WBAUnofficial
Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions (/showthread.php?tid=2925)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - Pragmatist - 03-23-2019

(03-23-2019, 08:59 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 12:25 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 10:26 AM)sickParrot Wrote: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-6840541/Villa-Derby-Sheffield-Wednesday-clubs-face-sanctions.html

Apologies for linking to the daily hate mail.

It’s really interesting reading the comments of even the more sensible posters on “Heroes and Villains”.

Firstly, they are convinced that Purslow has done a deal with the EFL for Villa to be exempt.  That simply cannot be the case as the EFL would be taken to court not only by QPR and Birmingham but also by those clubs in the Championship who have not broken the rules. I may be wrong, but I think Purslow has either misread the situation or has 
misled Villa.

Secondly, they think they are safe because the EFL has announced that only Birmingham broke the rules in 2017/8.  That may be true re 2017/8, but they are spectacularly missing the point that under the new rules the test runs for 2018/9 as well!    That’s why any club “under watch” has to submit forecast accounts for this current season during March so that any sanctions (if they are clearly in breach this season) can be applied in respect of this season!  Those sanctions can include relegation, loss of an automatic promotion place, loss of a play-off place, plus embargos and points deductions for next season!   These new regulations were brought in specifically to overcomes the farce of not being able to apply sanctions till March next year when the audited accounts come out.

I think those clubs are in deep trouble right now, and it will make no difference who they sell in the summer which will only assist them re their assessment for NEXT season.

This could get very interesting as I’ve read (can’t confirm it’s accuracy) that 28th March is the latest date this season by when points can be deducted.

You are allowed 39m losses over 3 seasons. 

Villa are well in excess of that. 

Sheff W have gone for bust bringing Bruce in - their owner has already admitted that.  

No idea what Derby's position is.

The other very amusing point about Villa is where their fans talk about taking a 6-point penalty if it means they can hold on to Grealish and McGinn. They don’t seem to realise the extent of the problem.  It’s a rolling 3-year test.  They are about to fail the 2018-9 test which covers 2016/7, 2017/8 and 2018/9.  The large losses from 2017/8 and 2018/9 form the first year of the 2019/20 test, and so on.  They are bound to fail next year’s test as well!


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - Kit Kat Chunky - 03-23-2019

(03-23-2019, 09:11 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 08:59 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 12:25 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 10:26 AM)sickParrot Wrote: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-6840541/Villa-Derby-Sheffield-Wednesday-clubs-face-sanctions.html

Apologies for linking to the daily hate mail.

It’s really interesting reading the comments of even the more sensible posters on “Heroes and Villains”.

Firstly, they are convinced that Purslow has done a deal with the EFL for Villa to be exempt.  That simply cannot be the case as the EFL would be taken to court not only by QPR and Birmingham but also by those clubs in the Championship who have not broken the rules. I may be wrong, but I think Purslow has either misread the situation or has 
misled Villa.

Secondly, they think they are safe because the EFL has announced that only Birmingham broke the rules in 2017/8.  That may be true re 2017/8, but they are spectacularly missing the point that under the new rules the test runs for 2018/9 as well!    That’s why any club “under watch” has to submit forecast accounts for this current season during March so that any sanctions (if they are clearly in breach this season) can be applied in respect of this season!  Those sanctions can include relegation, loss of an automatic promotion place, loss of a play-off place, plus embargos and points deductions for next season!   These new regulations were brought in specifically to overcomes the farce of not being able to apply sanctions till March next year when the audited accounts come out.

I think those clubs are in deep trouble right now, and it will make no difference who they sell in the summer which will only assist them re their assessment for NEXT season.

This could get very interesting as I’ve read (can’t confirm it’s accuracy) that 28th March is the latest date this season by when points can be deducted.

You are allowed 39m losses over 3 seasons. 

Villa are well in excess of that. 

Sheff W have gone for bust bringing Bruce in - their owner has already admitted that.  

No idea what Derby's position is.

The other very amusing point about Villa is where their fans talk about taking a 6-point penalty if it means they can hold on to Grealish and McGinn. They don’t seem to realise the extent of the problem.  It’s a rolling 3-year test.  They are about to fail the 2018-9 test which covers 2016/7, 2017/8 and 2018/9.  The large losses from 2017/8 and 2018/9 form the first year of the 2019/20 test, and so on.  They are bound to fail next year’s test as well!
I think you raise some interesting points, Prag. I'll add my tuppence worth in this post, rather than individually.

Firstly, with my understanding of the rules, I 99% agree with you. There has been some comment though, (I think it was in the EFL ruling) that those who were in breach last March, were given until the end of June to rectify the situation. Only Blues failed to do so, hence why they were placed under soft embargo. They were expecting c£9M of transfer fees in (Butland sell on??) which failed to arrive. Again this was in the EFL summary.

If we fast forward to this season, Villa would be given opportunity to rectify the situation this summer if the same scenario applies - but as you state the EFL has the ability to apply sanctions now, to prevent promotion for clubs who are breaking the rules. So what of our Neighbours Wolves, who many clubs complained about last year? They were investigated, but found to be clean. They then posted large losses for last season, which would have bust the rolling 3 year budget. They will argue, that but for promotion bonuses, they would have complied, but we will never know. Many are saying that promotion is the only espcape if you are about to bust the rules, but the whole point of the March filings is a "2+1" return (2 years historic + current year forecast based on 10 months trading) to stop this sort of stuff in its tracks.

Where Villa have half an argument, is that the new owners will claim they cannot be held responsible for previous owner's losses, and the more I think about it, the more I can foresee a situation where a new clock could start ticking with new ownership. I'm not saying this is the case here, but I do understand the argument. Why would you save a club, in the knowledge that for the next 2 years it would be a money pit, and for good measure you faced a certain sanction from the authorities? If this logic is applied though, you would have to work to a strictly monitored budget, and lose no more than say £13M a season. It defies belief that they have lost less than this, given the extent of the wages they pay, and the transfer fees they have paid out, with no fees coming in (Phoney Tony sold off all the future fees last season).

I think the EFL needs to come out and tell us how these rules really do work. I know many aren't bothered, but those of us who take an interest in such matters would like to know. I think we can work out what the accounts really mean, and the help of guys like Swiss Ramble help here. What we don't know is how the EFL interpret such matters. I don't understand why it is so clandestine.

My final point is future failings. Given the losses the Blues have posted for last season (which was the forecast that caused them to fail last March), and the likely losses this season, based upon the level of parental financial support that the recent accounts say they need for this current season, you would expect them to fail again this March. It was reported by some journalists yesterday though that this will not be the case, in almost a "double jeopardy" scenario. Instead they will have to work within a strict budget moving forward, rather than be kicked for previous misdemeanors.  You could argue that they still have the benefit of the players they blew the budget on, but then again those players have hardly performed well. I don't know how true it is about future monitoring/compliance with the rules - again the EFL haven't told us how it works.


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - Pragmatist - 03-23-2019

(03-23-2019, 09:31 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 09:11 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 08:59 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 12:25 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 10:26 AM)sickParrot Wrote: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-6840541/Villa-Derby-Sheffield-Wednesday-clubs-face-sanctions.html

Apologies for linking to the daily hate mail.

It’s really interesting reading the comments of even the more sensible posters on “Heroes and Villains”.

Firstly, they are convinced that Purslow has done a deal with the EFL for Villa to be exempt.  That simply cannot be the case as the EFL would be taken to court not only by QPR and Birmingham but also by those clubs in the Championship who have not broken the rules. I may be wrong, but I think Purslow has either misread the situation or has 
misled Villa.

Secondly, they think they are safe because the EFL has announced that only Birmingham broke the rules in 2017/8.  That may be true re 2017/8, but they are spectacularly missing the point that under the new rules the test runs for 2018/9 as well!    That’s why any club “under watch” has to submit forecast accounts for this current season during March so that any sanctions (if they are clearly in breach this season) can be applied in respect of this season!  Those sanctions can include relegation, loss of an automatic promotion place, loss of a play-off place, plus embargos and points deductions for next season!   These new regulations were brought in specifically to overcomes the farce of not being able to apply sanctions till March next year when the audited accounts come out.

I think those clubs are in deep trouble right now, and it will make no difference who they sell in the summer which will only assist them re their assessment for NEXT season.

This could get very interesting as I’ve read (can’t confirm it’s accuracy) that 28th March is the latest date this season by when points can be deducted.

You are allowed 39m losses over 3 seasons. 

Villa are well in excess of that. 

Sheff W have gone for bust bringing Bruce in - their owner has already admitted that.  

No idea what Derby's position is.

The other very amusing point about Villa is where their fans talk about taking a 6-point penalty if it means they can hold on to Grealish and McGinn. They don’t seem to realise the extent of the problem.  It’s a rolling 3-year test.  They are about to fail the 2018-9 test which covers 2016/7, 2017/8 and 2018/9.  The large losses from 2017/8 and 2018/9 form the first year of the 2019/20 test, and so on.  They are bound to fail next year’s test as well!
I think you raise some interesting points, Prag. I'll add my tuppence worth in this post, rather than individually.

Firstly, with my understanding of the rules, I 99% agree with you. There has been some comment though, (I think it was in the EFL ruling) that those who were in breach last March, were given until the end of June to rectify the situation. Only Blues failed to do so, hence why they were placed under soft embargo. They were expecting c£9M of transfer fees in (Butland sell on??) which failed to arrive. Again this was in the EFL summary.

If we fast forward to this season, Villa would be given opportunity to rectify the situation this summer if the same scenario applies - but as you state the EFL has the ability to apply sanctions now, to prevent promotion for clubs who are breaking the rules. So what of our Neighbours Wolves, who many clubs complained about last year? They were investigated, but found to be clean. They then posted large losses for last season, which would have bust the rolling 3 year budget. They will argue, that but for promotion bonuses, they would have complied, but we will never know. Many are saying that promotion is the only espcape if you are about to bust the rules, but the whole point of the March filings is a "2+1" return (2 years historic + current year forecast based on 10 months trading) to stop this sort of stuff in its tracks.

Where Villa have half an argument, is that the new owners will claim they cannot be held responsible for previous owner's losses, and the more I think about it, the more I can foresee a situation where a new clock could start ticking with new ownership. I'm not saying this is the case here, but I do understand the argument. Why would you save a club, in the knowledge that for the next 2 years it would be a money pit, and for good measure you faced a certain sanction from the authorities? If this logic is applied though, you would have to work to a strictly monitored budget, and lose no more than say £13M a season. It defies belief that they have lost less than this, given the extent of the wages they pay, and the transfer fees they have paid out, with no fees coming in (Phoney Tony sold off all the future fees last season).

I think the EFL needs to come out and tell us how these rules really do work. I know many aren't bothered, but those of us who take an interest in such matters would like to know. I think we can work out what the accounts really mean, and the help of guys like Swiss Ramble help here. What we don't know is how the EFL interpret such matters. I don't understand why it is so clandestine.

Some very good points there mate.

The EFL will ask Villa whether they can eradicate the shortfall by June but after 10 months trading its impossible unless they have assets which can be sold at a profit before then.  They haven’t though, and player sales cannot happen until the new window opens on 1st July. 

If Wolves only failed the test last season because of promotion bonuses then they are clear. There is an exclusion for costs which solely arose due to achieving promotion and not otherwise payable. 

A loophole of avoiding sanctions in the event of a sale of the club is too easy a copout. It still enables a club to gamble/cheat and not suffer any consequences. It doesn’t seem as though Blues received any leeway when the damage was done under a previous regime. You are right that it would make a reckless club less attractive to rescue, but surely that should be a deterrent to allowing the situation to arise on the first place?


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - Kit Kat Chunky - 03-23-2019

(03-23-2019, 09:49 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 09:31 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 09:11 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 08:59 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(03-23-2019, 12:25 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: It’s really interesting reading the comments of even the more sensible posters on “Heroes and Villains”.

Firstly, they are convinced that Purslow has done a deal with the EFL for Villa to be exempt.  That simply cannot be the case as the EFL would be taken to court not only by QPR and Birmingham but also by those clubs in the Championship who have not broken the rules. I may be wrong, but I think Purslow has either misread the situation or has 
misled Villa.

Secondly, they think they are safe because the EFL has announced that only Birmingham broke the rules in 2017/8.  That may be true re 2017/8, but they are spectacularly missing the point that under the new rules the test runs for 2018/9 as well!    That’s why any club “under watch” has to submit forecast accounts for this current season during March so that any sanctions (if they are clearly in breach this season) can be applied in respect of this season!  Those sanctions can include relegation, loss of an automatic promotion place, loss of a play-off place, plus embargos and points deductions for next season!   These new regulations were brought in specifically to overcomes the farce of not being able to apply sanctions till March next year when the audited accounts come out.

I think those clubs are in deep trouble right now, and it will make no difference who they sell in the summer which will only assist them re their assessment for NEXT season.

This could get very interesting as I’ve read (can’t confirm it’s accuracy) that 28th March is the latest date this season by when points can be deducted.

You are allowed 39m losses over 3 seasons. 

Villa are well in excess of that. 

Sheff W have gone for bust bringing Bruce in - their owner has already admitted that.  

No idea what Derby's position is.

The other very amusing point about Villa is where their fans talk about taking a 6-point penalty if it means they can hold on to Grealish and McGinn. They don’t seem to realise the extent of the problem.  It’s a rolling 3-year test.  They are about to fail the 2018-9 test which covers 2016/7, 2017/8 and 2018/9.  The large losses from 2017/8 and 2018/9 form the first year of the 2019/20 test, and so on.  They are bound to fail next year’s test as well!
I think you raise some interesting points, Prag. I'll add my tuppence worth in this post, rather than individually.

Firstly, with my understanding of the rules, I 99% agree with you. There has been some comment though, (I think it was in the EFL ruling) that those who were in breach last March, were given until the end of June to rectify the situation. Only Blues failed to do so, hence why they were placed under soft embargo. They were expecting c£9M of transfer fees in (Butland sell on??) which failed to arrive. Again this was in the EFL summary.

If we fast forward to this season, Villa would be given opportunity to rectify the situation this summer if the same scenario applies - but as you state the EFL has the ability to apply sanctions now, to prevent promotion for clubs who are breaking the rules. So what of our Neighbours Wolves, who many clubs complained about last year? They were investigated, but found to be clean. They then posted large losses for last season, which would have bust the rolling 3 year budget. They will argue, that but for promotion bonuses, they would have complied, but we will never know. Many are saying that promotion is the only espcape if you are about to bust the rules, but the whole point of the March filings is a "2+1" return (2 years historic + current year forecast based on 10 months trading) to stop this sort of stuff in its tracks.

Where Villa have half an argument, is that the new owners will claim they cannot be held responsible for previous owner's losses, and the more I think about it, the more I can foresee a situation where a new clock could start ticking with new ownership. I'm not saying this is the case here, but I do understand the argument. Why would you save a club, in the knowledge that for the next 2 years it would be a money pit, and for good measure you faced a certain sanction from the authorities? If this logic is applied though, you would have to work to a strictly monitored budget, and lose no more than say £13M a season. It defies belief that they have lost less than this, given the extent of the wages they pay, and the transfer fees they have paid out, with no fees coming in (Phoney Tony sold off all the future fees last season).

I think the EFL needs to come out and tell us how these rules really do work. I know many aren't bothered, but those of us who take an interest in such matters would like to know. I think we can work out what the accounts really mean, and the help of guys like Swiss Ramble help here. What we don't know is how the EFL interpret such matters. I don't understand why it is so clandestine.

Some very good points there mate.

The EFL will ask Villa whether they can eradicate the shortfall by June but after 10 months trading its impossible unless they have assets which can be sold at a profit before then.  They haven’t though, and player sales cannot happen until the new window opens on 1st July. 

If Wolves only failed the test last season because of promotion bonuses then they are clear. There is an exclusion for costs which solely arose due to achieving promotion and not otherwise payable. 

A loophole of avoiding sanctions in the event of a sale of the club is too easy a copout. It still enables a club to gamble/cheat and not suffer any consequences. It doesn’t seem as though Blues received any leeway when the damage was done under a previous regime. You are right that it would make a reckless club less attractive to rescue, but surely that should be a deterrent to allowing the situation to arise on the first place?

Thanks Prag.

The point with eradicating the situation n June though, is at what point do you deduct the points? If 9 points had been deducted off Blues last March, based on their forecasts, then they would have finished on 35 points, and been relegated. Surely this is what should have happened? (Not saying I would want to see Blues relegated, but making the point). 

I agree on the takeover issue. Villa was a true third party sale, but there would be nothing to stop "soft" sales to cheat the rules. 

Plenty to run on this one.


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - Pragmatist - 03-23-2019

KKC

The only reason why that didn’t apply to Blues last year was a timing issue. This season is the end of the first full 3-year cycle under the changes made in 2016. 2016/7 was the first year under the new system, then 2017/8, so it is only this season when the EFL have the ability to take into account the current year forecast and apply it this season with it being the third year of the cycle.

The EFL are under huge pressure now to be consistent. Can’t see Villa escaping major sanctions this week but I think the EFL’s lawyers are going to be kept busy.


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - Kit Kat Chunky - 03-23-2019

(03-23-2019, 10:06 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: KKC

The only reason why that didn’t apply to Blues last year was a timing issue.  This season is the end of the first full 3-year cycle under the changes made in 2016.  2016/7 was the first year under the new system, then 2017/8, so it is only this season when the EFL have the ability to take into account the current year forecast and apply it this season with it being the third year of the cycle.

The EFL are under huge pressure now to be consistent.  Can’t see Villa escaping major sanctions this week but I think the EFL’s lawyers are going to be kept busy.

I'll bow to your more in depth research, but I thought sanctions were available last March. Anyway, it doesn't matter. The here and now is important. Alan Nixon is reporting that Villa aren't worried. I'm guessing this is either something to do with the revaluation of the ground on relegation, which created a loss, and a subsequent upwards valuation will create a profit in the 10+2 forecast. JRP did something similar with the amortisation of players contracts on relegation. I can't see such an argument working, though. P&S basically turns the P&L into a cashflow, and such revaluations do not impact on cash.

Either that, or a legal argument on previous ownership.

As you say, the EFL are going to be kept busy. According to reports, those clubs at risk were arguing vociferously at the EFL meeting of the 72 members this week in Nottingham. I think it is important for the members to stay strong. there are only a handful of clubs trying to cheat the system. Many more are perfectly happy with it.

It's a bit like Brexit  Big Grin Big Grin


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - fbaggy - 03-24-2019

Alan Nixon just tweeted that the Vile are looking to make around £13M in wages savings with a summer cull of players


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - albion_pigeon - 03-24-2019

(03-24-2019, 10:24 AM)fbaggy Wrote: Alan Nixon just tweeted that the Vile are looking to make around £13M in wages savings with a summer cull of players

So a third of the £39 mil?

Sounds like they're working on the premise the rules have been "reset" for them?


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - Kit Kat Chunky - 03-24-2019

(03-24-2019, 11:14 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(03-24-2019, 10:24 AM)fbaggy Wrote: Alan Nixon just tweeted that the Vile are looking to make around £13M in wages savings with a summer cull of players

So a third of the £39 mil?

Sounds like they're working on the premise the rules have been "reset" for them?

There seems to be a common consensus that there will have to be a fire sale to comply going forward, if they do not achieve promotion.

Even if they sneak promotion, they will be limited on their salary bill, per Prem rules.

Bed sheets at the ready................


RE: Aston Villa, Derby County and Sheffield Wednesday all facing sanctions - Tom Joad - 03-24-2019

As someone said earlier. The rules need to be simple and transparent, not clandestine. They should also be watertight and clear enough to pre empt any legal bunfights. I have no knowledge of how they currently work but it seems absolutely clear to me that Villa are paying out way more than they could ever rake in without Premiership TV money.
Oh, and thanks to KKC and Prag for translating all this into something I almost understand!