WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=29506)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Ratings - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-08-2023

(04-08-2023, 12:23 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 09:23 AM)Sliced Wrote: Griffiths 8

Furlong 1 - Shocking
Ajayi 2 - Bad game but despite being labelled  as a scapegoat, wasn't at fault for any of the goals.
Pieters 1 - All over the place
Townsend - 7 Our best outfield player by a distance, decent at both ends of the pitch

Chalobah, TGH, Swift - 1 It was basically pointless having a midfield. Each as bad as one another. Actually Chalobah gets 0 because he lost his man for the first goal

Wallace - 2 Didn't do anything

BTA and Dike - 5 Neither got much service but neither looked threatening.

Albrighton 5
Rogic 4
Grant 3
Bartley 1 - Only just came on and couldnt be arsed to pretend to close down for their third goal.

If you can tell me what he was doing for the two Hugill goals, I might begin to accept his blamelessness. By standing not where the ball is likely to go and not near any opponent who needs to be marked, you can make a case for not being to blame. I suppose. He's 6 foot 4, but doesn't win the headers. Pieters, Dike or Okay have to mark the big men. What is that all about, eh?

Ah, so it's his fault he didn't mark someone elses man? Got it

Anyone would think you had a bizarre agenda Chesh. I find it weird that you don't have this same energy for those who actually were to blame.

It's not bizarre. He's crap, we concede cheap goals every time he plays. He's tall but doesn't mark the opponent's big players. He's never where the errors happen because he's all over the place positionally. I'm not alone in thinking he is a fraud of a defender, I don't think there's a player for the future in him and I don't want to see him in the stripes again. It confounds me that so many people see something that isn't there (a solid defender) and fail to see the carnage that surrounds him.

I suppose if I put as much effort into dissing Nathaniel Chalobah, Adam Reach or Karlan Grant you wouldn't call it bizarre.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 04-08-2023

(04-08-2023, 12:43 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:23 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 09:23 AM)Sliced Wrote: Griffiths 8

Furlong 1 - Shocking
Ajayi 2 - Bad game but despite being labelled  as a scapegoat, wasn't at fault for any of the goals.
Pieters 1 - All over the place
Townsend - 7 Our best outfield player by a distance, decent at both ends of the pitch

Chalobah, TGH, Swift - 1 It was basically pointless having a midfield. Each as bad as one another. Actually Chalobah gets 0 because he lost his man for the first goal

Wallace - 2 Didn't do anything

BTA and Dike - 5 Neither got much service but neither looked threatening.

Albrighton 5
Rogic 4
Grant 3
Bartley 1 - Only just came on and couldnt be arsed to pretend to close down for their third goal.

If you can tell me what he was doing for the two Hugill goals, I might begin to accept his blamelessness. By standing not where the ball is likely to go and not near any opponent who needs to be marked, you can make a case for not being to blame. I suppose. He's 6 foot 4, but doesn't win the headers. Pieters, Dike or Okay have to mark the big men. What is that all about, eh?

Ah, so it's his fault he didn't mark someone elses man? Got it

Anyone would think you had a bizarre agenda Chesh. I find it weird that you don't have this same energy for those who actually were to blame.

It's not bizarre. He's crap, we concede cheap goals every time he plays. He's tall but doesn't mark the opponent's big players. He's never where the errors happen because he's all over the place positionally. I'm not alone in thinking he is a fraud of a defender, I don't think there's a player for the future in him and I don't want to see him in the stripes again. It confounds me that so many people see something that isn't there (a solid defender) and fail to see the carnage that surrounds him.

I suppose if I put as much effort into dissing Nathaniel Chalobah, Adam Reach or Karlan Grant you wouldn't call it bizarre.

Of course I would, it's comes across as a weird obsession. I find the bashing of Adam Reach by our fanbase to be unfortunate because I don't think he's really done much wrong since he's been here as limited as he is. However your Ajayi obsession is a whole other level.

Ajayi was clumsy yesterday, he didn't play well, but he wasn't responsible for any of the goals we conceded and wasn't the reason that we didn't create anything yet I've read about 6 or 7 posts from you exclusively blaming Ajayi when he wasn't even supposed to be marking Hugill for two of the goals and wasn't even on the pitch for the third.


RE: Ratings - Calgary_Baggie - 04-08-2023

(04-08-2023, 12:52 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:43 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:23 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 09:23 AM)Sliced Wrote: Griffiths 8

Furlong 1 - Shocking
Ajayi 2 - Bad game but despite being labelled  as a scapegoat, wasn't at fault for any of the goals.
Pieters 1 - All over the place
Townsend - 7 Our best outfield player by a distance, decent at both ends of the pitch

Chalobah, TGH, Swift - 1 It was basically pointless having a midfield. Each as bad as one another. Actually Chalobah gets 0 because he lost his man for the first goal

Wallace - 2 Didn't do anything

BTA and Dike - 5 Neither got much service but neither looked threatening.

Albrighton 5
Rogic 4
Grant 3
Bartley 1 - Only just came on and couldnt be arsed to pretend to close down for their third goal.

If you can tell me what he was doing for the two Hugill goals, I might begin to accept his blamelessness. By standing not where the ball is likely to go and not near any opponent who needs to be marked, you can make a case for not being to blame. I suppose. He's 6 foot 4, but doesn't win the headers. Pieters, Dike or Okay have to mark the big men. What is that all about, eh?

Ah, so it's his fault he didn't mark someone elses man? Got it

Anyone would think you had a bizarre agenda Chesh. I find it weird that you don't have this same energy for those who actually were to blame.

It's not bizarre. He's crap, we concede cheap goals every time he plays. He's tall but doesn't mark the opponent's big players. He's never where the errors happen because he's all over the place positionally. I'm not alone in thinking he is a fraud of a defender, I don't think there's a player for the future in him and I don't want to see him in the stripes again. It confounds me that so many people see something that isn't there (a solid defender) and fail to see the carnage that surrounds him.

I suppose if I put as much effort into dissing Nathaniel Chalobah, Adam Reach or Karlan Grant you wouldn't call it bizarre.

Of course I would, it's comes across as a weird obsession. I find the bashing of Adam Reach by our fanbase to be unfortunate because I don't think he's really done much wrong since he's been here as limited as he is. However your Ajayi obsession is a whole other level.

Ajayi was clumsy yesterday, he didn't play well, but he wasn't responsible for any of the goals we conceded and wasn't the reason that we didn't create anything yet I've read about 6 or 7 posts from you exclusively blaming Ajayi when he wasn't even supposed to be marking Hugill for two of the goals and wasn't even on the pitch for the third.

Reach lacks ability and will never be good enough. A dreadful signing. Very lazy. 

I think Ajayi has the ability to be good player but is error prone. Hugely frustrating.


RE: Ratings - Stillclem4england - 04-08-2023

(04-08-2023, 10:41 AM)Cuzer Wrote: As bad as Pieters and Semi were yesterday they tried, they were just piss poor and weak, I’ve raised that point on Pieters numerous times this season, good ball playing CH but not a great defensive CH and easily bullied, working a game plan against West Brom isn’t difficult let’s face it

Work harder and ask questions from set pieces is a blue print for 3 points

However Swift yesterday was disgusting, he was at open training BTW, nice shiny pink boots which still look as brand new now as they did at kick off, strolled about, no tracking of runners, no demanding of the ball, no trying to find space utterly disgusting lack of effort

Chalobah another, strolls around, no change of pace, ducked  three headers I counted off goal kicks, his job is to win the ball ahead of Pieters as Okay does, he was utterly terrible and I hope the not fit to wear the shirt stuck in his throat as it was aimed at him as much as anybody else
Come in on decent money on an 18 month deal and shown little ambition or heart from day one

Furlong was terrible, TGH struggled but I saw no lack of effort Swift and Chalobah though we’re disgusting

Cuzer
I don't recall having seen Swift on Tuesday but I didn't have my glasses on. My son said he was there.

I don't blame Chalobah; I blame whoever deemed him a signing we should make. I had seen him play previously a few times and never thought anything of him. He's been a bit nomadic and is clearly on the way down. Just the sort of lazy signing we never made under DA but have loved since the relegation season. It's all well and good moving out the Sawyers, Zohores and Livermores but when you replace them with the likes of Chalobah what's the fucking point?

(04-08-2023, 12:54 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:52 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:43 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:23 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 12:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: If you can tell me what he was doing for the two Hugill goals, I might begin to accept his blamelessness. By standing not where the ball is likely to go and not near any opponent who needs to be marked, you can make a case for not being to blame. I suppose. He's 6 foot 4, but doesn't win the headers. Pieters, Dike or Okay have to mark the big men. What is that all about, eh?

Ah, so it's his fault he didn't mark someone elses man? Got it

Anyone would think you had a bizarre agenda Chesh. I find it weird that you don't have this same energy for those who actually were to blame.

It's not bizarre. He's crap, we concede cheap goals every time he plays. He's tall but doesn't mark the opponent's big players. He's never where the errors happen because he's all over the place positionally. I'm not alone in thinking he is a fraud of a defender, I don't think there's a player for the future in him and I don't want to see him in the stripes again. It confounds me that so many people see something that isn't there (a solid defender) and fail to see the carnage that surrounds him.

I suppose if I put as much effort into dissing Nathaniel Chalobah, Adam Reach or Karlan Grant you wouldn't call it bizarre.

Of course I would, it's comes across as a weird obsession. I find the bashing of Adam Reach by our fanbase to be unfortunate because I don't think he's really done much wrong since he's been here as limited as he is. However your Ajayi obsession is a whole other level.

Ajayi was clumsy yesterday, he didn't play well, but he wasn't responsible for any of the goals we conceded and wasn't the reason that we didn't create anything yet I've read about 6 or 7 posts from you exclusively blaming Ajayi when he wasn't even supposed to be marking Hugill for two of the goals and wasn't even on the pitch for the third.

Reach lacks ability and will never be good enough. A dreadful signing. Very lazy. 

I think Ajayi has the ability to be good player but is error prone. Hugely frustrating.
Agree re Ajayi Nick, but you could argue the same about Mardon, Carbon, Burgess yet I'd swap them for Tony Butler in a heartbeat. No frills but a heart the size of a small island.


RE: Ratings - Calgary_Baggie - 04-08-2023

(04-08-2023, 01:36 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 10:41 AM)Cuzer Wrote: As bad as Pieters and Semi were yesterday they tried, they were just piss poor and weak, I’ve raised that point on Pieters numerous times this season, good ball playing CH but not a great defensive CH and easily bullied, working a game plan against West Brom isn’t difficult let’s face it

Work harder and ask questions from set pieces is a blue print for 3 points

However Swift yesterday was disgusting, he was at open training BTW, nice shiny pink boots which still look as brand new now as they did at kick off, strolled about, no tracking of runners, no demanding of the ball, no trying to find space utterly disgusting lack of effort

Chalobah another, strolls around, no change of pace, ducked  three headers I counted off goal kicks, his job is to win the ball ahead of Pieters as Okay does, he was utterly terrible and I hope the not fit to wear the shirt stuck in his throat as it was aimed at him as much as anybody else
Come in on decent money on an 18 month deal and shown little ambition or heart from day one

Furlong was terrible, TGH struggled but I saw no lack of effort Swift and Chalobah though we’re disgusting

Cuzer
I don't recall having seen Swift on Tuesday but I didn't have my glasses on. My son said he was there.

I don't blame Chalobah; I blame whoever deemed him a signing we should make. I had seen him play previously a few times and never thought anything of him. He's been a bit nomadic and is clearly on the way down. Just the sort of lazy signing we never made under DA but have loved since the relegation season. It's all well and good moving out the Sawyers, Zohores and Livermores but when you replace them with the likes of Chalobah what's the fucking point?

Spot on.

And now we're saddled with another useless lump.

We never learn.......


RE: Ratings - baggie_ray - 04-09-2023

(04-08-2023, 12:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 09:23 AM)Sliced Wrote: Griffiths 8

Furlong 1 - Shocking
Ajayi 2 - Bad game but despite being labelled  as a scapegoat, wasn't at fault for any of the goals.
Pieters 1 - All over the place
Townsend - 7 Our best outfield player by a distance, decent at both ends of the pitch

Chalobah, TGH, Swift - 1 It was basically pointless having a midfield. Each as bad as one another. Actually Chalobah gets 0 because he lost his man for the first goal

Wallace - 2 Didn't do anything

BTA and Dike - 5 Neither got much service but neither looked threatening.

Albrighton 5
Rogic 4
Grant 3
Bartley 1 - Only just came on and couldnt be arsed to pretend to close down for their third goal.

If you can tell me what he was doing for the two Hugill goals, I might begin to accept his blamelessness. By standing not where the ball is likely to go and not near any opponent who needs to be marked, you can make a case for not being to blame. I suppose. He's 6 foot 4, but doesn't win the headers. Pieters, Dike or Okay have to mark the big men. What is that all about, eh?

I'm no fan of Ajayi and think he's a walking disaster area but it is the manager who decides who stands where and who marks who when defending set pieces (and every other aspect of play, for that matter!).

For the first goal, Ajayi is assigned to mark space in the six yard box, by the near post. The ball is crossed well over his head.

For the second, he is marking a player but, again, his position is near post. Again, the ball is crossed well over his head.

What we need is how Megson would have organised it. "Big Dave, any ball in the air is for you to win. Everybody else, play off Big Dave".