WBAUnofficial
Just 4 non glory hunter clubs have won cup in last 30 years - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Just 4 non glory hunter clubs have won cup in last 30 years (/showthread.php?tid=33421)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Just 4 non glory hunter clubs have won cup in last 30 years - sickParrot - 04-22-2024

Not sure how true it is, but due to the speed of the frames on screen the margin of error is 7cm.

As I said to the wife, that's huge.


RE: Just 4 non glory hunter clubs have won cup in last 30 years - NewWanker - 04-22-2024

(04-22-2024, 02:29 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Not sure how true it is, but due to the speed of the frames on screen the margin of error is 7cm.

As I said to the wife, that's huge.

Think someone on 'ere said it was 713mm, so sounds the same... I then found this:

Let's imagine the 240hz frame rate with best frame selection, one player running while the other is perfectly still, the perfect pixel selection on a 4k image. Final margin of error: 7.13 cm

Let's imagine the 60hz frame rate with worst frame selection, players running in opposite directions, a miss by one pixel on each player on a 1080p image. Final margin of error: 179.24 cm

Table:

Frame Rate (hz) Reasonable Frames to Use Image Size Relative Player Speed Total pixels missed by Final Error Margin
240 2 2160p (4k) 20 kmph (12.4 mph) 0 7.13 cm (2.81 in)
240 2 2160p (4k) 70 kmph (43.5 mph) 0 18.66 cm (7.35 in)
240 2 2160p (4k) 0 kmph (0 mph) 0 2.52 cm (0.99 in)
240 2 1080p 20 kmph (12.4 mph) 0 13.72 cm (5.40 in)
60 2 1080p 20 kmph (12.4 mph) 2 35.74 cm (14.07 in)
60 5 1080p 70 kmph (43.5 mph) 2 179.24 cm (70.57 in)

Sorry for the bad formatting!

Someone then suggested calculate the margin of error and make the lines that thick so that it's a lot more visually appealing to viewers etc... any body part within that error margin is ignored... Far too sensible for them to use that though!

this Reddit (where I got the table from) seems to cover a lot of the technicalities:

https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/jtir5u/var_for_offside_margin_of_error/#:~:text=VAR%20is%20to%20be%20used,outside%20the%20margin%20or%20error.


RE: Just 4 non glory hunter clubs have won cup in last 30 years - MancBaggie - 04-22-2024

(04-22-2024, 02:29 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Not sure how true it is, but due to the speed of the frames on screen the margin of error is 7cm.

As I said to the wife, that's huge.

Big Grin Big Grin


RE: Just 4 non glory hunter clubs have won cup in last 30 years - aj21 - 04-22-2024

The play offs is about having that day out at Wembley and if you win it’ll make a memory you’ll always cherish. Going into the Prem has nothing exciting about it considering we have been there recently, the league is a complete bore.


RE: Just 4 non glory hunter clubs have won cup in last 30 years - Spandaubaggie - 04-22-2024

Just looked and Arsenal have won 9, Chelsea 7 and Man U 5 in the past 30 years. That's 2/3rds of cup wins shared between 3 clubs in the last 30 years. It's pitiful as a competition. The past decade in the League Cup is the same old faces too. Not since Swansea in 2013 have one of the less fashionable clubs won that.


RE: Just 4 non glory hunter clubs have won cup in last 30 years - Shabby Russian - 04-22-2024

Not so strange those who seek glory, attain glory.

Being a pedant, as I agree with the premise of the thread, just the title is a bit odd.

Also a lot of criticism about how var impacts on offside, all justified, but this has been going on since var was introduced ed, would have been a bit weird if they had ignored it for this game.

And if it is a conspiracy to ensure another all Manchester final, why didn't they overturn the penalty decision.


RE: Just 4 non glory hunter clubs have won cup in last 30 years - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 04-22-2024

(04-22-2024, 02:56 PM)NewWanker Wrote:
(04-22-2024, 02:29 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Not sure how true it is, but due to the speed of the frames on screen the margin of error is 7cm.

As I said to the wife, that's huge.

Think someone on 'ere said it was 713mm, so sounds the same... I then found this:

Let's imagine the 240hz frame rate with best frame selection, one player running while the other is perfectly still, the perfect pixel selection on a 4k image. Final margin of error: 7.13 cm

Let's imagine the 60hz frame rate with worst frame selection, players running in opposite directions, a miss by one pixel on each player on a 1080p image. Final margin of error: 179.24 cm

Table:

Frame Rate (hz) Reasonable Frames to Use Image Size Relative Player Speed Total pixels missed by Final Error Margin
240 2 2160p (4k) 20 kmph (12.4 mph) 0 7.13 cm (2.81 in)
240 2 2160p (4k) 70 kmph (43.5 mph) 0 18.66 cm (7.35 in)
240 2 2160p (4k) 0 kmph (0 mph) 0 2.52 cm (0.99 in)
240 2 1080p 20 kmph (12.4 mph) 0 13.72 cm (5.40 in)
60 2 1080p 20 kmph (12.4 mph) 2 35.74 cm (14.07 in)
60 5 1080p 70 kmph (43.5 mph) 2 179.24 cm (70.57 in)

Sorry for the bad formatting!

Someone then suggested calculate the margin of error and make the lines that thick so that it's a lot more visually appealing to viewers etc... any body part within that error margin is ignored... Far too sensible for them to use that though!

this Reddit (where I got the table from) seems to cover a lot of the technicalities:

https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/jtir5u/var_for_offside_margin_of_error/#:~:text=VAR%20is%20to%20be%20used,outside%20the%20margin%20or%20error.

Good fact’ING. They must surely use high FPS cameras like in t’lympics for 100m and stuff? And if not, why not?