WBAUnofficial
Ratings... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings... (/showthread.php?tid=2990)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Ratings... - WorcBaggie - 03-29-2019

Always said kudos for those putting up reports and ratings but giving Livermore anything less than 7.5 (his 2nd half performance alone deserved it) would be unjust. He was fantastic.

A generally untidy first half performance but credit to Blues and Monk for the way they set up. However, credit to all at the Albion from Shan to the players to the crowd, the MC was brilliant tonight, for the second half performance.


RE: Ratings... - Tom Joad - 03-29-2019

(03-29-2019, 11:36 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: Always said kudos for those putting up reports and ratings but giving Livermore anything less than 7.5 (his 2nd half performance alone deserved it) would be unjust. He was fantastic.

A generally untidy first half performance but credit to Blues and Monk for the way they set up. However, credit to all at the Albion from Shan to the players to the crowd, the MC was brilliant tonight, for the second half performance.

The worst we could to against an organised, disciplined, albeit slightly short of talent,  Gary Monk side.....was give them an early goal.


RE: Ratings... - TETLEY74 - 03-30-2019

(03-29-2019, 11:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: You lot come out with some crap Livermore was by far and away our best midfielder scored a cracker and linked play really well second half. Some of you should look in the mirror with your treatment of Jake Good honest hardworking pro. Gets the same treatment as Kanu but now your beginning to realise we are a better team with Kanu than without.

Wouldn't disagree with that thought he played well tonight to be fair, another who if played in the right position produces the goods, not rocket science really.,,,, oh and that finish was worth m.o.m for me alone.


RE: Ratings... - Mancbaggies - 03-30-2019

(03-29-2019, 11:19 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Johnstone 7.  Steady tonight. Poor handling started that chain of corners for the 1st. 6.5

Holgate 6.5.  Solid enough. Needs to show more going forward. 
Dawson 6.5.  Far from convincing 1 half. Bit better 2nd 5.5
Hegazi 7.       Lost too many headers to Jut - but a lot of good blocks/interceptions 6.5
Townsend 7.   Real trier and energy.  Did v well to win crucial pen

Livermore 6.5.  Anonymous 1 half but excellent 2nd. Clean strike for massive winner 7
Brunt 6.5.        Dreadful marking for 1st and struggled with 2nd ball. Great delivery
Mozza 6 (HRK 7). Tried to make things happen - just not effective enough

HRK. 8. Changed the game with his hold up play. Good touch/movement 

Edwards 7 (Murphy 5). Ran into blind alleys today. Good effort and energy tho. 6.5
Rodriguez 6.5 (Bartley 6.5).  Great pen but so slow and ineffective. Really needs to improve general play 
Gayle 6.5.  Much sharper and quicker tonight. Good movement and deserved goal. 7

murphy  more urgency and effort in cameo tonight. Key clearance in 98th mon.  6
bartley. Did his job and won 3 big headers 

Not far off these - comments above.


RE: Ratings... - Cuzer - 03-30-2019

(03-29-2019, 11:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: You lot come out with some crap Livermore was by far and away our best midfielder scored a cracker and linked play really well second half. Some of you should look in the mirror with your treatment of Jake Good honest hardworking pro. Gets the same treatment as Kanu but now your beginning to realise we are a better team with Kanu than without.

Your half right there, 2nd half he was tremendous, a proper center midfield performance in a 442, wanted the ball, played forward, covered lots of ground and scored a great goal

First half.....woeful

Like most of em

Cuzer


RE: Ratings... - Boutros - 03-30-2019

(03-29-2019, 11:18 PM)Pwba13 Wrote: You lot come out with some crap Livermore was by far and away our best midfielder scored a cracker and linked play really well second half. Some of you should look in the mirror with your treatment of Jake Good honest hardworking pro. Gets the same treatment as Kanu but now your beginning to realise we are a better team with Kanu than without.

Calm down snowflake.


RE: Ratings... - SW4Baggie - 03-30-2019

(03-29-2019, 11:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: You lot come out with some crap Livermore was by far and away our best midfielder scored a cracker and linked play really well second half. Some of you should look in the mirror with your treatment of Jake Good honest hardworking pro. Gets the same treatment as Kanu but now your beginning to realise we are a better team with Kanu than without.


Beginning to realise? I’ve backed HRK for quite a while - he’s he only one who gets us up the pitch.

Livermore wasn’t our best central midfielder -Brunt’s short cameo in that position was the best.

Livermore was out-paced consistently, and let them make multiple runs through not being able to cover the ground needed. I realise some people may see the goal and the couple of Hollywood passes as making him brilliant, but his general positional play for his role showed his dire lack of legs.

But like with the HRK comments see whatever you want to see.


RE: Ratings... - Cuzer - 03-30-2019

(03-30-2019, 01:25 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-29-2019, 11:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: You lot come out with some crap Livermore was by far and away our best midfielder scored a cracker and linked play really well second half. Some of you should look in the mirror with your treatment of Jake Good honest hardworking pro. Gets the same treatment as Kanu but now your beginning to realise we are a better team with Kanu than without.


Beginning to realise? I’ve backed HRK for quite a while - he’s he only one who gets us up the pitch.

Livermore wasn’t our best central midfielder -Brunt’s short cameo in that position was the best.

Livermore was out-paced consistently, and let them make multiple runs through not being able to cover the ground needed. I realise some people may see the goal and the couple of Hollywood passes as making him brilliant, but his general positional play for his role showed his dire lack of legs.

But like with the HRK comments see whatever you want to see.

I thought HRK was very good, I have no issue with him and as you say he gets us up the pitch

Think you're wrong about Livermore though, 1st class he was very poor but 2nd half arguably our best player, regardless of the goal, watch it back on TV, I watched the 2nd half again when I got in and just reaffirmed how much better he looks in a two man midfield over a three

Cuzer


RE: Ratings... - Dumbo - 03-30-2019

(03-29-2019, 11:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: You lot come out with some crap Livermore was by far and away our best midfielder scored a cracker and linked play really well second half. Some of you should look in the mirror with your treatment of Jake Good honest hardworking pro. Gets the same treatment as Kanu but now your beginning to realise we are a better team with Kanu than without.

https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread.php?tid=2359