WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=33686)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Ratings - Derek Hardballs - 05-12-2024

(05-12-2024, 05:40 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:35 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:24 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:18 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 04:27 PM)Sliced Wrote: Decent day today, we certainly didn't look intimidated by Southampton. I thought it was a pretty even game and as much as we should've scored a couple, Armstrong could have had one or two as well.

Ratings:

Palmer 8 - A safe pair of hands but it has to be an 8 just for that save alone. Unbelievable reflexes

Townsend 7 - Solid. Handled their threat well down the flank. He's started to develop a more aggressive side to his game which showed today.
Bartley 8.5 - MOTM for me. Solid, assured, never looked trouble. If only he'd timed that free header a bit better.
Kipre 7 - Solid for the most part. Good movement. Reads the game fantastically.
Furlong 7.5 - Another good performance. Was an attacking threat as much as a defensive stalwart and his throw ins were on point today.

Okay 7.5 - A class act. Got better as the game progressed and was popping up all over the place.
Mowatt 6.5 - All around play was good but was a bit wasteful from free kicks and wild shots.

Fellows - 7.5 - Probably our best attacking outlet today. Lots of great runs and crosses but not enough presence in the box to aim for.
Diangana - 6.5 - I thought he played well overall but has to drop some points for the finishing. He had time on the shot in the second half.
Johnston - 7 - Played well but is has lacked end product a bit since the incredible run of games he had when he first arrived.

BTA 4 - Completely anonymous unfortunately. Fewest touches of any starting player, 4 successful passes, lost the vast majority of his duals, one shot blocked. Off ball movement was decent but that was it.

Subs:
M' Vila 6.5 Composed
Ajayi 6 - Won a header but didn't have much to do
Swift 6 - Not a massive impact. Corners no worse than before he came on
Reach 5 - A couple of decent moved but has to lose a point for the hail mary shot
Wallace 5 - Ran about a lot, touched the ball 3 times

Ridiculous on BTA, he was at least 6

Furlong at least 8

What did he do, other than pass the ball successfully once every 20 minutes and lose the ball every other time. Are our expectations really that low?

He won possession from closing down at least 5/6 times. I agree he’s limited but a 4? Don’t be a dick.

I didn't say he was limited, I said he did nothing today, which is true

No it’s not it’s drivel.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 05-12-2024

(05-12-2024, 05:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry but BTA 4? Nonsense, he’s playing on his own up front, putting pressure on their defence all match. He worked tirelessly against a team who are set-up to keep the ball in defence waiting to break through our press, the fact they didn’t for most of the game was due in part to BTA.

Sorry but I completely disagree with the criticism BTA has received after today’s match and tbh all season. Without him there are no play-offs.

Also those BTA stats are utter rubbish and prove you cannot judge a player or game properly with them in isolation from what is actually happening at the game.

I watched the game, I've acknowledged we wouldn't be in the playoffs without him.

I will acknowledge that he ran about a bit. Well done. The vast majority of the time when he got on the ball (which was hardly at all) things broke down.

I'd still start him next game, but that doesn't change his non-performance today.

(05-12-2024, 05:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:40 PM)Sliced Wrote: I didn't say he was limited, I said he did nothing today, which is true

No it’s not it’s drivel.

Ah sorry, he ran about a bit, that's worth at least a 6


RE: Ratings - Albionmad - 05-12-2024

Fwiw I thought BTA started really well.
He ran the channels, hurried their defenders and because of him we had a few openings.

He pressed well when they were playing out from the back and we could've created something when we regained the ball deep in their half

As the game wore on he was less effective and unsurprisingly subbed.

I'd say a 6 overall is fair.


RE: Ratings - Derek Hardballs - 05-12-2024

(05-12-2024, 05:43 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry but BTA 4? Nonsense, he’s playing on his own up front, putting pressure on their defence all match. He worked tirelessly against a team who are set-up to keep the ball in defence waiting to break through our press, the fact they didn’t for most of the game was due in part to BTA.

Sorry but I completely disagree with the criticism BTA has received after today’s match and tbh all season. Without him there are no play-offs.

Also those BTA stats are utter rubbish and prove you cannot judge a player or game properly with them in isolation from what is actually happening at the game.

I watched the game, I've acknowledged we wouldn't be in the playoffs without him.

I will acknowledge that he ran about a bit. Well done. The vast majority of the time when he got on the ball (which was hardly at all) things broke down.

I'd still start him next game, but that doesn't change his non-performance today.

(05-12-2024, 05:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:40 PM)Sliced Wrote: I didn't say he was limited, I said he did nothing today, which is true

No it’s not it’s drivel.

Ah sorry, he ran about a bit, that's worth at least a 6

Did you actually go to the game? Seriously Slice the criticism is way ott and bares little relation to what actually happened.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 05-12-2024

(05-12-2024, 05:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:43 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry but BTA 4? Nonsense, he’s playing on his own up front, putting pressure on their defence all match. He worked tirelessly against a team who are set-up to keep the ball in defence waiting to break through our press, the fact they didn’t for most of the game was due in part to BTA.

Sorry but I completely disagree with the criticism BTA has received after today’s match and tbh all season. Without him there are no play-offs.

Also those BTA stats are utter rubbish and prove you cannot judge a player or game properly with them in isolation from what is actually happening at the game.

I watched the game, I've acknowledged we wouldn't be in the playoffs without him.

I will acknowledge that he ran about a bit. Well done. The vast majority of the time when he got on the ball (which was hardly at all) things broke down.

I'd still start him next game, but that doesn't change his non-performance today.

(05-12-2024, 05:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:40 PM)Sliced Wrote: I didn't say he was limited, I said he did nothing today, which is true

No it’s not it’s drivel.

Ah sorry, he ran about a bit, that's worth at least a 6

Did you actually go to the game? Seriously Slice the criticism is way ott and bares little relation to what actually happened.

Yes I did. I thought he was poor on the ball and offered very little threat. I've said some of his off the ball movements were decent but on the ball it was poor. The stats seem to back that up and there seems to be some others saying that we really could have done with a striker up front.

When did having a difference of opinion have to turn into something else? Saying I'm a dick or implying I have something against Asante because I didn't rate him today. Saying "I don't think he had a good game, he hardly touched the ball, but I'd still start him next game" it not over the top criticism.

I shouldn't even have to clarify this before stating an opinion on one performance, but I like Asante. I think he's been a fantastic signing; but I hope he will be better on the ball next game than he was today.


RE: Ratings - Derek Hardballs - 05-12-2024

(05-12-2024, 05:54 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:43 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry but BTA 4? Nonsense, he’s playing on his own up front, putting pressure on their defence all match. He worked tirelessly against a team who are set-up to keep the ball in defence waiting to break through our press, the fact they didn’t for most of the game was due in part to BTA.

Sorry but I completely disagree with the criticism BTA has received after today’s match and tbh all season. Without him there are no play-offs.

Also those BTA stats are utter rubbish and prove you cannot judge a player or game properly with them in isolation from what is actually happening at the game.

I watched the game, I've acknowledged we wouldn't be in the playoffs without him.

I will acknowledge that he ran about a bit. Well done. The vast majority of the time when he got on the ball (which was hardly at all) things broke down.

I'd still start him next game, but that doesn't change his non-performance today.

(05-12-2024, 05:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 05:40 PM)Sliced Wrote: I didn't say he was limited, I said he did nothing today, which is true

No it’s not it’s drivel.

Ah sorry, he ran about a bit, that's worth at least a 6

Did you actually go to the game? Seriously Slice the criticism is way ott and bares little relation to what actually happened.

Yes I did. I thought he was poor on the ball and offered very little threat. I've said some of his off the ball movements were decent but on the ball it was poor. The stats seem to back that up and there seems to be some others saying that we really could have done with a striker up front.

When did having a difference of opinion have to turn into something else? Saying I'm a dick or implying I have something against Asante because I didn't rate him today. Saying "I don't think he had a good game, he hardly touched the ball, but I'd still start him next game" it not over the top criticism.

I shouldn't even have to clarify this before stating an opinion on one performance, but I like Asante. I think he's been a fantastic signing; but I hope he will be better on the ball next game than he was today.

I think we would all like a more complete striker / forward to play but we don’t have one currently so we have to rely on BTA. I just think that he was nowhere near the 4 mark in regards to his performance and that without him today they would have broke through our lines time and time again.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 05-12-2024

And that's fine, football discussion would be boring if we all had the same opinion Big Grin


RE: Ratings - Lurker#3 - 05-12-2024

Without seeing the stats, I would go;

Palmer - 8

Furlong - 7
Bartley - 8
Kipre - 7
Townsend - 7

Okay - 8
Mowatt - 7

Fellows - 8
Grady - 7
MJ - 7

BTA - 5


RE: Ratings - BurleyBaggie - 05-12-2024

Where was Maja today?


RE: Ratings - MancBaggie - 05-12-2024

Largely agree with Slice marks. Thought we were excellent for first 15 and edged 2nd half. For an open team - they took few risks. Thought we had better chances and deserved the win. Marks

Palmer 7.5. Largely untroubled but great save. Distribution was good - could of communicated better a couple of times to prevent corners

DF 8. Excellent today and kept some good players v quiet. Got crucial touches and blocks in that minimised their chances.

Townsend 7.5. Like last week, aggressive and defended well. Might have supported MJ a touch more but won a number of corners

Bart 8. The best game I’ve seen from him for a while. Kept AA v quiet and defended long balls well. Should of done better with headers Less comfortable against subs

Kipre 7.5. Solid and physical against their strikers. Got done couple of times by Mara. Might of done better with set piece chances

Okay 6.5. Solid first 45 but Leggy again 2nd half when their no 4 kept breaking. Won key defensive headers from their corners - that were all on the money

Mowatt. 7.5. Quiet first half but got on the ball second. Good energy and barely gave it away. Might have got a few more shots off

Grady 6.5. Decent shift off the ball but didn’t move it quickly enough when on it. Got crowded a lot when a quick layoff was needed. Should of done better with both chances

Tom 7. Some excellent crosses and cutbacks that should have been finished off. Disciplined against Manning - just got muscled a couple of times

MJ 6.5. Good outlet first half but really wasteful with end product. Better after the break and central to our good spell. Overhit crosses even then however

BTA. 6. V difficult role in the heat against 3 c halves. In fairness, when he did get possession we were slow to support and he lost it. Just needs to make more runs when we do have it - just to make the pitch bigger

Jed 6. Good running and closing but limited impact. Was raging on Friday after being left out

Swift 6. Tidy on the ball but no penetration with passes or end product. Need more from him

Semi 6.5. Solidified us after their attacking changes and used ball well. Bart may be a doubt Friday

Yann 6.5. Has looked sluggish but v aggressive in his cameo and put himself about and pressed really well

Reach 5.5. Slotted in ok for CT. Loses a mark for that ridiculous volley