WBAUnofficial
Our current squad v Bilic's promotion squad - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Our current squad v Bilic's promotion squad (/showthread.php?tid=27987)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Our current squad v Bilic's promotion squad - AnelkasBeard - 12-14-2022

It's been 4 games of good play from this current squad.

Whilst they could get close to matching the Bilic promotion squad, let's not forget just how good that team played that year. They were fantastic.

Long way to go for these biffs to match them.


RE: Our current squad v Bilic's promotion squad - wbamitch - 12-14-2022

I'd go with the Bilic squad for Pereira alone, he was a cheat code and made everyone around him better. He even got HRK scoring regularly at one point. Krovinovic was also a decent option in midfield and was underused IMO.

It obviously went downhill after covid, but that side was fantastic for the first half of the season. Ferguson was playing brilliantly at fullback and we had better versions of Sawyers, Grady & Ajayi.

Current squad is clearly a strong one on paper but so many of them have been poor for a long time, the signs are good and we're in good hands it seems with CC but this group have a knack of getting your hopes up and folding when there's some pressure and expectancy. If Dike and Rogic can stay fit hopefully they can make the difference


RE: Our current squad v Bilic's promotion squad - Hopalong - 12-14-2022

(12-14-2022, 01:18 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 12:45 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(12-14-2022, 03:26 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2022, 11:47 PM)Hopalong Wrote: and in fact Bilic's Prem squad.  

I think the current squad overall is better and more experienced. 

If we keep our nerve and keep injuries to a bare minimum especially Dike, there's no reason this squad can't get promoted this season,  though it will probably need to be via the lottery of the play-offs now.  

At this level,  we have so much quality with possibly the addition of a couple of players in January. 

Certainly going to be an exciting second half of the season.

Think that’s a pretty big claim Athers.

We had players with significantly more quality in that Bilic squad IMO. Johnstone and Gibbs were head and shoulders above Palmer and Townsend, Sawyers was wonderfully suited to the role he was playing and both Livermore and Bartley were several years younger and contributing more. That’s before we consider the electric form Grady was in and the fact that in Periera we had the arguably the best player the Championship has ever seen.

I think Dike, BTA and Grant give us better striker options, but I’d still argue that Bilic's squad was better equipped in goal, in defence and midfield.

We'll agree to disagree mate.  Just opinions.  Pereira is a miss for sure.   Yokuslu is better than Livermore ever was then you have Swift, Wallace and Rogic and obviously we still have Diang and Grant.   And Dike.

(12-14-2022, 08:58 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Not like you to go OTT Athers.

What do you disagree with?  Do you have an opinion?

Grady is barely featuring and when he does he’s offered little, similarly with Grant this season. 

As much as I like Okay, he’s not playing at the level Livermore was in that promotion season.

I think the present squad has the ability to match what Bilic’s squad did, but as it stands too many of them haven’t displayed the quality we are led to believe they have or have been lacking in form for some time as as a result I’d take that squad over this one - a 2019 Diangana and Pereira were light years ahead of anything in this squad IMO.

If Dike can play like he did at Barnsley, if Swift, Wallace and Rogic can find some form, if Grady can rediscover what he had 3 years ago and if we can get Yokuslu dominating the midfield like he did under Fat Sam then I’ll agree with you. Until then, that Bilic squad is ahead.

I was talking about the actual squad of players Dumbo not performances (that is to be proven);  it sounds like you agree with me.


RE: Our current squad v Bilic's promotion squad - Johnnykayeengland - 12-14-2022

It's great to be looking up the table. It's great to be thinking of the top 6...
But this squad in the PL?
The thought terrifies me. As above, none would make any other PL team.
From Bilic squad, Pereira and Johnstone at least would. Plus perhaps Grady , Livermore from then.
But they weren't good enough to stay up either.