WBAUnofficial
The accounts are out - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The accounts are out (/showthread.php?tid=3027)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: The accounts are out - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 04-01-2019

(04-01-2019, 08:50 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-01-2019, 08:43 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(04-01-2019, 08:34 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-01-2019, 07:51 AM)Pontificator Wrote: We'll still be fucked if we don't go up; even if we'd been in a 5 million surplus. This season although 5/8s enjoyable compared to last is like last an utter clusterfuck. The appointment of Moore & Jones was a mistake and their late sacking compounded it. It may have consigned us to a middle of the Championship team with the only target avoiding relegation and beating Birmingham City. The thing is it may be a play off game against Villa that do it to us

I don’t share your pessimism if we don’t go up.

Sell Rondon and Burke - neither of whom play for us now, and we’ll raise close to £25m without any loss of playing personnel. That £25m will go a long way - our parachute funding only drops by £8m next season, so that leaves £17m.  Release Barry and Morrison, possibly Brunt as well, and that’s big wages gone, along with the wages of the 6 loanees (5 of which will inevitably be replaced with 5 new .  Quite likely that Dawson, Hegazi, Gibbs, Phillips and Rodriguez would be sold - another £50m sales and around £180k/week more off the wage bill.

Puts us in a perfect position to recruit very talented younger versions with resale value.  A rebuild is necessary regardless of which division we are in. 

The key of course is having the right coach and the right DoF to deliver.

I shared your optimism until the last sentence.

We absolutely have to get it right.

Absolutely. But will we....


RE: The accounts are out - Pontificator - 04-01-2019

(04-01-2019, 08:34 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-01-2019, 07:51 AM)Pontificator Wrote: We'll still be fucked if we don't go up; even if we'd been in a 5 million surplus. This season although 5/8s enjoyable compared to last is like last an utter clusterfuck. The appointment of Moore & Jones was a mistake and their late sacking compounded it. It may have consigned us to a middle of the Championship team with the only target avoiding relegation and beating Birmingham City. The thing is it may be a play off game against Villa that do it to us

I don’t share your pessimism if we don’t go up.

Sell Rondon and Burke - neither of whom play for us now, and we’ll raise close to £25m without any loss of playing personnel. That £25m will go a long way - our parachute funding only drops by £8m next season, so that leaves £17m.  Release Barry and Morrison, possibly Brunt as well, and that’s big wages gone, along with the wages of the 6 loanees (5 of which will inevitably be replaced with 5 new .  Quite likely that Dawson, Hegazi, Gibbs, Phillips and Rodriguez would be sold - another £50m sales and around £180k/week more off the wage bill.

Puts us in a perfect position to recruit very talented younger versions with resale value.  A rebuild is necessary regardless of which division we are in. 

The key of course is having the right coach and the right DoF to deliver.

You don't share my pessimism and then go on to underline exactly why I'm pessimistic. Also selling Brunt would be a huge error as he should play every game, just for his dead ball kicking. And then recruiting superstars FFS. I'm drawn to the conclusion that you don't live in the real world.


RE: The accounts are out - Pragmatist - 04-01-2019

(04-01-2019, 08:51 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(04-01-2019, 08:34 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-01-2019, 07:51 AM)Pontificator Wrote: We'll still be fucked if we don't go up; even if we'd been in a 5 million surplus. This season although 5/8s enjoyable compared to last is like last an utter clusterfuck. The appointment of Moore & Jones was a mistake and their late sacking compounded it. It may have consigned us to a middle of the Championship team with the only target avoiding relegation and beating Birmingham City. The thing is it may be a play off game against Villa that do it to us

I don’t share your pessimism if we don’t go up.

Sell Rondon and Burke - neither of whom play for us now, and we’ll raise close to £25m without any loss of playing personnel. That £25m will go a long way - our parachute funding only drops by £8m next season, so that leaves £17m.  Release Barry and Morrison, possibly Brunt as well, and that’s big wages gone, along with the wages of the 6 loanees (5 of which will inevitably be replaced with 5 new .  Quite likely that Dawson, Hegazi, Gibbs, Phillips and Rodriguez would be sold - another £50m sales and around £180k/week more off the wage bill.

Puts us in a perfect position to recruit very talented younger versions with resale value.  A rebuild is necessary regardless of which division we are in. 

The key of course is having the right coach and the right DoF to deliver.

You don't share my pessimism and then go on to underline exactly why I'm pessimistic. Also selling Brunt would be a huge error as he should play every game, just for his dead ball kicking. And then recruiting superstars FFS. I'm drawn to the conclusion that you don't live in the real world.

What on earth are you talking about?

We need to sell multiple players regardless of what division we are in. Some are not good enough for the PL if we go up, while others will not want a second season outside the PL and will have several options in the PL.  That means we need to replace them.  

I’m a big Brunt fan. I said “possibly” sell him.  He’s old and getting older. At some point soon his legs will have gone.  I’d love to keep him - if he can still play a role.


Where did I say anything about “recruiting superstars”? I’m talking about signing very good, younger Championship players with resale potential. There are lots of them in this division. Some of them already would cost too much - that’s why our recruitment needs to be a lot better.  The likes of Dack, Lolley, Bowen etc were all much more affordable a year ago and look at their values now.

I can assure you that my world at least is very real.


RE: The accounts are out - Kit Kat Chunky - 04-01-2019

(04-01-2019, 08:34 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-01-2019, 07:51 AM)Pontificator Wrote: We'll still be fucked if we don't go up; even if we'd been in a 5 million surplus. This season although 5/8s enjoyable compared to last is like last an utter clusterfuck. The appointment of Moore & Jones was a mistake and their late sacking compounded it. It may have consigned us to a middle of the Championship team with the only target avoiding relegation and beating Birmingham City. The thing is it may be a play off game against Villa that do it to us

I don’t share your pessimism if we don’t go up.

Sell Rondon and Burke - neither of whom play for us now, and we’ll raise close to £25m without any loss of playing personnel. That £25m will go a long way - our parachute funding only drops by £8m next season, so that leaves £17m.  Release Barry and Morrison, possibly Brunt as well, and that’s big wages gone, along with the wages of the 6 loanees (5 of which will inevitably be replaced with 5 new .  Quite likely that Dawson, Hegazi, Gibbs, Phillips and Rodriguez would be sold - another £50m sales and around £180k/week more off the wage bill.

Puts us in a perfect position to recruit very talented younger versions with resale value.  A rebuild is necessary regardless of which division we are in. 

The key of course is having the right coach and the right DoF to deliver.

I agree, that we have one last roll of the dice, Prag,  and the sales together with the loss of wages you suggest will leave us in a decent place.

For me the key is not to have "Dads Army", but to recruit some good young players.

If we look at the relegation season, we lost c£7M. Crucially the cash was drained as well, hence we needed an overdraft. Losses do not equate to cash, they are two very different things (as you know  Smile ), and I'll have a look at the cashflow when I have time. But with c£30M drained out of cash, and wages up to £90M, we were living beyond our means. What would have happened if we had stayed up though? It was only delaying the inevitable. The ageing squad would have been 1 year older, no players with any resale value, and the rest on comfy contracts and going nowhere. This is why clubs like us have to be relegated, so we can clear the decks and start again.


RE: The accounts are out - Lightnin - 04-01-2019

The staggering ratio of wages against income is just plain barmy and someone wasn't looking at this right which left us in a complete mess. I don't know what the flex was for relegation in the players contracts but it needs to be quite a chunk or the losses next season could be quite damaging with our parachute payment dropping and the Premier League income.

On a positive note, the losses we are allowed under FFP, taking into account the relgation from the Premier League are on the good side and do leave us quite a large room for manouver over the next 2 seasons when you take into account that players that we haven't seen this season like Rondon, Burke and to a lesser extent Nyom all have a resale value that can cover a large gap should they leave. There is room for optimism that we might be able to keep the spine of this squad together for one more season should we fail this season but we certainly need to start integrating good younger players into our squad as others have mentioned. Whether thats players from this league or good young Premier league players not getting game time then lets hope someone has a list of names.


RE: The accounts are out - Squid - 04-01-2019

I can't see us getting much for Burke, he sat on the bench on Saturday. Hegazi, on the other hand, will bring in a tidy sum.

Interesting point about us needing to be relegated to clear the decks, but it all points to a lack of forward planning.


RE: The accounts are out - Pragmatist - 04-01-2019

(04-01-2019, 09:09 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-01-2019, 08:34 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-01-2019, 07:51 AM)Pontificator Wrote: We'll still be fucked if we don't go up; even if we'd been in a 5 million surplus. This season although 5/8s enjoyable compared to last is like last an utter clusterfuck. The appointment of Moore & Jones was a mistake and their late sacking compounded it. It may have consigned us to a middle of the Championship team with the only target avoiding relegation and beating Birmingham City. The thing is it may be a play off game against Villa that do it to us

I don’t share your pessimism if we don’t go up.

Sell Rondon and Burke - neither of whom play for us now, and we’ll raise close to £25m without any loss of playing personnel. That £25m will go a long way - our parachute funding only drops by £8m next season, so that leaves £17m.  Release Barry and Morrison, possibly Brunt as well, and that’s big wages gone, along with the wages of the 6 loanees (5 of which will inevitably be replaced with 5 new .  Quite likely that Dawson, Hegazi, Gibbs, Phillips and Rodriguez would be sold - another £50m sales and around £180k/week more off the wage bill.

Puts us in a perfect position to recruit very talented younger versions with resale value.  A rebuild is necessary regardless of which division we are in. 

The key of course is having the right coach and the right DoF to deliver.

I agree, that we have one last roll of the dice, Prag,  and the sales together with the loss of wages you suggest will leave us in a decent place.

For me the key is not to have "Dads Army", but to recruit some good young players.

If we look at the relegation season, we lost c£7M. Crucially the cash was drained as well, hence we needed an overdraft. Losses do not equate to cash, they are two very different things (as you know  Smile ), and I'll have a look at the cashflow when I have time. But with c£30M drained out of cash, and wages up to £90M, we were living beyond our means. What would have happened if we had stayed up though? It was only delaying the inevitable. The ageing squad would have been 1 year older, no players with any resale value, and the rest on comfy contracts and going nowhere. This is why clubs like us have to be relegated, so we can clear the decks and start again.

Totally agree.  Being over-reliant on veteran players can never be a successful strategy, and offering new contracts to several 32/33/34 year olds means they will not be moving on.

I guess if we had stayed up then Lai might have sold, but we’ll never know.

(04-01-2019, 09:27 AM)Lightnin Wrote: The staggering ratio of wages against income is just plain barmy and someone wasn't looking at this right which left us in a complete mess. I don't know what the flex was for relegation in the players contracts but it needs to be quite a chunk or the losses next season could be quite damaging with our parachute payment dropping and the Premier League income.

On a positive note, the losses we are allowed under FFP, taking into account the relgation from the Premier League are on the good side and do leave us quite a large room for manouver over the next 2 seasons when you take into account that players that we haven't seen this season like Rondon, Burke and to a lesser extent Nyom all have a resale value that can cover a large gap should they leave. There is room for optimism that we might be able to keep the spine of this squad together for one more season should we fail this season but we certainly need to start integrating good younger players into our squad as others have mentioned. Whether thats players from this league or good young Premier league players not getting game time then lets hope someone has a list of names.

The relegation flex was apparently 50%.  The wage to income ratio is high but actually lower than many PL clubs.  It’s an insane industry these days, and unsustainable.

(04-01-2019, 09:37 AM)Squid Wrote: I can't see us getting much for Burke, he sat on the bench on Saturday. Hegazi, on the other hand, will bring in a tidy sum.

Interesting point about us needing to be relegated to clear the decks, but it all points to a lack of forward planning.

We’ll get a reasonable price for Burke but the reality is that we massively overpaid for him. We need to take the loss on the chin and move on.

Lack of forward planning is definitely an issue, but football is now a short term results business. A 5-year plan built around the right person (Potter or Smith come to mind) but without a far-sighted and realistic owner it rarely happens.  And Lai certainly doesn’t fit that description!


RE: The accounts are out - SW4Baggie - 04-01-2019

These accounts show why time and time again, every club outside the top 6 will get relegated, and the mythical next level may exist for a couple of years, but eventually you will drop.

The PL effectively forces clubs like ours to live beyond our means, and couples this with half-hearted financial responsibility measures which hinder sides in the long run. Every season you spend in the PL, the more pressure builds to get every transfer decision right, as one or two duff buys on big contracts restrict what you can do going forwards. Add to this the inert complacency that inevitably follows another year in the top flight and it's an accident waiting to happen.

Fortunately, the impact of our relegation doesn't seem too big. Yes we drained our cash, but we've made manageable losses and have more than enough saleable assets to ensure we can break even comfortably, whilst also giving us cash to fund a rebuild. Crucially we have no FFP issues ahead and an academy that is producing players capable of playing in the first team which will at least make us a realistic proposition for investment should we fail to get promoted this/next year.

Maybe it's the post-holiday bounce, but I don't foresee a long and painful few years ahead of us. I think failure to win promotion this year or next will see Lai sell up and cut his losses as he wont invest to take us back to the PL, and it's very difficult for owners to sell off assets and pull cash out to recoup their purchase outlay...

There will be other Fosuns out there - and should one be sniffing around the Championship we'll be a very investable club.


RE: The accounts are out - Pragmatist - 04-01-2019

(04-01-2019, 10:11 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: These accounts show why time and time again, every club outside the top 6 will get relegated, and the mythical next level may exist for a couple of years, but eventually you will drop.

The PL effectively forces clubs like ours to live beyond our means, and couples this with half-hearted financial responsibility measures which hinder sides in the long run.  Every season you spend in the PL, the more pressure builds to get every transfer decision right, as one or two duff buys on big contracts restrict what you can do going forwards. Add to this the inert complacency that inevitably follows another year in the top flight and it's an accident waiting to happen.

Fortunately, the impact of our relegation doesn't seem too big. Yes we drained our cash, but we've made manageable losses and have more than enough saleable assets to ensure we can break even comfortably, whilst also giving us cash to fund a rebuild. Crucially we have no FFP issues ahead and an academy that is producing players capable of playing in the first team which will at least make us a realistic proposition for investment should we fail to get promoted this/next year.

Maybe it's the post-holiday bounce, but I don't foresee a long and painful few years ahead of us. I think failure to win promotion this year or next will see Lai sell up and cut his losses as he wont invest to take us back to the PL, and it's very difficult for owners to sell off assets and pull cash out to recoup their purchase outlay...

There will be other Fosuns out there - and should one be sniffing around the Championship we'll be a very investable club.

Can’t argue with any of that. Good to see some common sense being written. We’re in better financial shape than just about every relegated club of the past 5 years.  Our only fly in the ointment is our owner.


RE: The accounts are out - Cunninghamismagic - 04-01-2019

Wage bill of £92.2 million. Ouch