WBAUnofficial
How do we fix this dressing room? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: How do we fix this dressing room? (/showthread.php?tid=29536)

Pages: 1 2


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - Man from delmonte - 04-10-2023

There will be no great re-set at the club until the summer of 2024 when we can have a huge clearout with the likes of Bartley, Phillips, Button, Reach, Chalobah and Kelly out of the club.

As much grief as Lai is getting from the fans, he didn't bring in the utter shower that we have at the club and have given stupidly long contracts to. We are paying the price for a prolonged period of terrible recruitment.

I would say two players we have who represent the sort of lads we need to bring in are Molumby and BTA. Both have excellent attitudes and don't hide away even if things aren't going their way. Players brought in relatively cheaply who either haven't quite made it at a top flight club or have earned a move from the lower leagues and have something to prove. This is the sort of recruitment we need rather than the 'one last payday' crowd we have signed for far too long.

The one thing going for us right now is we have a good coach. The crowd need to stick with him though as this isn't a quick fix. We're facing the biggest rebuilding job since Megson took over now.


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - TETLEY74 - 04-10-2023

(04-10-2023, 04:41 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I genuinely believe that players dating back to the big "down tools" reaction when Allardyce came in need to be canned. So that's Livermore, Phillips, Furlong, Townsend, Ajayi and Bartley. O'Shea gets a reprieve because he's a candidate for POTY.

Whatever it is CC is trying to do, the players clearly can't or won't cooperate. I reckon it's "No more Mr Nice Guy" time.

Of course, we have to take a financial hit on moving these players on and we have to fund replacements. Oh well.

Looks like another case of the players trying to see off another manager who expects them to work and perform consistently.


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - Calgary_Baggie - 04-10-2023

(04-10-2023, 05:31 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(04-10-2023, 04:41 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I genuinely believe that players dating back to the big "down tools" reaction when Allardyce came in need to be canned. So that's Livermore, Phillips, Furlong, Townsend, Ajayi and Bartley. O'Shea gets a reprieve because he's a candidate for POTY.

Whatever it is CC is trying to do, the players clearly can't or won't cooperate. I reckon it's "No more Mr Nice Guy" time.

Of course, we have to take a financial hit on moving these players on and we have to fund replacements. Oh well.

Looks like another case of the players trying to see off another manager who expects them to work and perform consistently.

Yup.

The common denominator remains and until it is removed or changed then a other manager will fall.


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - SW4Baggie - 04-10-2023

(04-10-2023, 05:23 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: There will be no great re-set at the club until the summer of 2024 when we can have a huge clearout with the likes of Bartley, Phillips, Button, Reach, Chalobah and Kelly out of the club.

As much grief as Lai is getting from the fans, he didn't bring in the utter shower that we have at the club and have given stupidly long contracts to. We are paying the price for a prolonged period of terrible recruitment.

I would say two players we have who represent the sort of lads we need to bring in are Molumby and BTA. Both have excellent attitudes and don't hide away even if things aren't going their way. Players brought in relatively cheaply who either haven't quite made it at a top flight club or have earned a move from the lower leagues and have something to prove. This is the sort of recruitment we need rather than the 'one last payday' crowd we have signed for far too long.

The one thing going for us right now is we have a good coach. The crowd need to stick with him though as this isn't a quick fix. We're facing the biggest rebuilding job since Megson took over now.

Correct.

We saw a similar hunger from Furlong, Ajayi, Townsend when they first signed, however they’ve now achieved everything they’re likely to achieve - none of those 3 will compete in the PL, or even for promotion to the PL again in their career - and are now part of the problem of comfort we currently have.

It’s not a difficult puzzle, we simply sign players that will be thankful for the opportunity to play here, and who will want to push on and continue to improve. We have done that very, very rarely in recent seasons and instead we’ve handed extensions and renewals to players who should have been shown the door any seasons ago.  Quite how Phillips and Livermore for example are still here I’ve absolutely no idea. 

We’ve allowed sentiment and laziness to cloud our judgment on recruitment for too long, and now we are getting what we deserve.


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - Calgary_Baggie - 04-10-2023

(04-10-2023, 05:42 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-10-2023, 05:23 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: There will be no great re-set at the club until the summer of 2024 when we can have a huge clearout with the likes of Bartley, Phillips, Button, Reach, Chalobah and Kelly out of the club.

As much grief as Lai is getting from the fans, he didn't bring in the utter shower that we have at the club and have given stupidly long contracts to. We are paying the price for a prolonged period of terrible recruitment.

I would say two players we have who represent the sort of lads we need to bring in are Molumby and BTA. Both have excellent attitudes and don't hide away even if things aren't going their way. Players brought in relatively cheaply who either haven't quite made it at a top flight club or have earned a move from the lower leagues and have something to prove. This is the sort of recruitment we need rather than the 'one last payday' crowd we have signed for far too long.

The one thing going for us right now is we have a good coach. The crowd need to stick with him though as this isn't a quick fix. We're facing the biggest rebuilding job since Megson took over now.

Correct.

We saw a similar hunger from Furlong, Ajayi, Townsend when they first signed, however they’ve now achieved everything they’re likely to achieve - none of those 3 will compete in the PL, or even for promotion to the PL again in their career - and are now part of the problem of comfort we currently have.

It’s not a difficult puzzle, we simply sign players that will be thankful for the opportunity to play here, and who will want to push on and continue to improve. We have done that very, very rarely in recent seasons and instead we’ve handed extensions and renewals to players who should have been shown the door any seasons ago.  Quite how Phillips and Livermore for example are still here I’ve absolutely no idea. 

We’ve allowed sentiment and laziness to cloud our judgment on recruitment for too long, and now we are getting what we deserve.

That last paragraph is perfect.

Take a bow, sir.


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - Seat109 - 04-10-2023

(04-10-2023, 05:32 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-10-2023, 05:31 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(04-10-2023, 04:41 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I genuinely believe that players dating back to the big "down tools" reaction when Allardyce came in need to be canned. So that's Livermore, Phillips, Furlong, Townsend, Ajayi and Bartley. O'Shea gets a reprieve because he's a candidate for POTY.

Whatever it is CC is trying to do, the players clearly can't or won't cooperate. I reckon it's "No more Mr Nice Guy" time.

Of course, we have to take a financial hit on moving these players on and we have to fund replacements. Oh well.

Looks like another case of the players trying to see off another manager who expects them to work and perform consistently.

Yup.

The common denominator remains and until it is removed or changed then a other manager will fall.
Don’t disagree with the ‘fix the dressing room’ sentiment however our perceived injury free strongest eleven would be 

Palmer/Griffiths
Furlong
O’Shea
Pieters 
Townsend
Wallace 
Molumby
Swift
Yokuslu 
Phillips/Diangana
Dike

Of which the 2 full backs are constants in failure plus Phillips/Diangana (you could argue CC had sorted Phillips out) the other 8 have been here for less than 2 seasons so maybe it’s the fact that the rest of the squad are simply not good enough and it’s nothing to do with mentality etc?


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - Duffers - 04-10-2023

Q. How do we fix the dressing room?

A. Flamethrowers.


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - Dial M for Mick - 04-10-2023

(04-10-2023, 05:50 PM)Seat109 Wrote:
(04-10-2023, 05:32 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-10-2023, 05:31 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(04-10-2023, 04:41 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I genuinely believe that players dating back to the big "down tools" reaction when Allardyce came in need to be canned. So that's Livermore, Phillips, Furlong, Townsend, Ajayi and Bartley. O'Shea gets a reprieve because he's a candidate for POTY.

Whatever it is CC is trying to do, the players clearly can't or won't cooperate. I reckon it's "No more Mr Nice Guy" time.

Of course, we have to take a financial hit on moving these players on and we have to fund replacements. Oh well.

Looks like another case of the players trying to see off another manager who expects them to work and perform consistently.

Yup.

The common denominator remains and until it is removed or changed then a other manager will fall.
Don’t disagree with the ‘fix the dressing room’ sentiment however our perceived injury free strongest eleven would be 

Palmer/Griffiths
Furlong
O’Shea
Pieters 
Townsend
Wallace 
Molumby
Swift
Yokuslu 
Phillips/Diangana
Dike

Of which the 2 full backs are constants in failure plus Phillips/Diangana (you could argue CC had sorted Phillips out) the other 8 have been here for less than 2 seasons so maybe it’s the fact that the rest of the squad are simply not good enough and it’s nothing to do with mentality etc?

People will be saying “it’s the same players” 10 years from now when most of this lot are retired.


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - Spandaubaggie - 04-10-2023

Sorry I’ll go against the grain with this.
We’ve a great coach in Corberan and given the season he would have got us top 6 with these players.
The issue has been the coaches and recruiting.
This season awful injuries caught up with us. We are down to the bare bones.


RE: How do we fix this dressing room? - Calgary_Baggie - 04-10-2023

(04-10-2023, 06:01 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Sorry I’ll go against the grain with this.
We’ve a great coach in Corberan and given the season he would have got us top 6 with these players.
The issue has been the coaches and recruiting.
This season awful injuries caught up with us. We are down to the bare bones.

One of the main issues is an idiot giving his mate 3 months of the season to effectively destroy any realistic hopes of promotion. 

The idiot in question is still employed by the club.