WBAUnofficial
The Next Bailout - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The Next Bailout (/showthread.php?tid=27495)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-06-2022

I know you don’t read any of my posts Dekka but I can assure you that I have never called for any of those things.

And I’m not the one now calling for taxpayers money - including those who rent and can’t afford to buy a house to support those who are in the fortunate position to merely have to tighten their belt a little. More trickle up economics from the asset poor. Liberals eh?


RE: The Next Bailout - Borin' Baggie - 11-06-2022

(11-06-2022, 10:35 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I know you don’t read any of my posts Dekka but I can assure you that I have never called for any of those things.

And I’m not the one now calling for taxpayers money - including those who rent and can’t afford to buy a house to support those who are in the fortunate position to merely have to tighten their belt a little. More trickle up economics from the asset poor. Liberals eh?

A rise of 10% of someone's annual income before tax is going to require a wee bit more than tightening their belt a little, especially when other costs are going up.

Is this not the kind of targeted support you have been clamouring for? As someone who rents and can't afford to buy a house I'm perfectly content with this support measure.


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-06-2022

There should be zero targeted support for any mortgage payer from the state.

I can’t believe you think such a daft policy is right. Renters subsidising the leveraged? Jesus fucking wept. What happened to mortgage holders getting a better paid or second job? Like people used to when things were a bit shit?

What happened to this country’s backbone?


RE: The Next Bailout - Borin' Baggie - 11-06-2022

Except if you'd read the policy proposal it is about recouping the cost of the grant from banks that received bailouts in 2008. An increase in outgoings of 10% of your income is huge especially when it's just one facet.

There's no simple answer to this and not doing anything will very likely exasperate the situation via another debt crisis where the only people in a position to take advantage are those with huge amounts of wealth. In an ideal world interest rates would be scaling up slowly but they just aren't. Is it a perfect policy? No, but the risk of another debt crisis and it's effect on equity, the knock-on effects on the rental markets and potentially contributing to a huge demographic crisis (the people taking out mortgages will likely want to start a family which is much needed given 20% of the UK population is now over 65 compared to 9% in 1992) which will have long term effects on the development and productivity of this country.


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-06-2022

No. No. No.

Have we learned nothing about the downside of nationalising debt and ignoring moral hazard?

If you’re over leveraged it is literally tough shit. Lenders will only repossess as a very very last resort - particularly as getting a court date would take a laughably long time. You cannot expect reality to ever return to the property market if you keep bucking it.


RE: The Next Bailout - Borin' Baggie - 11-06-2022

The whole premise of the proposal isn't to nationalise debt, it's to transfer some liability from an individual to the banks that got bailed out in 2008 in an attempt to alleviate a productivity crisis caused by external pressures. The state doesn't take on the debt.

As for the property market, that's got nowt to do with this policy or anything. In fact I'd argue people going into negative equity won't help people like me to buy their first house as lending restrictions will go stupid and we'll end up with another bubble. The only thing that will alleviate that pressure is to build more social and affordable housing to freeze the market.

You can't have your cake and eat it, you can't ignore the effect on productivity and the long term fallout from a housing debt crisis. It's not the fault of people with mortgages that interest rates have lagged where they have needed to be and are now rapidly rising to the point where it's difficult to keep up especially with wages rising below interest rate rises and general inflation. Do you want another lost decade?


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-07-2022

When a quarter of adults in this country have less than £100 in savings the idea of mortgage subsidies is exceptionally entitled.

Lenders will only repossess as a last resort if you cannot even provide a part of interest cover. Live with it.

Negative equity is only a problem if you wish to sell your home. Live with it.

There was a self described "low paid self employed artist" on Radio 4 Today the other morning with an interest-only mortgage whinging that he's be unable to afford the repayments. Aside from the fact that I have no idea how he managed to get an interest-only mortgage as a low paid self employed artist not one of the contributors suggested the obvious solution that he GET A FUCKING PROPER JOB.


RE: The Next Bailout - SophLad - 11-07-2022

(11-07-2022, 08:58 AM)Protheroe Wrote: When a quarter of adults in this country have less than £100 in savings the idea of mortgage subsidies is exceptionally entitled.

Lenders will only repossess as a last resort if you cannot even provide a part of interest cover. Live with it.

Negative equity is only a problem if you wish to sell your home. Live with it.

There was a self described  "low paid self employed artist" on Radio 4 Today the other morning with an interest-only mortgage whinging that he's be unable to afford the repayments. Aside from the fact that I have no idea how he managed to get an interest-only mortgage as a low paid self employed artist not one of the contributors suggested the obvious solution that he GET A FUCKING PROPER JOB.

Genuine question Proth:  Do you ever think about being something other than persistently joyless?


RE: The Next Bailout - Borin' Baggie - 11-07-2022

(11-07-2022, 08:58 AM)Protheroe Wrote: When a quarter of adults in this country have less than £100 in savings the idea of mortgage subsidies is exceptionally entitled.

Lenders will only repossess as a last resort if you cannot even provide a part of interest cover. Live with it.

Negative equity is only a problem if you wish to sell your home. Live with it.

There was a self described  "low paid self employed artist" on Radio 4 Today the other morning with an interest-only mortgage whinging that he's be unable to afford the repayments. Aside from the fact that I have no idea how he managed to get an interest-only mortgage as a low paid self employed artist not one of the contributors suggested the obvious solution that he GET A FUCKING PROPER JOB.

What does this have to do with the rapid increase of interest rates destabilising the market and severely threatening UK productivity in the medium term?


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-07-2022

(11-07-2022, 10:26 AM)SophLad Wrote: Genuine question Proth:  Do you ever think about being something other than persistently joyless?

I am permanently full of joy and optimism. I think you're confusing me with Dekka. Please don't do that.

(11-07-2022, 10:42 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: What does this have to do with the rapid increase of interest rates destabilising the market and severely threatening UK productivity in the medium term?

The market is not destabilised and UK productivity is not threatened in the medium term.

Quite the contrary. Suppressed interest rates have destabilised the market for over a decade and are a central reason for our productivity challenges. A return to some sort of equilibrium is to be welcomed, though that return to equilibrium is clearly not in the the interests of highly leveraged individuals or corporates (or governments).