WBAUnofficial
Modern football v yesterday. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Modern football v yesterday. (/showthread.php?tid=30043)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Modern football v yesterday. - Spandaubaggie - 05-20-2023

(05-19-2023, 11:37 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote:
(05-19-2023, 01:56 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It was me Bob. I was saying after the Man C display that the richest clubs are gaining more points than a generation ago, winning more games and by bigger scores. It's not just in the Prem, but all over Europe.

It stands to reason that the best players instead of being one of 3-4 superstars, being around 11 who are there to help you out makes them all look better.

I would say those who are in the Prem now are not quite as close in quality to the very best as a generation or 2 ago. It is simply that the very very best have world stars galore supporting them and the very best coaches etc all helping their performances.

It feels like there are less 'great' players currently compared to 20-30 years ago. The game may have improved a little in that timeframe but this is marginal IMO, so I don't think a supposed more competitive game making it more difficult for the best to shine can account for this.

Take this example: Paul Breitner won his first title with Bayern in 71. He went on to score in the '74 World Cup final, and scored again in the '82 final. Lothar Matthaus was part of that '82 West German squad. Matthaus captained West Germany to the trophy in '90 and was in the Bayern side when they lost in the '99 Champions League final. He won his final Bundesliga with Bayern in 2000. That's 30 years at the very top of the game covered between a mere two players! If the standard of players had improved drastically over that time, then why didn't either of these players get left behind, rather than seamlessly adjust to the changing landscape whilst remaining at the top? Football history is full of similar generational cross-overs, yet the best players almost always still compete with the best younger players. This in itself shows that while good coaching, fitness and tactics are important, the best talents will always shine, as long as they apply themselves with a good level of professionalism.

Hagi, Zidane, Suker, Maradona, Batistuta, Maldini, Baresi, Klinsmann, Seedorf, Rivaldo, Fat Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Cafu, Gascoigne, Baggio, Weah, Savicevic, Van Basten, Stoichkov, Bergkamp, Henry, Nedved, Boban, Figo, Del Piero, Zola, Cantona, Schmeichal, Michael Laudrup, Raul, Hierro, Frank D Boer, Stam, and the aforementioned Matthaus: all were playing and competing against each other at the very top level at some point in the '90s. No-ones going to convince me that they would not stand out for the talented players that they were if their peak selves were transported into the game as it is now.
And throw Bryan Robson into that exalted company too- a beast as a 20 year old with the stars of the 60s still in the twilight of their careers and also there as the 90s stars began to rise.


RE: Modern football v yesterday. - BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine - 05-20-2023

(05-19-2023, 04:12 PM)RAELALBION Wrote: The problem with City this season is the complete lack of jeopardy when ever they play. Yes they look good and it is beautiful to watch, but you knew they were going to beat Madrid the other night, I had absolutely no doubts. While you still get the odd freak result the games are not competitive, and it just seem a futile exercise when playing at the Eithad. Yes, while we did have teams who dominated in the 80/90's they never racked up City's point totals.
Football is supposed to be a competition, that is why I turn up to watch games, in the hope that something unique and unpredictable will happen. That is why the Sheff Wed game last night was such a thing of joy (and misery for Posh). It was exactly what makes this sport so special and a million miles more entertaining that City/Madrid.

(05-20-2023, 09:56 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-19-2023, 11:37 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote:
(05-19-2023, 01:56 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It was me Bob. I was saying after the Man C display that the richest clubs are gaining more points than a generation ago, winning more games and by bigger scores. It's not just in the Prem, but all over Europe.

It stands to reason that the best players instead of being one of 3-4 superstars, being around 11 who are there to help you out makes them all look better.

I would say those who are in the Prem now are not quite as close in quality to the very best as a generation or 2 ago. It is simply that the very very best have world stars galore supporting them and the very best coaches etc all helping their performances.

It feels like there are less 'great' players currently compared to 20-30 years ago. The game may have improved a little in that timeframe but this is marginal IMO, so I don't think a supposed more competitive game making it more difficult for the best to shine can account for this.

Take this example: Paul Breitner won his first title with Bayern in 71. He went on to score in the '74 World Cup final, and scored again in the '82 final. Lothar Matthaus was part of that '82 West German squad. Matthaus captained West Germany to the trophy in '90 and was in the Bayern side when they lost in the '99 Champions League final. He won his final Bundesliga with Bayern in 2000. That's 30 years at the very top of the game covered between a mere two players! If the standard of players had improved drastically over that time, then why didn't either of these players get left behind, rather than seamlessly adjust to the changing landscape whilst remaining at the top? Football history is full of similar generational cross-overs, yet the best players almost always still compete with the best younger players. This in itself shows that while good coaching, fitness and tactics are important, the best talents will always shine, as long as they apply themselves with a good level of professionalism.

Hagi, Zidane, Suker, Maradona, Batistuta, Maldini, Baresi, Klinsmann, Seedorf, Rivaldo, Fat Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Cafu, Gascoigne, Baggio, Weah, Savicevic, Van Basten, Stoichkov, Bergkamp, Henry, Nedved, Boban, Figo, Del Piero, Zola, Cantona, Schmeichal, Michael Laudrup, Raul, Hierro, Frank D Boer, Stam, and the aforementioned Matthaus: all were playing and competing against each other at the very top level at some point in the '90s. No-ones going to convince me that they would not stand out for the talented players that they were if their peak selves were transported into the game as it is now.
And throw Bryan Robson into that exalted company too- a beast as a 20 year old with the stars of the 60s still in the twilight of their careers and also there as the 90s stars began to rise.

Yes, another good example. Bomber was in the first team in '63 and played with Robson for 5 seasons starting in '75. Robson later played with Giggs for 2-3 season at Man U as well in the early '90's. Giggs was still playing for Man U less than 10 years ago. That's roughly a 50 year span with those three players. The game has improved over that time-frame no doubt, but I'd argue not nearly as much as many would think.


RE: Modern football v yesterday. - Jerry - 05-20-2023

Laurie Cunningham played when you could kick the skilled players up in the air without a booking. If you saw him play in those days think what he could do in todays no tackle game.