WBAUnofficial
When the weakest link is the keeper - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: When the weakest link is the keeper (/showthread.php?tid=28841)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - Borin' Baggie - 02-11-2023

(02-11-2023, 12:30 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(02-10-2023, 11:44 PM)devonbaggie Wrote: There must be another keeper out of contract who is better than Button? I'm assuming Foster is out of the question.

Can’t see why Foster would be out of the question. We should be offering him a blank cheque for the rest of the season.

Foster turned down a lot of money for a short term deal at Newcastle because it's too far, I honestly think he'd prefer to play for us than Spurs so he can spend more time at home.


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - Calgary_Baggie - 02-11-2023

(02-11-2023, 12:30 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(02-10-2023, 11:44 PM)devonbaggie Wrote: There must be another keeper out of contract who is better than Button? I'm assuming Foster is out of the question.

Can’t see why Foster would be out of the question. We should be offering him a blank cheque for the rest of the season.

Because he's retired and no longer wants to be involved in competitive football. 

Comes to something when you're trying to drag pundits out of retirement.


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - Kit Kat Chunky - 02-11-2023

Newcastle offered Foster a kings ransom for this year and he turned them down.

Johnstone is about 8th on my list after watching for 50 years. Jimmy is in the bottom 3


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - Stillclem4england - 02-11-2023

Totally agree Spandau.

In nearly 40 years he is the worst I have seen. That Zuberbuehler, Adamson and Crichton are better than him is truly embarrassing. Most keepers will go through a career without conceding a Mejbri goal or a Sarr one; let alone conceding two in a season. Useless wanker.

I'm struggling to see one thing he is good at: doesn't save saveable shots, flaps at crosses, positioning is schoolboy-esque... And the worst thing is that Blues targeted him and all opposition teams will now if they have done their homework. He simply cannot be picked. We cannot afford to go a goal down each game and the way CC allows us to hang onto a one goal lead and defend will not work with the hapless clown in goal.


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - Peachy - 02-11-2023

(02-11-2023, 09:43 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Totally agree Spandau.

In nearly 40 years he is the worst I have seen. That Zuberbuehler, Adamson and Crichton are better than him is truly embarrassing. Most keepers will go through a career without conceding a Mejbri goal or a Sarr one; let alone conceding two in a season. Useless wanker.

I'm struggling to see one thing he is good at: doesn't save saveable shots, flaps at crosses, positioning is schoolboy-esque... And the worst thing is that Blues targeted him and all opposition teams will now if they have done their homework. He simply cannot be picked. We cannot afford to go a goal down each game and the way CC allows us to hang onto a one goal lead and defend will not work with the hapless clown in goal.

Agree with all that. Never did I think I would ever see someone worse than Crichton yet Button is by some distance the worst Albion keeper I have ever witnessed.


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - TETLEY74 - 02-11-2023

(02-10-2023, 11:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Since Megson we've been lucky to generally always have a decent 'Keeper, Hoult, Kuszczak, Kiely, brief period we suffered through Carson who was only bad compared to the others in this list, Foster and then Johnstone. It was a crucial part of us doing well over that period. Button is probably the worst over that period, by a long way, even worse that Zuberhowler. Palmer has been decent and has kept up with that illustrious list.

Hopefully Griffiths get's a chance and does ok until Palmer is back, because Button harms the team.

Its no coincidence that our up turn in form more or less started with introduction of Palmer in goal. The back four looked more composed and assured and marshalled, then Button returns due to Palmers injury and said defence looks panic stricken.


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - BaggieBaggieBromBrom - 02-11-2023

Button was dropped cos he’s awful. Brought back in and he’s still awful. He’s awful.


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - Sliced - 02-11-2023

(02-10-2023, 11:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Since Megson we've been lucky to generally always have a decent 'Keeper, Hoult, Kuszczak, Kiely, brief period we suffered through Carson who was only bad compared to the others in this list, Foster and then Johnstone. It was a crucial part of us doing well over that period. Button is probably the worst over that period, by a long way, even worse that Zuberhowler. Palmer has been decent and has kept up with that illustrious list.

Hopefully Griffiths get's a chance and does ok until Palmer is back, because Button harms the team.

Absolutely.

I know it was a little hearwarming last week to see the team build him up because he got a clean sheet but ffs he's not a 17 year old playing his first game. He's towards the end of his career.

He faced ONE shot on target and was treated like he'd had an absolute stormer.


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - Spandaubaggie - 02-11-2023

(02-11-2023, 11:13 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-10-2023, 11:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Since Megson we've been lucky to generally always have a decent 'Keeper, Hoult, Kuszczak, Kiely, brief period we suffered through Carson who was only bad compared to the others in this list, Foster and then Johnstone. It was a crucial part of us doing well over that period. Button is probably the worst over that period, by a long way, even worse that Zuberhowler. Palmer has been decent and has kept up with that illustrious list.

Hopefully Griffiths get's a chance and does ok until Palmer is back, because Button harms the team.

Absolutely.

I know it was a little hearwarming last week to see the team build him up because he got a clean sheet but ffs he's not a 17 year old playing his first game. He's towards the end of his career.

He faced ONE shot on target and was treated like he'd had an absolute stormer.
I think many hoped the howler free quiet night v Coventry was a reset where his confidence would grow and he would prove us all wrong. It wasn’t. 
I will support him as long as he is in our goal but simply he should not be in such a level of football.
He may have been a decent player at one time but it’s so clear he is not of a level that should see him in the second tier of professional football.

I really expect that last night was his last game for us. 

I feel sorry on a human level for him but he is massively well paid and probably wealthier than any of us so that should cushion the load. 

Sorry David, I wish you the best, but I don’t want you hampering my football team anymore.


RE: When the weakest link is the keeper - EastMidsBaggie - 02-11-2023

(02-11-2023, 10:34 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(02-10-2023, 11:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Since Megson we've been lucky to generally always have a decent 'Keeper, Hoult, Kuszczak, Kiely, brief period we suffered through Carson who was only bad compared to the others in this list, Foster and then Johnstone. It was a crucial part of us doing well over that period. Button is probably the worst over that period, by a long way, even worse that Zuberhowler. Palmer has been decent and has kept up with that illustrious list.

Hopefully Griffiths get's a chance and does ok until Palmer is back, because Button harms the team.

Its no coincidence that our up turn in form more or less started with introduction of Palmer in goal. The back four looked more composed and assured and marshalled, then Button returns due to Palmers injury and said defence looks panic stricken.

The signs were there at Chesterfield so Carlos knew how poor the guy is and won't improve at his age.