WBAUnofficial
Defending set pieces - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Defending set pieces (/showthread.php?tid=30879)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Defending set pieces - hudds - 08-12-2023

(08-12-2023, 04:18 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: We don’t have a centre half with the balls to come and make it theirs. Kipre doesn’t appear to know what defending is and Ajayi is more than happy to stand at the near post and watch the ball sail over his head.

Is roysh.  They stand off instead of getting a head to it or otherwise reacting quickly and decisively.


RE: Defending set pieces - ABBaggie - 08-12-2023

(08-12-2023, 04:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:08 PM)ABBaggie Wrote: Never understood why any team uses zonal marking and we paid the price massively today. Too easy for players to pass the buck. Have a couple of zones maybe, front post and a spare one in the middle, but let everyone else mark up properly.

Because it's super easy for intelligent players to break man marking. 

Both have benefits and flaws, any player developed last 15 years should be good at both, since both are trained throughout academies.

Both have their benefits of course, but I’ve just never felt that going with a predominantly zonal approach works. Way too easy for players to get a run on the ball as we saw with the first goal, the header off the line and the one just past the post. One delivery off of the expected line of the ball and no one gets anywhere near. At least if you let people man mark they are accountable. If Corberan wants to go with zonal because he believes it’s better or avoids the risks of possible fouls etc then fine, but he’s going to have to seriously tighten it up because it was a disaster on the evidence of today.


RE: Defending set pieces - wbamitch - 08-12-2023

Corners aside I thought we defended reasonably well and kept two very decent strikers for this level quiet


RE: Defending set pieces - MancBaggie - 08-12-2023

(08-12-2023, 04:25 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Corners aside I thought we defended reasonably well and kept two very decent strikers for this level quiet

We defended ok bar that ridiculous last 20 and 9 mins


RE: Defending set pieces - Birdman1811 - 08-12-2023

(08-12-2023, 04:21 PM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:08 PM)ABBaggie Wrote: Never understood why any team uses zonal marking and we paid the price massively today. Too easy for players to pass the buck. Have a couple of zones maybe, front post and a spare one in the middle, but let everyone else mark up properly.

Because it's super easy for intelligent players to break man marking. 

Both have benefits and flaws, any player developed last 15 years should be good at both, since both are trained throughout academies.

Both have their benefits of course, but I’ve just never felt that going with a predominantly zonal approach works. Way too easy for players to get a run on the ball as we saw with the first goal, the header off the line and the one just past the post. One delivery off of the expected line of the ball and no one gets anywhere near. At least if you let people man mark they are accountable. If Corberan wants to go with zonal because he believes it’s better or avoids the risks of possible fouls etc then fine, but he’s going to have to seriously tighten it up because it was a disaster on the evidence of today.

It's only fans that want accountability, for a coach it does nothing, and Zonal has accountability for them since they know who was taking which zone, it's fans that don't.

Man Marking often forgets runners into the box, it also allows big target men to take the best header in the defence away from where the ball is being delivered far too easily, making it easier to create a goal-scoring opportunity. With Zonal Marking, if the big target man isn't near the area the ball is usually delivered, but the defending teams best header is, it essentially removes that threat totally, meaning the opposition has to start making up Set Piece tactics on the fly. Sadly it requires intelligence and adaptability from defenders too, whereas Man Marking is very simple, but super easy to pass the buck when it goes wrong.


RE: Defending set pieces - Borin' Baggie - 08-12-2023

(08-12-2023, 04:32 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:21 PM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:08 PM)ABBaggie Wrote: Never understood why any team uses zonal marking and we paid the price massively today. Too easy for players to pass the buck. Have a couple of zones maybe, front post and a spare one in the middle, but let everyone else mark up properly.

Because it's super easy for intelligent players to break man marking. 

Both have benefits and flaws, any player developed last 15 years should be good at both, since both are trained throughout academies.

Both have their benefits of course, but I’ve just never felt that going with a predominantly zonal approach works. Way too easy for players to get a run on the ball as we saw with the first goal, the header off the line and the one just past the post. One delivery off of the expected line of the ball and no one gets anywhere near. At least if you let people man mark they are accountable. If Corberan wants to go with zonal because he believes it’s better or avoids the risks of possible fouls etc then fine, but he’s going to have to seriously tighten it up because it was a disaster on the evidence of today.

It's only fans that want accountability, for a coach it does nothing, and Zonal has accountability for them since they know who was taking which zone, it's fans that don't.

Man Marking often forgets runners into the box, it also allows big target men to take the best header in the defence away from where the ball is being delivered far too easily, making it easier to create a goal-scoring opportunity. With Zonal Marking, if the big target man isn't near the area the ball is usually delivered, but the defending teams best header is, it essentially removes that threat totally, meaning the opposition has to start making up Set Piece tactics on the fly. Sadly it requires intelligence and adaptability from defenders too, whereas Man Marking is very simple, but super easy to pass the buck when it goes wrong.

You need a mix, you have some players cover their zone but you also need to man mark the big men otherwise you're letting them come in with a running jump unchallenged. As happened today, Harding had a free run and nearly every time had a free header because he was running onto the ball. You can't zonal mark away biomechanics.

Yokuslu was covering Darling from set pieces until he went off.


RE: Defending set pieces - Birdman1811 - 08-12-2023

(08-12-2023, 04:26 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:25 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Corners aside I thought we defended reasonably well and kept two very decent strikers for this level quiet

We defended ok bar that ridiculous last 20 and 9 mins

Which is the problem.

Many will want to say CC messed up with the sybs, but we need to make subs, what would they have said if we hadn't, then exhaustion and even possibly injuries lead to them scoring goals too? There is a well-known phenomena in football. When the team ahead make subs, quite often, the pendulum of play swings to the losing team, it's why some managers wait for that first, then look at making subs themselves, rather than trying to force it with their own subs. 

Defenders are supposed to know that once subs are made, there is a chance they'll come under pressure, that's when you concentrate, give your all and do not make any mistakes. Evans, Gmac, Olsson, Dawson, even Hegazi were good at that, when the game swung towards the opposition, they just doubled down, acted the hero for a bit, and then when the confidence drained from the opposition, you take the game back. However our muppets just give the opposition confidence, leading to 2 very quick goals and we're in trouble. 

Yes you could argue CC shouldn't make subs, but that is JUST as risky, they may have then made subs which had the same effect, as I say far, far too often, it is a game with two sides in opposition, not one side and a bunch of NPC's. Doesn't help our subs often do weaken us because of how weak our squad is overall.

I just want to see our defence defend, that's all, and I get more and more disappointed every time I watch them try to, honestly, most League 1 teams are better defensively than we are.


RE: Defending set pieces - Birdman1811 - 08-12-2023

(08-12-2023, 04:35 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:32 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:21 PM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:08 PM)ABBaggie Wrote: Never understood why any team uses zonal marking and we paid the price massively today. Too easy for players to pass the buck. Have a couple of zones maybe, front post and a spare one in the middle, but let everyone else mark up properly.

Because it's super easy for intelligent players to break man marking. 

Both have benefits and flaws, any player developed last 15 years should be good at both, since both are trained throughout academies.

Both have their benefits of course, but I’ve just never felt that going with a predominantly zonal approach works. Way too easy for players to get a run on the ball as we saw with the first goal, the header off the line and the one just past the post. One delivery off of the expected line of the ball and no one gets anywhere near. At least if you let people man mark they are accountable. If Corberan wants to go with zonal because he believes it’s better or avoids the risks of possible fouls etc then fine, but he’s going to have to seriously tighten it up because it was a disaster on the evidence of today.

It's only fans that want accountability, for a coach it does nothing, and Zonal has accountability for them since they know who was taking which zone, it's fans that don't.

Man Marking often forgets runners into the box, it also allows big target men to take the best header in the defence away from where the ball is being delivered far too easily, making it easier to create a goal-scoring opportunity. With Zonal Marking, if the big target man isn't near the area the ball is usually delivered, but the defending teams best header is, it essentially removes that threat totally, meaning the opposition has to start making up Set Piece tactics on the fly. Sadly it requires intelligence and adaptability from defenders too, whereas Man Marking is very simple, but super easy to pass the buck when it goes wrong.

You need a mix, you have some players cover their zone but you also need to man mark the big men otherwise you're letting them come in with a running jump unchallenged. As happened today, Harding had a free run and nearly every time had a free header because he was running onto the ball. You can't zonal mark away biomechanics.

Yokuslu was covering Darling from set pieces until he went off.

Usually it is a bit of a mix. Very few teams use purely one or other. Darling shouldn't have been on the pitch mind, but whoever replaced Yokuslu should then have been picking up Darling.


RE: Defending set pieces - Borin' Baggie - 08-12-2023

(08-12-2023, 04:41 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:35 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:32 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:21 PM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Because it's super easy for intelligent players to break man marking. 

Both have benefits and flaws, any player developed last 15 years should be good at both, since both are trained throughout academies.

Both have their benefits of course, but I’ve just never felt that going with a predominantly zonal approach works. Way too easy for players to get a run on the ball as we saw with the first goal, the header off the line and the one just past the post. One delivery off of the expected line of the ball and no one gets anywhere near. At least if you let people man mark they are accountable. If Corberan wants to go with zonal because he believes it’s better or avoids the risks of possible fouls etc then fine, but he’s going to have to seriously tighten it up because it was a disaster on the evidence of today.

It's only fans that want accountability, for a coach it does nothing, and Zonal has accountability for them since they know who was taking which zone, it's fans that don't.

Man Marking often forgets runners into the box, it also allows big target men to take the best header in the defence away from where the ball is being delivered far too easily, making it easier to create a goal-scoring opportunity. With Zonal Marking, if the big target man isn't near the area the ball is usually delivered, but the defending teams best header is, it essentially removes that threat totally, meaning the opposition has to start making up Set Piece tactics on the fly. Sadly it requires intelligence and adaptability from defenders too, whereas Man Marking is very simple, but super easy to pass the buck when it goes wrong.

You need a mix, you have some players cover their zone but you also need to man mark the big men otherwise you're letting them come in with a running jump unchallenged. As happened today, Harding had a free run and nearly every time had a free header because he was running onto the ball. You can't zonal mark away biomechanics.

Yokuslu was covering Darling from set pieces until he went off.

Usually it is a bit of a mix. Very few teams use purely one or other. Darling shouldn't have been on the pitch mind, but whoever replaced Yokuslu should then have been picking up Darling.

So... Chalobah.


RE: Defending set pieces - ABBaggie - 08-12-2023

(08-12-2023, 04:32 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:21 PM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2023, 04:08 PM)ABBaggie Wrote: Never understood why any team uses zonal marking and we paid the price massively today. Too easy for players to pass the buck. Have a couple of zones maybe, front post and a spare one in the middle, but let everyone else mark up properly.

Because it's super easy for intelligent players to break man marking. 

Both have benefits and flaws, any player developed last 15 years should be good at both, since both are trained throughout academies.

Both have their benefits of course, but I’ve just never felt that going with a predominantly zonal approach works. Way too easy for players to get a run on the ball as we saw with the first goal, the header off the line and the one just past the post. One delivery off of the expected line of the ball and no one gets anywhere near. At least if you let people man mark they are accountable. If Corberan wants to go with zonal because he believes it’s better or avoids the risks of possible fouls etc then fine, but he’s going to have to seriously tighten it up because it was a disaster on the evidence of today.

It's only fans that want accountability, for a coach it does nothing, and Zonal has accountability for them since they know who was taking which zone, it's fans that don't.

Man Marking often forgets runners into the box, it also allows big target men to take the best header in the defence away from where the ball is being delivered far too easily, making it easier to create a goal-scoring opportunity. With Zonal Marking, if the big target man isn't near the area the ball is usually delivered, but the defending teams best header is, it essentially removes that threat totally, meaning the opposition has to start making up Set Piece tactics on the fly. Sadly it requires intelligence and adaptability from defenders too, whereas Man Marking is very simple, but super easy to pass the buck when it goes wrong.

Game of opinions at the end of the day so no point continuing to discuss as we see it differently, but whether it’s the principle of zonal marking or simply the poor application of instructions that was the cause it was a complete disaster today and I’d be changing it. Best of both world’s, a couple of zones to cover dangerous areas with everyone else picked up is the way I’d go. Let’s see how CC manages it, but clear he needs to do something because it will cost us over the season if he doesn’t. He clearly isn’t a daft guy though, so sure he will sort something.