![]() |
|
Stats and Ratings v Blues - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Stats and Ratings v Blues (/showthread.php?tid=32611) |
RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - Jerry - 02-07-2024 Unusual ratings for many of the players. Palmers almost lets a ball though his hands and still gets an 8, Furlong gets a perfect score, Bartley was uninterested, Townsend was only average, BTA worked is socks off alone upfront, Wallace and Fellows worked hard and created a few chances. Mowatt probably motm. Also subs scored to high for what they did but extra marks to Weimann for scoring. In general the way you are using statistics does not reflect what’s happening in the game. RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - Ted Maul - 02-07-2024 (02-07-2024, 08:23 AM)Jerry Wrote: In general the way you are using statistics does not reflect what’s happening in the game. It does, that's the point. RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - Jerry - 02-07-2024 (02-07-2024, 08:32 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:(02-07-2024, 08:23 AM)Jerry Wrote: In general the way you are using statistics does not reflect what’s happening in the game. Sorry but it does not ie Furlong playing a perfect game etc. RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - Lurker#3 - 02-07-2024 (02-07-2024, 08:23 AM)Jerry Wrote: Unusual ratings for many of the players. Palmers almost lets a ball though his hands and still gets an 8, Furlong gets a perfect score, Bartley was uninterested, Townsend was only average, BTA worked is socks off alone upfront, Wallace and Fellows worked hard and created a few chances. Mowatt probably motm. Also subs scored to high for what they did but extra marks to Weimann for scoring. So because Palmer NEARLY makes a mistake he shouldn't get a good score for keeping a clean sheet where the xG suggests they should have scored. Making 100% of saves required and also having solid distribution? 6 is average remember: Palmer; +1 for the saves and clean sheet and +1 for his distribution. Furlong; +1 for his assist, +1 for his defensive contribution, +1 for his standout performance in possession, +1 to make it the perfect score as he excelled in every area which is tough as fullback. Townsend; +1 for his defensive contribution, +1 for his vital role in possession. BTA; Graft is expected to achieve a 6 alone, he contributed nothing else. -1 for his poor finishing and game awareness. Marshall; +1 for his role in the goal and his good hold up play. Johnston; +1 for his effective carrying of the ball and the number of times he attempted to beat his man, one of which led to us getting on overload which resulted in Furlongs assist. Weimann; +2 for his goal, one for scoring, one for the quality of the finish. Stats are never a fool proof way of marking, but that's why I only use them to influence scores that I have given based on "what my eyes saw". RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - Jerry - 02-07-2024 (02-07-2024, 09:35 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(02-07-2024, 08:23 AM)Jerry Wrote: Unusual ratings for many of the players. Palmers almost lets a ball though his hands and still gets an 8, Furlong gets a perfect score, Bartley was uninterested, Townsend was only average, BTA worked is socks off alone upfront, Wallace and Fellows worked hard and created a few chances. Mowatt probably motm. Also subs scored to high for what they did but extra marks to Weimann for scoring. How is six the average, is this pulled from the air? The extra points given are not stistcically based as you have tried to claim, they are add ons and are just numbers you have given thus distorting the scores. The review of data is interesting but how you are using it is totally flawed. RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - Lurker#3 - 02-07-2024 (02-07-2024, 11:04 AM)Jerry Wrote:(02-07-2024, 09:35 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(02-07-2024, 08:23 AM)Jerry Wrote: Unusual ratings for many of the players. Palmers almost lets a ball though his hands and still gets an 8, Furlong gets a perfect score, Bartley was uninterested, Townsend was only average, BTA worked is socks off alone upfront, Wallace and Fellows worked hard and created a few chances. Mowatt probably motm. Also subs scored to high for what they did but extra marks to Weimann for scoring. Sorry mate, on previous fred I have done like this I state that 6 is the average, starting score, and then events/contributions/lack of are what gets +/- scored. I always do "what my eyes tell me" scores first before I even open the stats site. Read the above along side my original post. You'll see it's directly correlated with what data I have provided. If you disagree because you'd rather trust your eyes, that's fine, pal. Many prefer that way of viewing the game. If you think the data or application of said data is flawed, feel free to find some evidence which contradicts either. RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - Jerry - 02-07-2024 It is up to me find evidence to contradict how you have got the scores it is up to you to justify the methodology you use. If the starting point is 6 then do not call it an average. Adding marks as you have done gives Furlong a perfect score which cannot be correct or using your method can you get scores over 10? There are lies, dam lies, and statistics, I am not sure which camp you fall into. RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - Tom Joad - 02-07-2024 This Palmer "mistake". (Upthread). He saved it. Now he may have been thinking of tipping it over then realised he could keep it in. Or the flight of the ball varied so he just about got his hands behind it. Whatever it was, he saved a shot on target, it is not a mistake. RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - Jerry - 02-07-2024 (02-07-2024, 01:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: This Palmer "mistake". (Upthread). He saved it. Now he may have been thinking of tipping it over then realised he could keep it in. Or the flight of the ball varied so he just about got his hands behind it. Whatever it was, he saved a shot on target, it is not a mistake. He almost let a simple catch through his hands and was lucky to catch it before it went over the line. Simplest of saves for a professional keeper or parks pitch keeper. You have made comments on the scores did you or have you not seen the game? RE: Stats and Ratings v Blues - richbaggie - 02-07-2024 I'm trying to get my head around Bartley looking disinterested, absolutely not the case. He had a solid, no nonsense game and hardly put a foot wrong . |