![]() |
|
Second Referendum - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Second Referendum (/showthread.php?tid=2991) |
RE: Second Referendum - CornishView - 03-30-2019 How about having a Referendum on having Referendums? MPs are our elected representatives, and should decide these matters on our behalf, because hardly 1% of us - if we're honest - knew the complexities 2 years ago. (I hope the people of Uxbridge vote Boris The Twat out at the next Election, bearing in mind he put his own ambition above his Country and Constituency). RE: Second Referendum - Pontificator - 03-30-2019 (03-30-2019, 07:36 AM)strawman Wrote:(03-30-2019, 07:12 AM)Pontificator Wrote:(03-29-2019, 11:37 PM)GMBaggie Wrote:(03-29-2019, 10:34 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Have been against this but am fast coming to the conclusion that it may be the only answer to the current impasse. The current Parliament seem unable to come to a resolution of this issue and there is no guarantee that if we held a General Election, that the new parliament would be anymore capable of finding a resolution than the current one. WTF has the last three years been about other than trying to implement the result FFS. It beggars belief how stupid some people can be at times. If you shoot yourself in the head you cant change your fucking mind afterwards. RE: Second Referendum - strawman - 03-30-2019 (03-30-2019, 08:34 AM)Pontificator Wrote:(03-30-2019, 07:36 AM)strawman Wrote:(03-30-2019, 07:12 AM)Pontificator Wrote:(03-29-2019, 11:37 PM)GMBaggie Wrote:(03-29-2019, 10:34 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Have been against this but am fast coming to the conclusion that it may be the only answer to the current impasse. The current Parliament seem unable to come to a resolution of this issue and there is no guarantee that if we held a General Election, that the new parliament would be anymore capable of finding a resolution than the current one. I think it's been more about politicking, Labours one and only tactic is to try and get another GE, rather than actually trying to implement it. However in line with your thinking, we should hold another GE, Labour should get voted in and then the result should be ignored, go back to parliament for a vote and if they can't carry the vote in Parliament then we retain the status quo, just because lot of people believe that voting in a Labour Government would definitely be shooting ourselves in the head. RE: Second Referendum - Derek Hardballs - 03-30-2019 Ok so the argument against a second referendum is that it’s ‘anti-democratic’. How exactly is having a further vote on the specifics of Brexit, having learnt a great deal more about what it entails anti-democratic? Surely the argument for leaving has been comprehensively won after thee years? So why are so many leavers terrified it seems at giving the final seal of approval back to the ahem people? Also if a majority of people decided after a vote to put their hands into a fire, how exactly is that the right thing to do? The bizarre wish to make our lives more difficult ‘cuz we voted for it’ suggests we have a country full of masochists. RE: Second Referendum - strawman - 03-30-2019 (03-30-2019, 08:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ok so the argument against a second referendum is that it’s ‘anti-democratic’. How exactly is having a further vote on the specifics of Brexit, having learnt a great deal more about what it entails anti-democratic? Surely the argument for leaving has been comprehensively won after thee years? So why are so many leavers terrified it seems at giving the final seal of approval back to the ahem people? The arguments for leave have certainly not been comprehensively won. The arguments for remain seem to be "well we keep what we have now", but that would seem to assume that there is a status quo. There is no status quo. The EU will change. We have no idea what our situation will be in 10 years time, stay or leave. The major countries of the EU are not exactly an economic wonder now that the ECB has stopped QE. WE do not know in either direction, both are completely surmised. The only way we could even attempt to keep the status quo from staying in is to veto absolutely everything we can to avoid major changes and I'm sure that would pretty well piss the EU off, we have pissed em off for years anyway. And there may be a point where unanimity is no longer available. There are already proposals for uniform corporation tax rates, which has pissed the Irish off. But those with clout in the EU are pushing for unanimity in more areas to be abandoned to majority voting. "In addition, the scale and urgency of the challenges facing Member States today – be it in terms of internal and external security, globalisation, migration, climate change, or adapting to the digital revolution – means that important decisions should not be allowed to be held hostage while Member States seek to exact the highest possible price in return for not using their veto power." Note those words "important decisions should not be allowed to be held hostage while Member States seek to exact the highest possible price in return for not using their veto power[" We know better than you Luckily to enable majority voting it requires unanimity, but they won't let this go. https://ec.europa.eu/epsc/sites/epsc/files/epsc_brief_passerelles_2.pdf There is no status quo RE: Second Referendum - Pontificator - 03-30-2019 (03-30-2019, 09:08 AM)strawman Wrote:(03-30-2019, 08:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ok so the argument against a second referendum is that it’s ‘anti-democratic’. How exactly is having a further vote on the specifics of Brexit, having learnt a great deal more about what it entails anti-democratic? Surely the argument for leaving has been comprehensively won after thee years? So why are so many leavers terrified it seems at giving the final seal of approval back to the ahem people? Wow that was showstopper RE: Second Referendum - baggy1 - 03-30-2019 (03-30-2019, 09:08 AM)strawman Wrote:(03-30-2019, 08:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ok so the argument against a second referendum is that it’s ‘anti-democratic’. How exactly is having a further vote on the specifics of Brexit, having learnt a great deal more about what it entails anti-democratic? Surely the argument for leaving has been comprehensively won after thee years? So why are so many leavers terrified it seems at giving the final seal of approval back to the ahem people? The argument isn't "lets keep the status quo" at all, the argument is that it isn't broken and causing us problems, don't try and fix it by leaping into the unknown. Your argument works both ways, we definitely don't know what the future holds but why don't we wait until we get there before we make a decision on what it is. Nobody would be against leaving the EU if there was a rational and well thought out reason for doing it - there really isn't to the point that you could get 5 Brexiteers in a room and still not get an agreed approach. We've opened the discussions about leaving amongst ourselves, let's have a 2nd referendum to see if the majority want to leave still now that they are better informed. If we decide to stay in now it doesn't mean forever, it means, if we are serious, that we can think out the best approach to doing so and get prepared. Leaving now is chaotic and insane based on where we are. RE: Second Referendum - Black Lake Victoria - 03-30-2019 What's the celebrity world think? I'll ask David Beckham next time I see him on the 87 bus or in the doctors waiting room? Democracy my arse...if voting changed anything we wouldn't be allowed to do it (wasn't Mark Twain quote) RE: Second Referendum - baggy1 - 03-30-2019 (03-30-2019, 11:31 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Wow that was showstopper It would be if the basis of the point was accurate RE: Second Referendum - Shabby Russian - 03-30-2019 The other point I would make is that the issue of Europe will go forward to future General Elections. If there is no second referendum, then I would expect a favourable electoral result for any party that campaigns for closer ties to the EU. But if there was a second referendum, unless there was an overwhelming result for remain, I suspect that Eurosceptic parties would do well at the next General Election. With that in mind, and as someone who is in favour of closer ties to the EU, I think there is much to be lost from holding a second referendum, and much to be gained by leave supporters. Trouble is in the short term I am not certain what the alternative is to a referendum. |