WBAUnofficial
Our conservative approach - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Our conservative approach (/showthread.php?tid=29143)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Our conservative approach - oldun - 03-08-2023

(03-08-2023, 09:30 AM)Cuzer Wrote: I don't sense that

Only a couple of times, Stoke at Home, Luton away when in front he's gone 5 at the back and invited teams on, backing us to deal with it, which we did in both instances

Thought last night we just needed that 2nd, we had plenty of chances to get a second, any side in this league will have moments and Wigan did at the end, going direct but I don't see us a side who sits on a lead personally, hit the woodwork four times last night

Cuzer

I thought we were just holding the ball, passing around and making them run around, bit concerned they won a few headers in our box though


RE: Our conservative approach - Cheshire East Baggie - 03-08-2023

My feeling is that if even one of those 5 or so chances (woodwork or open goals missed) had gone in, we wouldn't be talking about a conservative approach or criticising the changes that maybe weakened us late on.

Main points for me:
Molumby is key, needs to stay fit and avoid suspension. Chalobah doesn't provide enough energy or movement.
Okay was always looking for the ball, much more so than at Hull. Gets us out of that centre-back to goalie possession loop.
Swift had one of the best games I've seen him play. All over the pitch, strong in possession, intelligent passing.
Dike looked the player we thought we'd bought. Impressive.
Ajayi is catastrophic. I know there are some who say "O'Shea's no good on the left", but that's crap. Ajayi was skinned within moments of coming on and Wigan never stopped attacking from that point. Barts may get fit (or not) but we need a new partner for Dara long term.
Full backs were both dodgy at times.


RE: Our conservative approach - GunsOfNavarone - 03-08-2023

Nothing wrong with the approach and tactics last night. The problems such as they were centred on occasionally poor decisions, the final ball, finishing and concentration.

Despite those shortcomings which read back as quite damning we should still have won the game at a canter. We will play better and lose which we already have at times.


RE: Our conservative approach - Fido - 03-08-2023

(03-08-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My feeling is that if even one of those 5 or so chances (woodwork or open goals missed) had gone in, we wouldn't be talking about a conservative approach or criticising the changes that maybe weakened us late on.

Main points for me:
Molumby is key, needs to stay fit and avoid suspension. Chalobah doesn't provide enough energy or movement.
Okay was always looking for the ball, much more so than at Hull. Gets us out of that centre-back to goalie possession loop.
Swift had one of the best games I've seen him play. All over the pitch, strong in possession, intelligent passing.
Dike looked the player we thought we'd bought. Impressive.
Ajayi is catastrophic. I know there are some who say "O'Shea's no good on the left", but that's crap. Ajayi was skinned within moments of coming on and Wigan never stopped attacking from that point. Barts may get fit (or not) but we need a new partner for Dara long term.
Full backs were both dodgy at times.

Agree with pretty much all of this. A couple of times Swift ballsed up passes in attacking positions which meant chances went but at least he was trying to get the ball behind their line and open them up.


RE: Our conservative approach - Spandaubaggie - 03-08-2023

(03-08-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My feeling is that if even one of those 5 or so chances (woodwork or open goals missed) had gone in, we wouldn't be talking about a conservative approach or criticising the changes that maybe weakened us late on.

Main points for me:
Molumby is key, needs to stay fit and avoid suspension. Chalobah doesn't provide enough energy or movement.
Okay was always looking for the ball, much more so than at Hull. Gets us out of that centre-back to goalie possession loop.
Swift had one of the best games I've seen him play. All over the pitch, strong in possession, intelligent passing.
Dike looked the player we thought we'd bought. Impressive.
Ajayi is catastrophic. I know there are some who say "O'Shea's no good on the left", but that's crap. Ajayi was skinned within moments of coming on and Wigan never stopped attacking from that point. Barts may get fit (or not) but we need a new partner for Dara long term.
Full backs were both dodgy at times.

Very good point with Ajayi- 3 of us were commenting on it at the time. Whatever player he was he seems to have lost it.


RE: Our conservative approach - SW4Baggie - 03-08-2023

(03-08-2023, 10:13 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-08-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My feeling is that if even one of those 5 or so chances (woodwork or open goals missed) had gone in, we wouldn't be talking about a conservative approach or criticising the changes that maybe weakened us late on.

Main points for me:
Molumby is key, needs to stay fit and avoid suspension. Chalobah doesn't provide enough energy or movement.
Okay was always looking for the ball, much more so than at Hull. Gets us out of that centre-back to goalie possession loop.
Swift had one of the best games I've seen him play. All over the pitch, strong in possession, intelligent passing.
Dike looked the player we thought we'd bought. Impressive.
Ajayi is catastrophic. I know there are some who say "O'Shea's no good on the left", but that's crap. Ajayi was skinned within moments of coming on and Wigan never stopped attacking from that point. Barts may get fit (or not) but we need a new partner for Dara long term.
Full backs were both dodgy at times.

Very good point with Ajayi- 3 of us were commenting on it at the time. Whatever player he was he seems to have lost it.

Ajayi better with a dominant player alongside him - Dara is a very solid CB but think he’s better when he can concentrate on his own game. Ajayi is a much better player alongside Bartley, who offers a more commanding presence.

Also think Ajayi is far better when playing a high line and his pace can be utilised. When we play as deep we were sitting when he came on there’s very little chance for him to use his limbs and pace to recover from his other flaws.

Pieters offers composure and balance but as Cuzer said, every now and again there’s a sign that he’s an LB at CB. I would have Bartley back in when fit, if nothing else just for his aerial threat in both boxes.


RE: Our conservative approach - Spandaubaggie - 03-08-2023

(03-08-2023, 10:37 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-08-2023, 10:13 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-08-2023, 10:08 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My feeling is that if even one of those 5 or so chances (woodwork or open goals missed) had gone in, we wouldn't be talking about a conservative approach or criticising the changes that maybe weakened us late on.

Main points for me:
Molumby is key, needs to stay fit and avoid suspension. Chalobah doesn't provide enough energy or movement.
Okay was always looking for the ball, much more so than at Hull. Gets us out of that centre-back to goalie possession loop.
Swift had one of the best games I've seen him play. All over the pitch, strong in possession, intelligent passing.
Dike looked the player we thought we'd bought. Impressive.
Ajayi is catastrophic. I know there are some who say "O'Shea's no good on the left", but that's crap. Ajayi was skinned within moments of coming on and Wigan never stopped attacking from that point. Barts may get fit (or not) but we need a new partner for Dara long term.
Full backs were both dodgy at times.

Very good point with Ajayi- 3 of us were commenting on it at the time. Whatever player he was he seems to have lost it.

Ajayi better with a dominant player alongside him - Dara is a very solid CB but think he’s better when he can concentrate on his own game. Ajayi is a much better player alongside Bartley, who offers a more commanding presence.

Also think Ajayi is far better when playing a high line and his pace can be utilised. When we play as deep we were sitting when he came on there’s very little chance for him to use his limbs and pace to recover from his other flaws.

Pieters offers composure and balance but as Cuzer said, every now and again there’s a sign that he’s an LB at CB. I would have Bartley back in when fit, if nothing else just for his aerial threat in both boxes.

Yes, I really want to see Bartley back. Currently we are quite a short side by modern standards, with O"Shea and Dike the tallest at 6 1. We need those 6 4 characters to get their heads on the end of crosses and set pieces.


RE: Our conservative approach - Tom Joad - 03-08-2023

I'd like us to have another look at Kipre. After a shakey start he settled down after finally getting a run of games and was looking very decent when Bruce bombed him out without giving him a game. I've seen enough of Semi to notice he will always be a mistake waiting to happen. Bartley is missed, I never thought I'd say it but he wasn't looking bad before the injury.


RE: Our conservative approach - CaptainFantastico - 03-08-2023

Kipre is a far better CH than Ajayi


RE: Our conservative approach - Birdman1811 - 03-08-2023

Almost every defender in this league is a better CH than Ajayi, never understood the love for him. Has been decent enough at times, but never looked solid long term, and his positioning and game intelligence are worse than academy players.