WBAUnofficial
Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit (/showthread.php?tid=28029)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - Tom Joad - 12-18-2022

(12-17-2022, 11:36 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Difference between you and I Tom, is that I spent a large part of my career cleaning up coalfield sites and ex-power stations in the green belt creating thousands of quality, sustainable jobs that wouldn’t kill you via lung disease.

Look at Hams Hall, Birch Coppice, Bermuda, Keresley and tell me I’m wrong. There are tens of thousands of acres of scrubby unproductive and unattractive fields surrounding every city that wouldn’t cost a fortune to bring forward like the rancid, foul polluted crap I worked on.

And there’s none of that crap left to bring forward anyway. It’s all been done.

I actually believe that you (Proth) and I  would like the same thing, we just disagree on how to achieve it. Hams Hall is a good example you quoted, I walk a lot around the wildlife sanctuaries areas that surround it. It works well.  Not such a good example is the green belt destruction at Peddimore nearby. 5000 houses and an industrial area being built over fields and ancient rights of ways.There are numerous examples of vacant industrial/commercial land nearby but of course, nowhere near as attractive as clean land. I think we have a duty to look after the land,as when it's gone it's gone.


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - Protheroe - 12-18-2022

(12-18-2022, 09:10 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(12-17-2022, 11:36 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Difference between you and I Tom, is that I spent a large part of my career cleaning up coalfield sites and ex-power stations in the green belt creating thousands of quality, sustainable jobs that wouldn’t kill you via lung disease.

Look at Hams Hall, Birch Coppice, Bermuda, Keresley and tell me I’m wrong. There are tens of thousands of acres of scrubby unproductive and unattractive fields surrounding every city that wouldn’t cost a fortune to bring forward like the rancid, foul polluted crap I worked on.

And there’s none of that crap left to bring forward anyway. It’s all been done.

I actually believe that you (Proth) and I  would like the same thing, we just disagree on how to achieve it. Hams Hall is a good example you quoted, I walk a lot around the wildlife sanctuaries areas that surround it. It works well.  Not such a good example is the green belt destruction at Peddimore nearby. 5000 houses and an industrial area being built over fields and ancient rights of ways. There are numerous examples of vacant industrial/commercial land nearby but of course, nowhere near as attractive as clean land. I think we have a duty to look after the land,as when it's gone it's gone.

Where?

Even the most foul sites around M6 Junction 10 are being reclaimed. I simply don't know where these numerous examples are.


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - baggy1 - 12-18-2022

(12-17-2022, 11:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The government should also be accelerating deregulation of the City which pretty much bankrolls the rest of the UK anyway and always will, and deregulating gene editing and GMO (where we are a world leader) and which has the potential to contribute enormously to coping with climate change.

What does this actually mean Proth, I work in Financial Services and deal with a lot of regulation of which the vast majority is required due to the crooks and chancers that inhabit this world. It's a hugely generic statement I see bandied about regularly without any substance. Which bit of regulation would you get rid of?


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - Protheroe - 12-18-2022

Solvency II in particular, the government has "plans" to reform this but to say they're dragging their feet would be an understatement.


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - baggy1 - 12-18-2022

And that's it?


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - Borin' Baggie - 12-18-2022

The City diverging from the EU while New York is granted equivalency with the EU will definitely help the City...

(12-17-2022, 11:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote: and deregulating gene editing and GMO (where we are a world leader) and which has the potential to contribute enormously to coping with climate change.

This is one of the dumbest things I've read, stop getting your science journalism from political hacks in the Times and Spectator.

GMO and gene editing are not equivalent and we should absolutely under no circumstances ever deregulate GMO. GMO is the biggest agricultural monopolisation risk, forcing producers to use certified crops under licence and as with all monopolies that drives up market costs. Not to mention cross contamination risks that could force agricultural businesses into licensing seeds involuntarily.

The belief that GMO and gene editing are the same thing is why countries like Austria are worried about the latter because they're thinking about the consequences of the latter. GMO, no. Gene editing, go for it.


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - Tom Joad - 12-18-2022

Protheroe Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
Protheroe Wrote:Difference between you and I Tom, is that I spent a large part of my career cleaning up coalfield sites and ex-power stations in the green belt creating thousands of quality, sustainable jobs that wouldn’t kill you via lung disease.

Look at Hams Hall, Birch Coppice, Bermuda, Keresley and tell me I’m wrong. There are tens of thousands of acres of scrubby unproductive and unattractive fields surrounding every city that wouldn’t cost a fortune to bring forward like the rancid, foul polluted crap I worked on.

And there’s none of that crap left to bring forward anyway. It’s all been done.

I actually believe that you (Proth) and I  would like the same thing, we just disagree on how to achieve it. Hams Hall is a good example you quoted, I walk a lot around the wildlife sanctuaries areas that surround it. It works well.  Not such a good example is the green belt destruction at Peddimore nearby. 5000 houses and an industrial area being built over fields and ancient rights of ways. There are numerous examples of vacant industrial/commercial land nearby but of course, nowhere near as attractive as clean land. I think we have a duty to look after the land,as when it's gone it's gone.

Where?

Even the most foul sites around M6 Junction 10 are being reclaimed. I simply don't know where these numerous examples are.
They are numerous, off the top of my head and in that area for example,  along the Heartlands Spine Rd.


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - Protheroe - 12-19-2022

There are no developable and serviceable sites on the Heartlands Spine Road at all. They’d all been developed long before I left the industry in 2008.

And thanks BB, I am aware of the difference between the two and as usual I don’t agree with your shrill and hyperbolic fear of progress.


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - Derek Hardballs - 12-19-2022

(12-19-2022, 05:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: There are no developable and serviceable sites on the Heartlands Spine Road at all. They’d all been developed long before I left the industry in 2008.

And thanks BB, I am aware of the difference between the two and as usual I don’t agree with your shrill and hyperbolic fear of progress.

Nothing says progress like concreting over the greenbelt.


RE: Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit - baggy1 - 12-19-2022

Sorry did Proth skip over the bit where he was explaining the ‘deregulation’ of the financial services sector by allowing fund managers to ‘invest’ our pension funds more easily instead of putting them in a safe place to, erm, checks notes, pay our pensions when they become due.