WBAUnofficial
Culture wars - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Culture wars (/showthread.php?tid=30697)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Culture wars - Borin' Baggie - 08-01-2023

(08-01-2023, 05:28 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Just so as I’m clear how are we ‘exploiting our energy resources’?

By banning the construction of onshore wind farms and photovoltaic power stations.

Oh, wait. Almost like that line the Tories are using is actually full of shit and it's just being used as a cover for pandering to their gas lobby masters again.


RE: Culture wars - baggy1 - 08-01-2023

Is someone going to explain to Proth about the subsidies given to the oil industry to encourage them to drill so he can compare that to the tax revenues


RE: Culture wars - CaptainFantastico - 08-01-2023

I see Rishi has been looking after his father in law in all this.

Nothing ever changes with that bunch of cunts


RE: Culture wars - Protheroe - 08-01-2023

(08-01-2023, 06:06 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-01-2023, 05:28 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Just so as I’m clear how are we ‘exploiting our energy resources’?

By banning the construction of onshore wind farms and photovoltaic power stations.

Oh, wait. Almost like that line the Tories are using is actually full of shit and it's just being used as a cover for pandering to their gas lobby masters again.

Oh, we’re back to pathetic binary arguments again are we? We will need oil and gas for decades but so much better for us to leave it all in the ground and buy it off dictators worldwide.


RE: Culture wars - baggy1 - 08-01-2023

If we take it out of the ground do you
a) think we can use it to our hearts content
b) be sent to the international market

And then the companies drilling it will make profits from which we will collect taxes. Which we will give back to the oil companies in subsidies for them to drill oil.

Brilliant


RE: Culture wars - Protheroe - 08-01-2023

We will need to use oil and gas for decades. A great deal of it will be required to engineer the great electric utopia you crave.

Would you rather all of that under our feet is left there whilst we just buy it from others? It's a simple question.


RE: Culture wars - baggy1 - 08-02-2023

Do you think that we will get to use the oil ourselves or sell it into the international market? It’s a simpler question


RE: Culture wars - Borin' Baggie - 08-02-2023

(08-01-2023, 09:17 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-01-2023, 06:06 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-01-2023, 05:28 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Just so as I’m clear how are we ‘exploiting our energy resources’?

By banning the construction of onshore wind farms and photovoltaic power stations.

Oh, wait. Almost like that line the Tories are using is actually full of shit and it's just being used as a cover for pandering to their gas lobby masters again.

Oh, we’re back to pathetic binary arguments again are we? We will need oil and gas for decades but so much better for us to leave it all in the ground and buy it off dictators worldwide.

The UK's capacity to sell oil and gas into the global market is the square root of fuck all, look at the the available extraction data. That includes the proposed expansion. It's a drop in the ocean, even with this we'll be 99% reliant on external extraction compared to 100%, wow what a huge difference. The only valid argument for accelerated extraction from the North Sea is to cover domestic heating while there is a transition to electric heating - but even to justify that over the medium term you would need to block the gas extracted from the internal markets which makes no sense. That's why there's been divestment from the oil and gas market in the UK, it makes zero sense from an economic perspective to extract oil and gas from the UK-controlled North Sea - unless it's heavily subsidised which it most definitely should not be.

As for "needing oil and gas for decades" we can rapidly reduce our reliance on it through better usage of available plastics (including more aggressive recycling), and accelerate the transition to biopolymers. Saying we need oil and gas is purely a copout to excuse doing anything to wean ourselves off it.


RE: Culture wars - Protheroe - 08-02-2023

(08-02-2023, 06:46 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:  Saying we need oil and gas is purely a copout to excuse doing anything to wean ourselves off it.

How do you expect us to cost effectively wean ourselves off gas for domestic heating in particular? The cost of doing so is absolutely prohibitive for the vast majority of people in existing homes, never mind the practicalities of doing so. I also read MOTO is complaining that they can't turn on the vehicle chargers they've been told by the government to install up and down the country because the network hasn't been reinforced - so how on Earth would the network be able to cope with hundreds of thousands of new heat pumps? 

The easy wins in the pursuit of net zero have already been made. The pursuit of further gains is now colliding with the reality of the cost. The bizarre onshore wind moratorium will have to go, we'll have to burn gas for baseload for another generation at least in the absence of new nuclear.

I will be keen to see how the next Labour government proposes to deal with the challenges of cost and practicality - as historically neither has been their strength any more than it has been for the Tories.

All I see at the moment is the end of cheap / convenient mass personal transportation as we know it, huge costs and practical challenges for most households to come off gas and the denial of foreign holidays to all but the elite within a generation.

No one voted for any of that. 

You may believe it's a cop out, I don't believe the public will put up with literal impoverishment, or the impoverishment of aspiration in the pursuit of the pyrrhic attainment of net zero by some arbitrary false deadline.


RE: Culture wars - HawkingsHalfpint - 08-02-2023

(08-01-2023, 04:35 PM)Protheroe Wrote: They're attempting to create clear blue water between themselves and Labour.

I don't think it's particularly controversial to exploit your energy resources and tax them. After all, we and the rest of the world will all need oil and gas for many more decades yet.

'Tis true. 

But to pre-empt another common misconception of "oh well why should we bother whilst BRICS economies continue pumping shite into the atmosphere", well a lot of that is changing also. China have just switched on the largest wind-turbine in the world; most wind OEMs have manufacturing sites in India.

But what isn't being reported enough (and an inconvenient truth for the likes of JSO, because of how fascist it makes them appear) is that if the Oil & Gas taps were to be shut-off immediately tomorrow, billions would die pretty quickly. 

We are transitioning, slowly. But it will take time; meanwhile we have to read about it ad-nauseum every day, because it worries people and worried people generate revenue. 

There are also reasons beyond the climate which make self-sufficiency in renewables very much a common sense policy to adopt.