WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=27395)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 10-29-2022

We see it differently. I thought Phillips about a 2, never found his man with a pass. Those I was with said he wasn't so bad. As ever, I disagree with the Livermore marks. Him and TGH were our best players 1st half.
Palmer 5. Shakey, poor distribution and above all, absolutely no urgency.
Furlong 2.
Townsend 0. I used to like this lad, maybe he needs a rest?
O'Shea 2. Slow for the 2nd goal and not great throughout. Maybe he needs some proper players around him?
Pieters 0. How to slow a game down to a stroll.
Livermore 5. Barely wasted a pass, has few fans but always puts a shift in.
TGH 6.5. Unlucky to be on the losing side. Some great passes. Could do better than us.
Jed 4. Worst game to date, he was due one I suppose, still got credit in the goodwill bank.
Grady 5. Won some battles, just missed the final pass at times, I feel he needs someone to play off.
Phillips 2. How many times will we see him not manage a 1-2? Tried, but he is finished at this level.
Grant 0. Shocking. No presence whatsoever.
Subs. Molumby 6. At least bought some energy, had a few digs at goal.Should be ok for where we are.
Swift 5. Eye for a pass and at last some vision. Much improved.
BTA 5. nowhere near the finished article but caused more problems in a few minutes than Grant managed in 90.
Reach 2. Neither here nor there. Must start ahead of Townsend next or bomb him out altogether and look at Ashworth.


RE: Ratings - Derek Hardballs - 10-29-2022

How does Wallace get 4 and Phillips 2? Wallace barely touched the ball.


RE: Ratings - Cuzer - 10-29-2022

(10-29-2022, 03:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: How does Wallace get 4 and Phillips 2? Wallace barely touched the ball.

Not that often I agree with you Dekka but spot on here, Wallace had a stinker today, absolute stinker

Rightly hooked

Cuzer

Tom, Livermore 5? God he was appalling today

Not helped by the system or his lack of legs but an absolute passenger today, really should have been replaced after 45

TV or there? Really is a different game from the stands and the sofa sometimes

Cuzer


RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 10-29-2022

Cuzer Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:How does Wallace get 4 and Phillips 2? Wallace barely touched the ball.

Not that often I agree with you Dekka but spot on here, Wallace had a stinker today, absolute stinker

Rightly hooked

Cuzer

Tom, Livermore 5? God he was appalling today

Not helped by the system or his lack of legs but an absolute passenger today, really should have been replaced after 45

TV or there? Really is a different game from the stands and the sofa sometimes

Cuzer

I'll let that go. STH and regular away goer.
Livermore gets 5 by the simple virtue of passing the ball regularly to a striped shirt. TGH excepted, no one else managed it. Agree, I was probably too generous for Jed.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 10-29-2022

Phillip's passing accuracy was the lowest of any of our players today other than Townsend with a whopping 66.7%. That's lower than Palmer. Every 1 in 3 passes wasn't to one of our players. For reference all of the rest of our starting outfield players had above 80%.

Yes he was involved, but he gave the ball away more than any other attacking player on the pitch by an absolute mile.


RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 10-29-2022

Sliced Wrote:Phillip's passing accuracy was the lowest of any of our players today other than Townsend with a whopping 66.7%. That's lower than Palmer. Every 1 in 3 passes wasn't to one of our players. For reference all of the rest of our starting outfield players had above 80%.

Yes he was involved, but he gave the ball away more than any other attacking player on the pitch by an absolute mile.

I'm amazed it was that high. Time and again our moves halted with him picking out a defender.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 10-29-2022

(10-29-2022, 05:35 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Sliced Wrote:Phillip's passing accuracy was the lowest of any of our players today other than Townsend with a whopping 66.7%. That's lower than Palmer. Every 1 in 3 passes wasn't to one of our players. For reference all of the rest of our starting outfield players had above 80%.

Yes he was involved, but he gave the ball away more than any other attacking player on the pitch by an absolute mile.

I'm amazed it was that high. Time and again our moves halted with him picking out a defender.

Yep. Before anyone jumps in with "you can use stats to prove anything". It was my eyes that saw move after move break down because of Phillips, the stats only subsequently confirmed it.


RE: Ratings - Cunninghamismagic - 10-29-2022

(10-29-2022, 05:35 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Sliced Wrote:Phillip's passing accuracy was the lowest of any of our players today other than Townsend with a whopping 66.7%. That's lower than Palmer. Every 1 in 3 passes wasn't to one of our players. For reference all of the rest of our starting outfield players had above 80%.

Yes he was involved, but he gave the ball away more than any other attacking player on the pitch by an absolute mile.

I'm amazed it was that high. Time and again our moves halted with him picking out a defender.

With no one in the middle to pass to he had little option.


RE: Ratings - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-29-2022

(10-29-2022, 05:44 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 05:35 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Sliced Wrote:Phillip's passing accuracy was the lowest of any of our players today other than Townsend with a whopping 66.7%. That's lower than Palmer. Every 1 in 3 passes wasn't to one of our players. For reference all of the rest of our starting outfield players had above 80%.

Yes he was involved, but he gave the ball away more than any other attacking player on the pitch by an absolute mile.

I'm amazed it was that high. Time and again our moves halted with him picking out a defender.

With no one in the middle to pass to he had little option.

That's what I thought. Karcrash Grant kept arriving after Phillips.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 10-29-2022

(10-29-2022, 05:44 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 05:35 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Sliced Wrote:Phillip's passing accuracy was the lowest of any of our players today other than Townsend with a whopping 66.7%. That's lower than Palmer. Every 1 in 3 passes wasn't to one of our players. For reference all of the rest of our starting outfield players had above 80%.

Yes he was involved, but he gave the ball away more than any other attacking player on the pitch by an absolute mile.

I'm amazed it was that high. Time and again our moves halted with him picking out a defender.

With no one in the middle to pass to he had little option.

Doesn't explain why most of our players were pushing high 80s. Phillips wasnt the only one crossing.