WBAUnofficial
The Rwanda Policy - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The Rwanda Policy (/showthread.php?tid=31718)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Pipkins - 11-16-2023

(11-16-2023, 03:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 01:08 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 12:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It's optics for the hard of thinking.

We have and have had a chronic labour shortage in this country for a couple of decades. We have some of the most highly motivated individuals in the world literally often risking their lives to get here. Perhaps we could put them to work and give them residence status?

It's not often we are fully on the same page but I find it astounding this hasn't at some point become the incredibly obvious direction to take. Couldn't agree more.

We could, you know - train people to build the 300,000 houses we need each year....

Just a thought.

They could be built in Blackheath, London rather than Blackheath Rowley Regis
Meaning the property prices will fall and make affordable affordable to all rather than select few


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Protheroe - 11-16-2023

(11-16-2023, 03:13 PM)Pipkins Wrote: They could be built in Blackheath, London rather than Blackheath Rowley Regis
Meaning the property prices will fall and make affordable affordable to all rather than select few

For prices to fall we need to build a few decent sized cities in well connected areas that people actually want to live in. This is another basic truth that eludes polticians of all parties.


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Borin' Baggie - 11-16-2023

(11-16-2023, 03:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 03:13 PM)Pipkins Wrote: They could be built in Blackheath, London rather than Blackheath Rowley Regis
Meaning the property prices will fall and make affordable affordable to all rather than select few

For prices to fall we need to build a few decent sized cities in well connected areas that people actually want to live in. This is another basic truth that eludes polticians of all parties.

Based on the stuff coming out of Labour (grey belt) and the Lib Dems (garden cities in transit corridors) I can't disagree more.

It's just the Conservative Party leadership denying reality.


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Protheroe - 11-16-2023

But only the Tories and Labour matter. Labour is not proposing doing much more than the Tories were before your NIMBY campaign in Bucks.


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-16-2023

(11-16-2023, 12:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It's optics for the hard of thinking.

We have and have had a chronic labour shortage in this country for a couple of decades. We have some of the most highly motivated individuals in the world literally often risking their lives to get here. Perhaps we could put them to work and give them residence status?

The problem is this Government was elected on a mandate of "getting Brexit done" which included closing our borders, and limiting immigration, because that's what the ageing Tory demographic wanted. That's what they have to deliver. 

There is a chronic shortage of labour in the UK, particularly in the unskilled market (everyone has to start somewhere). This could have been turned into a Windrush style opportunity (not the Windrush scandal).


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Borin' Baggie - 11-16-2023

(11-16-2023, 03:35 PM)Protheroe Wrote: But only the Tories and Labour matter. Labour is not proposing doing much more than the Tories were before your NIMBY campaign in Bucks.

I'm not taking any accusations of NIMBYism from anyone that campaigned to scrap the 8 garden cities planned during the coalition.

And I think you'll find that while the Lib Dems went naïvely NIMBY in C&A (why I didn't help campaign for Sarah Green) the Tories went full BANANA and the Tories were also full BANANA before that if I highlight the 100 strong Tory MP group led by Seely and Villiers that actually were the reason for the weak zoning reforms being scrapped because the government sure hasn't given a shit about the stuff that has lost them so many seats to Labour and the Lib Dems. And need I remind you what the Tories response to the Lib Dem enhanced housing target was? Oh yeah, not to match it and then to scrap it so they have no target, again pandering to Villiers and that group of Tory MPs.


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Protheroe - 11-16-2023

I haven't been a member of the Conservative Party 3.5 years, and I didn't then and don't now support their housing policies.

It's neither here nor there how you personally feel about an accusation of the Lib Dems being NIMBYS. C&A wasn't the first time and definitely won't be the last. It's been a tactic of the party for as long as its been printing misleading bar charts on election leaflets. The Lib Dems can afford to appear to be all things to all people as they're never likely to be in power and have to deliver contradictory policies.

(11-16-2023, 03:42 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 12:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It's optics for the hard of thinking.

We have and have had a chronic labour shortage in this country for a couple of decades. We have some of the most highly motivated individuals in the world literally often risking their lives to get here. Perhaps we could put them to work and give them residence status?

The problem is this Government was elected on a mandate of "getting Brexit done" which included closing our borders, and limiting immigration, because that's what the ageing Tory demographic wanted. That's what they have to deliver. 

There is a chronic shortage of labour in the UK, particularly in the unskilled market (everyone has to start somewhere). This could have been turned into a Windrush style opportunity (not the Windrush scandal).

But there is no chance whatsoever of delivering this. That's why I say it's optics - they have to be seen to to be attempting to do something without actually having the ability to do anything.


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Borin' Baggie - 11-16-2023

(11-16-2023, 03:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I haven't been a member of the Conservative Party 3.5 years, and I didn't then and don't now support their housing policies.

It's neither here nor there how you personally feel about an accusation of the Lib Dems being NIMBYS. C&A wasn't the first time and definitely won't be the last. It's been a tactic of the party for as long as its been printing misleading bar charts on election leaflets. The Lib Dems can afford to appear to be all things to all people as they're never likely to be in power and have to deliver contradictory policies.

Scrapping the garden cities was 2015, you were a fully paid up member then so that cop out doesn't work. This has been a longstanding issue in the Conservative Party going back to the 1950s.

My response to the C&A campaign was to as a member of Liberal Reform within the party to push for a grassroots member-led review of the federal party housing policy and that led to the federal policy on housing at the last conference being codified into the party constitution (even the most pro-housing Tory MP, Simon Clarke, has praised it). It's the most fleshed out policy on housing from any party in Britain since the slum clearance plans and as it's written in black and white any party is able to copy it if they wish. And when the Lib Dems were last in government they managed to get through the first net increase of social housing in 30 years (14.1k lost last year btw), the 8 garden cities (scrapped by the Tories), preliminary legislation on land market reforms (abandoned by the Tories after 2015) and preliminary legislation for community land auctions (abandoned by the Tories after 2015). You keep arguing that housing has been the biggest issue for you but it's like you didn't even bother reading the 2015 Tory manifesto otherwise you'd have left the party well before you did.

Both Labour and Lib Dems have commitments to building houses and have developed strategies to do that. Meanwhile, the Conservative Party scrapped their house building targets (can't blame Lib Dems for that). Face it, the Tories are a deeply NIMBY party, and they have been for ages. You know full well how restrictive the 1990 T&CPA is and you know who was PM when that was drafted.


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-16-2023

(11-16-2023, 03:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I haven't been a member of the Conservative Party 3.5 years, and I didn't then and don't now support their housing policies.

It's neither here nor there how you personally feel about an accusation of the Lib Dems being NIMBYS. C&A wasn't the first time and definitely won't be the last. It's been a tactic of the party for as long as its been printing misleading bar charts on election leaflets. The Lib Dems can afford to appear to be all things to all people as they're never likely to be in power and have to deliver contradictory policies.

(11-16-2023, 03:42 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 12:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It's optics for the hard of thinking.

We have and have had a chronic labour shortage in this country for a couple of decades. We have some of the most highly motivated individuals in the world literally often risking their lives to get here. Perhaps we could put them to work and give them residence status?

The problem is this Government was elected on a mandate of "getting Brexit done" which included closing our borders, and limiting immigration, because that's what the ageing Tory demographic wanted. That's what they have to deliver. 

There is a chronic shortage of labour in the UK, particularly in the unskilled market (everyone has to start somewhere). This could have been turned into a Windrush style opportunity (not the Windrush scandal).

But there is no chance whatsoever of delivering this. That's why I say it's optics - they have to be seen to to be attempting to do something without actually having the ability to do anything.

It may well be optics, Proth, but they still have to deliver, otherwise the Opposition will hold them to account. Big Dog got them into this mess, and has now bailed out (before he was pushed).


RE: The Rwanda Policy - Protheroe - 11-16-2023

(11-16-2023, 04:18 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Both Labour and Lib Dems have commitments to building houses and have developed strategies to do that. 

Good for them and you.

The difference is you'll never be in a position to have to deliver, so I'll await with bated breath the inevitable anti development campaigns by local Lib Dems across the south of England.

(11-16-2023, 04:22 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It may well be optics, Proth, but they still have to deliver, otherwise the Opposition will hold them to account. Big Dog got them into this mess, and has now bailed out (before he was pushed).

Deliver what? 

It's like asking Pulis to deliver tika taka. You just know it's never going to happen.