WBAUnofficial
Here we go again - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Here we go again (/showthread.php?tid=33159)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24


RE: Here we go again - Derek Hardballs - 03-28-2024

Such great business men and women they are failing to run a ‘business’ ahem monopoly properly. They deserve those massive salaries…


RE: Here we go again - Protheroe - 03-28-2024

(03-28-2024, 09:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(03-28-2024, 12:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-28-2024, 11:11 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Just as with the banks, privatise the profits and nationalise the losses.
It's what capitalism does. And people don't bat an eyelid.
https://www.bbc.com/news/business-68682198

Government nationalised the banks losses. If markets had functioned as they ought to then the banks would've gone bust. Don't blame capitalism, blame government.

For the water companies, blame regulators and our nineteenth century sewers.


Capitalism has lifted billions out of extreme poverty world wide. We'd be far worse off without it.

1/ Re Banks. I too would not have been so keen to bail them out.  It is possible to blame both capitalism and government. In fact, it is the only sensible opinion.

2/ The regulators have been toothless in the face of such greed. Maybe we should look at the capitalists too? The tories sold off the water companies at a time Thames Water was not in debt. Since 1989 they have ran up debts of £15 Billion while paying out bonuses and dividends. Since Macquarie sold it on, Thames Water claims it has paid no dividends to "external shareholders". It has however reportedly paid over £200M  to other companies within the group. 

So are you saying that capitalism is a very good thing and needs to never be regulated? Or that capitalism should over_ride government ministers? Because it looks to me like capitalism fosters either, or both, greed and incompetence and should be subject to all the controls we can muster in order to protect the electorate. In the case of Thames Water, the greed has actually strayed beyond criminality and those responsible should be held to account.

It’s very clear what I said; government should enable markets and regulate them effectively. It’s also clear that governments are not very good at doing either in banking, housing, rail, water, broadcasting, postal services, legal services and accountancy (for example). 

You’re right about Thames being loaded with debt btw. It’s not alone amongst infrastructure companies.


RE: Here we go again - CaptainFantastico - 03-28-2024

(03-28-2024, 05:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-28-2024, 12:29 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: By the very same processes that it lifts some out it creates an equal amount that then come into being and exist within it. Like everything else in the world, it has an equal and opposite reaction.

Can you say that again in English?

(03-28-2024, 12:52 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Depends how you see government. I see it as simply as an agent of capital, doing capitalism's thing. You seem to see it as in some sort of independent or benign authority. I wouldn't agree with that.

I am with you on allowing banks to have gone bust though. Though I think it is a minority view.

I see government as a malign influence on many markets and the outcomes of markets for consumers. 

The 2019 Tory intake hasn't helped. Most of them have little or no experience of business or enterprise.

(03-28-2024, 01:40 PM)Ossian Wrote: I'll continue to blame that particular style of capitalism for the recklessness and lack of diligence which contributed to the scale of the financial sector's losses.

Hope that's okay.

That's perfectly OK. The Banks' behaviour existed within the regulatory frameworks created for it. The UK's regulatory framework created by Brown and continued by the Tories has also led to moribund returns from the FTSE and encouraged dangerous behaviour from pension funds in their bondholdings - as illustrated by one of the unintended consequences of Kwarteng's ludicrous Budget.

Governments' role ought to be to enable and regulate markets to ensure fair competition. Instead it interferes.

Sure. All the problems it appears to solve also inevitably produce a new set as a consequence. Ad infinitum (look it up)


RE: Here we go again - Shabby Russian - 03-29-2024

(03-28-2024, 12:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-28-2024, 11:11 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Just as with the banks, privatise the profits and nationalise the losses.
It's what capitalism does. And people don't bat an eyelid.
https://www.bbc.com/news/business-68682198

Government nationalised the banks losses. If markets had functioned as they ought to then the banks would've gone bust. Don't blame capitalism, blame government.

For the water companies, blame regulators and our nineteenth century sewers.

Capitalism has lifted billions out of extreme poverty world wide. We'd be far worse off without it.

The idea that capitalism has lifted billions out of extreme poverty is one that is widely stated, but those making it rarely have to justify it.
If they did I think they would struggle to do so.
In the UK for example, if it had been left to the capitalists then high levels of absolute poverty would have lasted far longer than they did.
There is no reason to believe that this would be any less true globally.


RE: Here we go again - Protheroe - 03-29-2024

(03-29-2024, 08:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The idea that capitalism has lifted billions out of extreme poverty is one that is widely stated, but those making it rarely have to justify it.
If they did I think they would struggle to do so.
In the UK for example, if it had been left to the capitalists then high levels of absolute poverty would have lasted far longer than they did.
There is no reason to believe that this would be any less true globally.

The adoption of markets by an otherwise awful regime has pretty much eradicated absolute poverty in China in a generation or two. How much more evidence do you need?

In the UK government used to recognise what it was for in the enablement and effective regulation of markets. As it is, crony capitalism and the nationalisation of risk threatens to condemn us all to tax servitude.

Grinding poverty exists only these days in states that eschew markets, property rights and the rule of law. Tell me I'm wrong?

(03-28-2024, 11:59 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Sure. All the problems it appears to solve also inevitably produce a new set as a consequence. Ad infinitum (look it up)

Really? "All the problems"?

So working fewer hours than ever, being better housed, educated, fed and clothed than ever - largely due to the magic of markets has thrown up what particular First World Problems in its place?

Externalties? Definitely. But all have been, are, or could be overcome with effective regulation and incentivisation.


RE: Here we go again - Ossian - 03-29-2024

One of the things I don't get about this Thames Water story (and it's equally applied to others previously) is that - unless Company Law has changed beyond all recognition from what I recall - dividends were only payable from any residual profits/reserves after Corporation Tax. So, if Thames water has been in a position to legitimately pay dividends, why has it needed to keep loading debt to the point where it is now all but insolvent? 

I'm guessing 'creative' use of Capital Allowances has played some part, although the state of the infrastructure would leave me wondering what capital investment has actually been taking place. 

Needs one of the finance professionals from the main board to unravel it for this bewildered layman.


RE: Here we go again - Shabby Russian - 03-29-2024

(03-29-2024, 08:41 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2024, 08:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The idea that capitalism has lifted billions out of extreme poverty is one that is widely stated, but those making it rarely have to justify it.
If they did I think they would struggle to do so.
In the UK for example, if it had been left to the capitalists then high levels of absolute poverty would have lasted far longer than they did.
There is no reason to believe that this would be any less true globally.

The adoption of markets by an otherwise awful regime has pretty much eradicated absolute poverty in China in a generation or two. How much more evidence do you need?

In the UK government used to recognise what it was for in the enablement and effective regulation of markets. As it is, crony capitalism and the nationalisation of risk threatens to condemn us all to tax servitude.

Grinding poverty exists only these days in states that eschew markets, property rights and the rule of law. Tell me I'm wrong?

(03-28-2024, 11:59 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Sure. All the problems it appears to solve also inevitably produce a new set as a consequence. Ad infinitum (look it up)

Really? "All the problems"?

So working fewer hours than ever, being better housed, educated, fed and clothed than ever - largely due to the magic of markets has thrown up what particular First World Problems in its place?

Externalties? Definitely. But all have been, are, or could be overcome with effective regulation and incentivisation.

You're simplistic in your reasoning Proth. You could easily say that China's authoritarian system of Govt, allows them to ensure a fairer distribution of wealth is a factor that reduces poverty as the adoption of market forces. In post war USSR it could be argued that there was a similar reduction in poverty, without the introduction of market forces.

And let's be honest neither China nor USSR should be held up as good adverts in the fight to eradicate poverty.

You keep asserting that property alleviates poverty, how so? Property denies those who do not own it the right to resource which can be a cause of poverty.


RE: Here we go again - Protheroe - 03-29-2024

The USSR and China reduced poverty by killing millions of their own citizens via famine. Only with the adoption of markets has China thrived. Russia went from planned economy to kleptocracy - it has neither free markets, nor property rights nor the rule of law. It exchanged one elite for another.

I haven’t suggested “property” alleviates poverty; however Property Rights independent of the State are essential for markets to thrive.


RE: Here we go again - DemonicBaggie - 03-29-2024

(03-28-2024, 09:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(03-28-2024, 12:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-28-2024, 11:11 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Just as with the banks, privatise the profits and nationalise the losses.
It's what capitalism does. And people don't bat an eyelid.
https://www.bbc.com/news/business-68682198

Government nationalised the banks losses. If markets had functioned as they ought to then the banks would've gone bust. Don't blame capitalism, blame government.

For the water companies, blame regulators and our nineteenth century sewers.


Capitalism has lifted billions out of extreme poverty world wide. We'd be far worse off without it.

1/ Re Banks. I too would not have been so keen to bail them out.  It is possible to blame both capitalism and government. In fact, it is the only sensible opinion.

2/ The regulators have been toothless in the face of such greed. Maybe we should look at the capitalists too? The tories sold off the water companies at a time Thames Water was not in debt. Since 1989 they have ran up debts of £15 Billion while paying out bonuses and dividends. Since Macquarie sold it on, Thames Water claims it has paid no dividends to "external shareholders". It has however reportedly paid over £200M  to other companies within the group. 

So are you saying that capitalism is a very good thing and needs to never be regulated? Or that capitalism should over_ride government ministers? Because it looks to me like capitalism fosters either, or both, greed and incompetence and should be subject to all the controls we can muster in order to protect the electorate. In the case of Thames Water, the greed has actually strayed beyond criminality and those responsible should be held to account.

Excellent. There can be no apologism for the rampant profiteering of companies that provide failing services and attempt to make tax payers foot the bill a la Thames Water.


RE: Here we go again - Protheroe - 03-29-2024

Who’s apologising for them?