WBAUnofficial
Corberan/coaching/tactics - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Corberan/coaching/tactics (/showthread.php?tid=30946)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - Mr vertical - 08-20-2023

Maybe Carlos's tactics will make more sense when the window closes. I've only seen us at home but by and large we dictated against Swansea without playing well at all. There are obviously things to fix but we don't know what his ideal lineup is yet.


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - Stillclem4england - 08-20-2023

The OP is fair and you can’t argue with it. If we get new players in, fine, it could work but, without, he needs to find a system and style to suit the players and stick with it.

In fairness, I think the back five is a sticking plaster to cope with the lack of ability in a back four of our centre halves.


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - Birdman1811 - 08-20-2023

(08-20-2023, 10:33 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: The OP is fair and you can’t argue with it. If we get new players in, fine, it could work but, without, he needs to find a system and style to suit the players and stick with it.

In fairness, I think the back five is a sticking plaster to cope with the lack of ability in a back four of our centre halves.

In CC's defence, as I said in my post, there isn't a style that suits these players. As you say, the back three is basically a way of mitigating the issues the centre backs have, but it's not a solution.


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - Stratfordbaggie - 08-20-2023

It is only 3 games in, players will learn and adapt, if a player is only right footed, you do not just resort to only ever playing him on the right, you help him to improve his left foot ability.

Pep did not abandon his philosophy when he started at City, he took time to see which players can play the system and over time got players in who could, or help adapt the likes of Stones etc to play the system he wants to play…..give Carlos time


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - SW4Baggie - 08-20-2023

(08-20-2023, 10:36 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-20-2023, 10:33 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: The OP is fair and you can’t argue with it. If we get new players in, fine, it could work but, without, he needs to find a system and style to suit the players and stick with it.

In fairness, I think the back five is a sticking plaster to cope with the lack of ability in a back four of our centre halves.

In CC's defence, as I said in my post, there isn't a style that suits these players. As you say, the back three is basically a way of mitigating the issues the centre backs have, but it's not a solution.

And this is where CC is at Birdie. 

He knows more about football than anyone on this forum - even if he didn’t play the game - and anything obvious to us will be glaringly obvious to him… I’m sure he’s frustrated with the squad he’s inherited and the lack of movement he’s been able to have regarding transfers. All he can do is try and work on the weaknesses of the current players and find a way to get them to adapt to how he feels teams in general can be successful


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - TETLEY74 - 08-20-2023

(08-20-2023, 10:36 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-20-2023, 10:33 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: The OP is fair and you can’t argue with it. If we get new players in, fine, it could work but, without, he needs to find a system and style to suit the players and stick with it.

In fairness, I think the back five is a sticking plaster to cope with the lack of ability in a back four of our centre halves.

In CC's defence, as I said in my post, there isn't a style that suits these players. As you say, the back three is basically a way of mitigating the issues the centre backs have, but it's not a solution.

A lot of this squad have been asked to play almost every conceivable style of football and by and large have failed.


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - Peachy - 08-20-2023

(08-20-2023, 10:42 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: It is only 3 games in, players will learn and adapt, if a player is only right footed, you do not just resort to only ever playing him on the right, you help him to improve his left foot ability.

Pep did not abandon his philosophy when he started at City, he took time to see which players can play the system and over time got players in who could, or help adapt the likes of Stones etc to play the system he wants to play…..give Carlos time

Agree but the massive difference being once Pep had worked out who he needed he could go out and buy the best in class. Carlos can't even buy anyone. He has to wait to see who is available on a free/loan, then wait again until those players have chosen where they want to go, then pick through the carcass that is left.


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - GunsOfNavarone - 08-20-2023

(08-20-2023, 10:25 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Once we lost, and failed to replace Ashworth everything just fell apart. Made even worse by allowing McDonut to absolutely destroy what was left in his desperate grab for power.

And of course, some decisions since that were truly weird, the Terry Burton and Irvine experiment just proved that Peace really did just fall lucky with Ashworth.

As for CC. What way can we play with these players, can't lump it forward on the counter since no one can take a long ball down to hold it up. Can't invite pressure since our defence crumbles under the smallest bit of pressure. We don't have slick, ball retaining midfielders, so can't play a possession hungry, ball retentive game.

We've got a real mish-mash of players where there is no obvious style of play, all CC can do is try to get them to play how he likes and hope it does well enough.

And we haven't been playing a possession hungry ball retentive game with players who can't play it. If anything we're more direct than last season but we lack the required composure and outlet.

We're currently caught between two stools and it'll take a while to iron out the kinks. It'll take even longer without effective recruitment and squad progression.


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - SW4Baggie - 08-20-2023

(08-20-2023, 11:29 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(08-20-2023, 10:42 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: It is only 3 games in, players will learn and adapt, if a player is only right footed, you do not just resort to only ever playing him on the right, you help him to improve his left foot ability.

Pep did not abandon his philosophy when he started at City, he took time to see which players can play the system and over time got players in who could, or help adapt the likes of Stones etc to play the system he wants to play…..give Carlos time

Agree but the massive difference being once Pep had worked out who he needed he could go out and buy the best in class. Carlos can't even buy anyone. He has to wait to see who is available on a free/loan, then wait again until those players have chosen where they want to go, then pick through the carcass that is left.

Exactly. 

You either buy players for your system or you adapt your system to the players you have. Unfortunately for Carlos he has no money to bring players in, and the selection of players he has have no discernible system for success. The next option is to work with players to adapt their game, however we have an ageing squad with little motivation as most realise this is their last payday whether they adapt or not.

With quite a few contracts expiring this summer too I expect we will see a fair few players pulling out of challenges in the run in. It’s not like we can afford to extend contracts, even if we wanted to. Thoroughly expect to see Bartley, Phillips, Pieters, Reach and Co in the hydro pool from March.


RE: Corberan/coaching/tactics - Birdman1811 - 08-20-2023

Exactly.

What a fantastic state to be in as a club.