WBAUnofficial
Defense - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Defense (/showthread.php?tid=30781)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Defense - MGalea - 08-06-2023

I disagree about it being soul destroying for Taylor!

Kipre is shite but he’s consistently been playing championship football for multiple seasons.

I’m reverse I reckon Taylor is thinking - if they keep playing like that for a couple more then his chance is coming.

However he is very young and will make mistakes - will we just ruin his confidence by throwing him in to this shit show?


RE: Defense - Mr Nimbus - 08-06-2023

Last year Dara was the key to our way of playing. It was his job to take the ball from the keeper, stay composed and begin playing through the lines. When he was injured that role fell to Yokuslu to retreat past the back four and do the same as its was obvious CC didn't trust the other CBs to do that job. However it was very much a stop gap awaiting Dara's return.

I am100% sure that CC would love to get a technically proficient CB through the door to.do the job, but they go for £7million dont you know, so he's trying to work with what he is left with. I fully expected Kipre to start as by all accounts he is the best on the ball, but it was a known risk. It is all down to recruitment, of our CBs two were bought from teams being relegated to league one and Barts well what can you say....

I expect to see more experimentation in order to get a balance, that may include Taylor? but I have no idea what type of a defender he is (unit is all i know) unless the recruitment team can magic up a CB and we send one of ours out on loan. But who would want them?


RE: Defense - Stillclem4england - 08-06-2023

Good post Birdie. Agree pretty much 100% with all of that.

(08-06-2023, 06:28 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: Last year Dara was the key to our way of playing.  It was his job to take the ball from the keeper, stay composed and begin playing through the lines.  When he was injured that role fell to Yokuslu to retreat past the back four and do the same as its was obvious CC didn't trust the other CBs to do that job.  However it was very much a stop gap awaiting Dara's return.

I am100% sure that CC would love to get a technically proficient CB through the door to.do the job, but they go for £7million dont you know, so he's trying to work with what he is left with.  I fully expected Kipre to start as by all accounts he is the best on the ball, but it was a known risk.  It is all down to recruitment, of our CBs two were bought from teams being relegated to league one and Barts well what can you say....

I expect to see more experimentation in order to get a balance, that may include Taylor? but I have no idea what type of a defender he is (unit is all i know) unless the recruitment team can magic up a CB and we send one of ours out on loan.  But who would want them?
If you don’t have the players I’d suggest you find a different way of playing then.


RE: Defense - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-06-2023

My concern is less about the quality of the players available and more about the way CC wants them to play. He doesn't seem able to coach a defence properly. Pieters' many years of experience carried us through last season. You can't rely on players' innate ability, you have to establish a system that works. Graeme Jones fucked things up for Big Dave with his playing out from the back nonsense. It will cost us again.

I'm astounded that Lurker is still prepared to play down Dara O'Shea's ability. Losing him may have kept us in business, but it's a disaster for the quality of our squad.


RE: Defense - Lurker#3 - 08-06-2023

(08-06-2023, 07:42 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My concern is less about the quality of the players available and more about the way CC wants them to play. He doesn't seem able to coach a defence properly. Pieters' many years of experience carried us through last season. You can't rely on players' innate ability, you have to establish a system that works. Graeme Jones fucked things up for Big Dave with his playing out from the back nonsense. It will cost us again.

I'm astounded that Lurker is still prepared to play down Dara O'Shea's ability. Losing him may have kept us in business, but it's a disaster for the quality of our squad.

I am not down playing his ability. I was just pointing out that Dara was still at his best playing along side a more senior player. 

I was gutted Dara left, one of my favourite recent players in fact.


RE: Defense - Tom Joad - 08-06-2023

(08-06-2023, 07:47 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-06-2023, 07:42 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My concern is less about the quality of the players available and more about the way CC wants them to play. He doesn't seem able to coach a defence properly. Pieters' many years of experience carried us through last season. You can't rely on players' innate ability, you have to establish a system that works. Graeme Jones fucked things up for Big Dave with his playing out from the back nonsense. It will cost us again.

I'm astounded that Lurker is still prepared to play down Dara O'Shea's ability. Losing him may have kept us in business, but it's a disaster for the quality of our squad.

I am not down playing his ability. I was just pointing out that Dara was still at his best playing along side a more senior player. 

I was gutted Dara left, one of my favourite recent players in fact.
Dara was way better than given credit for. I reckon Kompany ought to know. I just don't buy this "experienced player" mantra, anyone looks better with someone good nearby, Dara played alongside our clowns and generally was good. He goes, look what happens.


RE: Defense - Cunninghamismagic - 08-06-2023

*DefenCe (unless you are from America)
Agree with the point about the way he wants them to play. Similar issue under Moore/Jones. Asking defenders not capable to try and play like Man City. Then we had likes of Gayle, J Rod and Barnes who could help us outscore teams after sloppy goals were conceded


RE: Defense - NewWanker - 08-06-2023

Any side that has Kipre in is struggling. Yet some on here were calling, nay happy, for him to be back and playing. The rest of them have been in situ too long and are too comfortable. Yet are guaranteed to make mistakes.

When the defence is bad then you need to score to make up for it, nothing to do with entertaining just it becomes a total necessity. We can neither defend nor score enough to make up for it. Most of this defence was here under Slav and most pointed out how frail it was back then, thankfully we made up for it the other end. This is not new, but that's what, 4 managers or is it 5? Who have done fuck all about it.

I don't even think we make it to being average at this stage.


RE: Defense - Jerry - 08-06-2023

The first goal was down to Townsend’s bad play in allowing to get so easily robbed of the ball. Ok that happens but just seen the highlights and can anyone tell me why he did not then run back to help defend his mistake.
We have needed new CF for the last 2 to 3 years at least, this is not a new problem and the question is why has it not been addressed.


RE: Defense - Stillclem4england - 08-06-2023

(08-06-2023, 09:01 AM)Jerry Wrote: The first goal was down to Townsend’s bad play in allowing to get so easily robbed of the ball. Ok that happens but just seen the highlights and can anyone tell me why he did not then run back to help defend his mistake.
We have needed new CF for the last 2 to 3 years at least, this is not a new problem and the question is why has it not been addressed.
There were ample opportunities to stop the first after CT’s mistake. I’d be amazed if Pulis’ team or Megson’s first promotion team had not prevented that goal in the next phase.