 07-11-2024

Great post Hawks


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - AnelkasBeard - 07-11-2024

(07-11-2024, 08:56 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(07-11-2024, 08:26 AM)Duffers Wrote: I'm still ashamed at myself for losing faith in him just as the tournament started.

Six years I'd been fighting his corner too.

Same.... Same

Right there with you both.


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - sickParrot - 07-11-2024

Anyone here old enough to remember the attitude of the press in 1966? Ive been told that the papers were critical of Ramsey and there was a lot of scrutiny and scepticism throughout.


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - Lurker#3 - 07-11-2024

Great post, Hawks!

Southgate has done a brilliant job in his role as the face of the the England Men's team, and the youth teams before that. He's a diligent, intelligent bloke who usually prepares his squad impeccably. Sadly he just doesn't have the speed of thought, during the game to really get the best out of our players. I think he is in fact very lucky to have such brilliant options in the squad that when he does make changes they normally influence the game.


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - Kit Kat Chunky - 07-11-2024

Could be worse, it could have been John Terry in charge.


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - Remi_Moses - 07-11-2024

(07-11-2024, 09:28 AM)sickParrot Wrote: Anyone here old enough to remember the attitude of the press in 1966? Ive been told that the papers were critical of Ramsey and there was a lot of scrutiny and scepticism throughout.

Ramsey was crucified for dropping Jimmy Greaves, but that was soon forgot when Hurst scored a hat trick and we won the world cup.

Southgate took over at a difficult time, big Sam had been given his marching orders after one game. Southgate only took the job on a temporary contract. He played some of his under 21 starlets and won a few games and the rest is history. 
Considering his time he has now become our best most consistent manager over the last 50 years. I feel a "Sir" on its way. 
He has shown how to get results with disciplined approach which can be boring, but you can't argue with his record.


RE: What did Southgate ever do for us? - CarlosCorbewrong - 07-11-2024

(07-11-2024, 08:26 AM)Duffers Wrote: I'm still ashamed at myself for losing faith in him just as the tournament started.

Six years I'd been fighting his corner too.

Just delete your posts mate, nobody will be able to prove anything.