![]() |
|
Has he got a point ? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Has he got a point ? (/showthread.php?tid=31327) |
RE: Has he got a point ? - CarlosCorbewrong - 09-30-2023 I'm sorry but "Thompson over Peace" is just daft. One showed promise but was ultimately successful (and dethroned) because of one man, Megson. The other genuinely built the club and gave us top flight foot all, fairly sustainably, throughout his tenure. I'm no fan boy of Peace but saying Thompson was better just isn't true by any objective measure RE: Has he got a point ? - Malcolm Tucker - 09-30-2023 Peace dropped massively lucky with Ashworth. Once he was gone, the wheels came off and right quick. This is why we ended up with short-term looking appointments like TCIC to protect his investment, while he sold us to the first idiot with cash on the hip. RE: Has he got a point ? - CarlosCorbewrong - 09-30-2023 (09-30-2023, 09:35 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Peace dropped massively lucky with Ashworth. Once he was gone, the wheels came off and right quick. This is why we ended up with short-term looking appointments like TCIC to protect his investment, while he sold us to the first idiot with cash on the hip. To provide balance to my previous posts praising Peace; this is all objectively true. RE: Has he got a point ? - fuzzbox - 09-30-2023 (09-30-2023, 09:20 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I'm sorry but "Thompson over Peace" is just daft. One showed promise but was ultimately successful (and dethroned) because of one man, Megson. It's just opinions. But here are my subjective reasons...
The only thing that has changed now, is that he is substantially richer. If that defines him as a success then so are most club owners from that time. Almost all clubs dramatically increased in value. I don't begrudge him, but his success is far outweighed by his failures. But I suppose it's how you define success. RE: Has he got a point ? - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-30-2023 Getting back to the OP, it seems on the face of it to be an unnecessarily aggressive and challenging statement. Certainly not one to appeal to the non-existent better nature of football fans. But if he and his family are getting direct and personal abuse from fans, and if fans' behaviour is costing the club in terms of reputation and money, then I fully understand his outburst. A full-on Cartmanesque "Screw you guys. I'm going home" would be my reaction. RE: Has he got a point ? - Tom Joad - 09-30-2023 I don't know if the Wednesday guy is a good egg or not but I know he badmouthed Big Dave. That's all I need to judge him. RE: Has he got a point ? - Derek Hardballs - 09-30-2023 (09-30-2023, 09:35 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Peace dropped massively lucky with Ashworth. Once he was gone, the wheels came off and right quick. This is why we ended up with short-term looking appointments like TCIC to protect his investment, while he sold us to the first idiot with cash on the hip. I wouldn’t say he was lucky given people were aware of Ashworth’s rising reputation in the game. He was astute in prioritising the position at that time, but the subsequent cheap replacements were poor and as you say meant the entire structure (which was failing no matter what anyone on here says) was torn up to ensure the sale of the club. Peace was good for the club when his own ambitions aligned with those of the club. RE: Has he got a point ? - lemon - 09-30-2023 One of the first things I remember Gary Megson saying when he joined the club was that he needed to get more players that had the mindset of what they could do for West Brom, rather that what West Brom could do for them. Unfortunately when it came to chairmanship, Jezza was in the latter category. Occasionally Jeremy Peace used his Business nous to create better times for the Albion, but in my opinion he always left the handbrake on just enough to play the ultimate end game of securing his own personal fortune. Some of the managerial appointments were 'cheap and nasty' e.g Irvine, and some of the signings also. I credit him for the best years I have seen as a supporter but his own desires ultimately restricted us from the potential that we could have reached. RE: Has he got a point ? - baggiebloke - 09-30-2023 Dan Ashworth coming to Albion was purely down to his mate Aidy Boothroyd pestering him. Ashworth had just turned 33. Peace got lucky. RE: Has he got a point ? - backsidebaggie - 09-30-2023 (09-30-2023, 12:15 PM)lemon Wrote: One of the first things I remember Gary Megson saying when he joined the club was that he needed to get more players that had the mindset of what they could do for West Brom, rather that what West Brom could do for them. Unfortunately when it came to chairmanship, Jezza was in the latter category. Potential we could have reached? Football is simply an ownership lottery. We got as high as anyone could under an owner that didn’t bankroll us. If Peace prevented us from reaching “potential”, that can only apply to who he sold us to. Anything before that, we completely reached our potential. |