![]() |
|
Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Formation v Personnel v Tactics (/showthread.php?tid=31286) Pages:
1
2
|
RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - CA Baggie - 09-25-2023 (09-24-2023, 08:38 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Who on here reckons we have any realistic chance of making top 6? Whatever formation we play I think the positions from 4th to 10th(Ish) are always up for grabs and we should be one of those teams in there fighting. Are Preston better than us on paper? They have a feel good factor and momentum, we still have a cloud overhead from the ownership. Zero atmosphere on Saturday. We have a squad imbalance and desperately need a bit of good luck on the injury front instead of the bad luck we’ve been having recently. And a few decisions to go our way, we’ve had the BTA goal at Leeds so far in the +column and the minus column has 2 at Blackburn and 1 at Bristol. RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Pontificator - 09-25-2023 I think choosing a formation, shape, style in defence & midfied from the squad is a conundrum. Fortunately for CC the front player is easy coz there's only one. Mowatt was very good on Saturday and gave him another selection problem. He has two players for every position and they are of similar ability ie distinctly average. I did like Sarmiento and Grady taking players on and I think they should be encouraged, but they need a midfield "on it" to cover when they give the ball away. I doubt we are going anywhere, but if CC fashions a team of 1st names on the teamsheet from that lot he will walk on water RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Bob Fossil - 09-25-2023 I think all players need a system to work to and get drilled in training. However, there has to be an element of freedom otherwise it becomes too rigid and regimental. That's why Pereira was such a Godsend, because he had the ability to be afforded freedom, which, in turn, created freedom for others, especially Diangana. Swift is probably the nearest we have to that now, but his workrate, compared to Pereira is not even close, especially out of possession. Sarmiento didn't appear to have that great a game on Saturday, but I hope he gets more opportunities and increased minutes, as he is definitely the sort of player that can create chances and change games. We can't seem to find the balance between defence and attack at present, which, perhaps perversely, is probably due to the gaps in midfield and absence of genuine wingbacks. I said at the start of the season, I expected a poor start and to improve towards the middle, once the squad was settled. First part has come true, just hope the next phase does too. RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Remi_Moses - 09-25-2023 With so many average players in our squad we don't have the luxury of giving any players freedom. The best teams IMO have a standard formation when they haven't got the ball. We're not very good at setting our stall out. CC is obviously working on it, but has limited resources. Man Ure of old were excellent at two banks of 4 and it served Fergy well for many years. It's a lot easier when you have quality players though. RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Tom Joad - 09-25-2023 I think Grady and Sarmiento need to attack the box more. They create panic amongst defenders and we would reap much benefit. To do this we need a midfield that understands when to drop and cover, and when to push forward. Having those two cross to an overworked BTA is pointless. RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Peachy - 09-25-2023 (09-25-2023, 12:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I think Grady and Sarmiento need to attack the box more. They create panic amongst defenders and we would reap much benefit. To do this we need a midfield that understands when to drop and cover, and when to push forward. Having those two cross to an overworked BTA is pointless. Spot on. For that to happen though they need to be playing higher up as a front 3 with BTA. Like Liverpool did with Mane, Firmino and Salah. I'm convinced that the best form of defence for us this season is to attack teams and try and out score them. I see no point trying to stay solid as invariably we concede or if we do manage to keep a clean sheet its at the cost of our attacking play and we draw a blank. We have better attacking options than defending ones so I'd play to our strengths imo. Let's be realistic. Are we going to get in the play offs playing like we are now? No. So we might as well just fucking go at teams..... RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Bob Fossil - 09-25-2023 (09-25-2023, 12:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I think Grady and Sarmiento need to attack the box more. They create panic amongst defenders and we would reap much benefit. To do this we need a midfield that understands when to drop and cover, and when to push forward. Having those two cross to an overworked BTA is pointless. Yeah, that's the point I was making. Not suggesting we give all 11 the freedom of the park in some kick and rush, back in goalie type scenario, but certain players need the shackles taking off to get us up the other end and put the oppo under pressure. We are too rigid at present and it's all a bit stinted. RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Lurker#3 - 09-25-2023 (09-25-2023, 12:55 PM)Peachy Wrote:(09-25-2023, 12:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I think Grady and Sarmiento need to attack the box more. They create panic amongst defenders and we would reap much benefit. To do this we need a midfield that understands when to drop and cover, and when to push forward. Having those two cross to an overworked BTA is pointless. The issue with that Peachy is Grady and Sarmiento are not strikers. That shape could work when we have Dike fit and BTA/Maja running off him. RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Woodman scoreboard - 09-25-2023 (09-24-2023, 08:38 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Who on here reckons we have any realistic chance of making top 6? Whatever formation we play We have no striker........simples midtable now that's before the firesale in January RE: Formation v Personnel v Tactics - Borin' Baggie - 09-25-2023 Molumby seems to be nullified by the system, he's not breaking the lines like he did last season which created space for the midfield. |