RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - SW4Baggie - 10-19-2022
(10-19-2022, 10:13 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I think you've got to think of the division Fat Sam was in Worcs and what was at his disposal, it didn't take him long to bin the likes of Jake, Grant, Phillips etc and bring in Okay, AMN etc
I was no Sam fan and I agree more long term would be a better appointment, Jake is gone in the summer, as is Bartley, maybe now most of us have thought this season is now all about staying up we can think a bit long term. I'm not sure Ron has a clue what he wants personally
Cuzer
I wish I shared your confidence that Jake will be gone in the summer but I don’t see it. We’ll extend his deal again.
RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - Calgary_Baggie - 10-19-2022
(10-19-2022, 11:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (10-19-2022, 10:13 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I think you've got to think of the division Fat Sam was in Worcs and what was at his disposal, it didn't take him long to bin the likes of Jake, Grant, Phillips etc and bring in Okay, AMN etc
I was no Sam fan and I agree more long term would be a better appointment, Jake is gone in the summer, as is Bartley, maybe now most of us have thought this season is now all about staying up we can think a bit long term. I'm not sure Ron has a clue what he wants personally
Cuzer
I wish I shared your confidence that Jake will be gone in the summer but I don’t see it. We’ll extend his deal again.
Depends where we are as a club.
It would make perfect sense to extend his contract if there was nothing else better on the horizon but depressingly that's where we may find ourselves.
But in terms of a promotion push from this division he is a diabolical player.
RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - Hopalong - 10-20-2022
(10-19-2022, 10:06 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (10-19-2022, 09:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: We have no idea how to win ugly in this division, there ae no leades, nobody giving bollockings to their team mates, no over my dead body defending
All drilled into us by Bruce's casual approach to training, exactly why a Dyche is exactly the manager we need
Many would regard Allardyce as being similar to Dyche and he continues to receive praise from some for having identified the wasters, yet he ended up with the 3rd worst win percentage of all Albion's permanent managers. This suggests that the problem isn't straightforward for anyone to sort out, whether they're very experienced or not. However, as I mentioned earlier, we spent nearly two-thirds of last season in at least a play-off position so, agreeing with Tom's original post, I don't think things are completely without hope.
For me, I'd rather have a manager who wants us to play on the front foot and exploit the creativity of players like Wallace, Diangana, Swift and Rogic. We were good at defending at the start of last season when we had a style of play and a plan, but Bruce decimated all of that and we're currently weakened in the back line because of it. Consequently, playing defensively might not be a great idea and I think we'll have more success if we're seeking to give the opposition something to worry about.
When you think Bruce was a centre half for Man U for years, it's baffling how he couldn't sort our defence and thought three CBs would be enough for the season. The guy is a complete fruitcake.
RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - Remi_Moses - 10-20-2022
(10-20-2022, 12:17 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (10-19-2022, 10:06 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (10-19-2022, 09:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: We have no idea how to win ugly in this division, there ae no leades, nobody giving bollockings to their team mates, no over my dead body defending
All drilled into us by Bruce's casual approach to training, exactly why a Dyche is exactly the manager we need
Many would regard Allardyce as being similar to Dyche and he continues to receive praise from some for having identified the wasters, yet he ended up with the 3rd worst win percentage of all Albion's permanent managers. This suggests that the problem isn't straightforward for anyone to sort out, whether they're very experienced or not. However, as I mentioned earlier, we spent nearly two-thirds of last season in at least a play-off position so, agreeing with Tom's original post, I don't think things are completely without hope.
For me, I'd rather have a manager who wants us to play on the front foot and exploit the creativity of players like Wallace, Diangana, Swift and Rogic. We were good at defending at the start of last season when we had a style of play and a plan, but Bruce decimated all of that and we're currently weakened in the back line because of it. Consequently, playing defensively might not be a great idea and I think we'll have more success if we're seeking to give the opposition something to worry about.
When you think Bruce was a centre half for Man U for years, it's baffling how he couldn't sort our defence and thought three CBs would be enough for the season. The guy is a complete fruitcake.
It has to be Dyche or Bielsa.
No other candidate brings the discipline and organisation needed to improve the whole of the club.
RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - Peachy - 10-20-2022
(10-20-2022, 06:29 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-20-2022, 12:17 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (10-19-2022, 10:06 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (10-19-2022, 09:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: We have no idea how to win ugly in this division, there ae no leades, nobody giving bollockings to their team mates, no over my dead body defending
All drilled into us by Bruce's casual approach to training, exactly why a Dyche is exactly the manager we need
Many would regard Allardyce as being similar to Dyche and he continues to receive praise from some for having identified the wasters, yet he ended up with the 3rd worst win percentage of all Albion's permanent managers. This suggests that the problem isn't straightforward for anyone to sort out, whether they're very experienced or not. However, as I mentioned earlier, we spent nearly two-thirds of last season in at least a play-off position so, agreeing with Tom's original post, I don't think things are completely without hope.
For me, I'd rather have a manager who wants us to play on the front foot and exploit the creativity of players like Wallace, Diangana, Swift and Rogic. We were good at defending at the start of last season when we had a style of play and a plan, but Bruce decimated all of that and we're currently weakened in the back line because of it. Consequently, playing defensively might not be a great idea and I think we'll have more success if we're seeking to give the opposition something to worry about.
When you think Bruce was a centre half for Man U for years, it's baffling how he couldn't sort our defence and thought three CBs would be enough for the season. The guy is a complete fruitcake.
It has to be Dyche or Bielsa.
No other candidate brings the discipline and organisation needed to improve the whole of the club.
Can you imagine Bartley, Kelly and Pieters playing Bielsa's murderball? Not a chance. I love Bielsa but I'm not sure the current make up of the squad lends itself to his style.
Dych would be the best fit but no chance he wants us. I personally wish Roy would come out of retirement for this season with a No2 he can groom for next season. Roy then moves upstairs for the DOF role. Perfect.
RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - Remi_Moses - 10-20-2022
(10-20-2022, 07:13 AM)Peachy Wrote: (10-20-2022, 06:29 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-20-2022, 12:17 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (10-19-2022, 10:06 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (10-19-2022, 09:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: We have no idea how to win ugly in this division, there ae no leades, nobody giving bollockings to their team mates, no over my dead body defending
All drilled into us by Bruce's casual approach to training, exactly why a Dyche is exactly the manager we need
Many would regard Allardyce as being similar to Dyche and he continues to receive praise from some for having identified the wasters, yet he ended up with the 3rd worst win percentage of all Albion's permanent managers. This suggests that the problem isn't straightforward for anyone to sort out, whether they're very experienced or not. However, as I mentioned earlier, we spent nearly two-thirds of last season in at least a play-off position so, agreeing with Tom's original post, I don't think things are completely without hope.
For me, I'd rather have a manager who wants us to play on the front foot and exploit the creativity of players like Wallace, Diangana, Swift and Rogic. We were good at defending at the start of last season when we had a style of play and a plan, but Bruce decimated all of that and we're currently weakened in the back line because of it. Consequently, playing defensively might not be a great idea and I think we'll have more success if we're seeking to give the opposition something to worry about.
When you think Bruce was a centre half for Man U for years, it's baffling how he couldn't sort our defence and thought three CBs would be enough for the season. The guy is a complete fruitcake.
It has to be Dyche or Bielsa.
No other candidate brings the discipline and organisation needed to improve the whole of the club.
Can you imagine Bartley, Kelly and Pieters playing Bielsa's murderball? Not a chance. I love Bielsa but I'm not sure the current make up of the squad lends itself to his style.
Dych would be the best fit but no chance he wants us. I personally wish Roy would come out of retirement for this season with a No2 he can groom for next season. Roy then moves upstairs for the DOF role. Perfect.
Your correct the current squad couldn't cope with the a rigid disciplined tactical game, full of running and pressing. Most of them wouldn't even try and that's exactly why we are in the bottom 3. Lazy unfit players who constantly under perform. We need to be brutally honest here and not just bench players but bin them completely.
RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - Bob Fossil - 10-20-2022
(10-19-2022, 10:13 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I think you've got to think of the division Fat Sam was in Worcs and what was at his disposal, it didn't take him long to bin the likes of Jake, Grant, Phillips etc and bring in Okay, AMN etc
I was no Sam fan and I agree more long term would be a better appointment, Jake is gone in the summer, as is Bartley, maybe now most of us have thought this season is now all about staying up we can think a bit long term. I'm not sure Ron has a clue what he wants personally
Cuzer
I think Ron will reckon his job is done once the new guy puts pen to paper! He'll then skulk back into the silent shadows and will only reappear if it becomes successful, to take the plaudits, if not he'll let the coach fail, until it becomes untenable, then he'll just start all over again, accepting no responsibility whatsoever.
You can probably tell I'm not a fan.
RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - Duffers - 10-20-2022
(10-20-2022, 06:29 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-20-2022, 12:17 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (10-19-2022, 10:06 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (10-19-2022, 09:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: We have no idea how to win ugly in this division, there ae no leades, nobody giving bollockings to their team mates, no over my dead body defending
All drilled into us by Bruce's casual approach to training, exactly why a Dyche is exactly the manager we need
Many would regard Allardyce as being similar to Dyche and he continues to receive praise from some for having identified the wasters, yet he ended up with the 3rd worst win percentage of all Albion's permanent managers. This suggests that the problem isn't straightforward for anyone to sort out, whether they're very experienced or not. However, as I mentioned earlier, we spent nearly two-thirds of last season in at least a play-off position so, agreeing with Tom's original post, I don't think things are completely without hope.
For me, I'd rather have a manager who wants us to play on the front foot and exploit the creativity of players like Wallace, Diangana, Swift and Rogic. We were good at defending at the start of last season when we had a style of play and a plan, but Bruce decimated all of that and we're currently weakened in the back line because of it. Consequently, playing defensively might not be a great idea and I think we'll have more success if we're seeking to give the opposition something to worry about.
When you think Bruce was a centre half for Man U for years, it's baffling how he couldn't sort our defence and thought three CBs would be enough for the season. The guy is a complete fruitcake.
It has to be Dyche or Bielsa.
No other candidate brings the discipline and organisation needed to improve the whole of the club.
To think either Bielsa or Dyche would even entertain the thought is Seal-level delusion.
Bielsa was one of the highest paid managers in the country even when Leeds were in the Championship, I doubt ten quid and Steve’s leftover Greggs vouchers would tempt him.
Dyche is savvy enough to wait it out, the Leicester job will be available soon and he doesn’t need his fingerprints on this train wreck.
RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - Cheshire East Baggie - 10-20-2022
(10-19-2022, 10:13 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I think you've got to think of the division Fat Sam was in Worcs and what was at his disposal, it didn't take him long to bin the likes of Jake, Grant, Phillips etc and bring in Okay, AMN etc
I was no Sam fan and I agree more long term would be a better appointment, Jake is gone in the summer, as is Bartley, maybe now most of us have thought this season is now all about staying up we can think a bit long term. I'm not sure Ron has a clue what he wants personally
Cuzer
Now here's a thought. Just how much is Beale calling the shots? Does he command much respect from the players? Is that why Brunt and Morrison are part of the setup? Those guys were long term team-mates of Phillips and Livermore, and also overlapped with Bartley. I reckon the old lags will be first choice starters until the new coach comes in, then will be head of the queue to bend his ear.
Go on Beale, prove me wrong by dropping Phillips and Livermore - although I'd possibly welcome Bartley back after Tuesday's defensive fiasco.
RE: My thoughts, both barrels. - TETLEY74 - 10-20-2022
(10-20-2022, 07:38 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-20-2022, 07:13 AM)Peachy Wrote: (10-20-2022, 06:29 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-20-2022, 12:17 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (10-19-2022, 10:06 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Many would regard Allardyce as being similar to Dyche and he continues to receive praise from some for having identified the wasters, yet he ended up with the 3rd worst win percentage of all Albion's permanent managers. This suggests that the problem isn't straightforward for anyone to sort out, whether they're very experienced or not. However, as I mentioned earlier, we spent nearly two-thirds of last season in at least a play-off position so, agreeing with Tom's original post, I don't think things are completely without hope.
For me, I'd rather have a manager who wants us to play on the front foot and exploit the creativity of players like Wallace, Diangana, Swift and Rogic. We were good at defending at the start of last season when we had a style of play and a plan, but Bruce decimated all of that and we're currently weakened in the back line because of it. Consequently, playing defensively might not be a great idea and I think we'll have more success if we're seeking to give the opposition something to worry about.
When you think Bruce was a centre half for Man U for years, it's baffling how he couldn't sort our defence and thought three CBs would be enough for the season. The guy is a complete fruitcake.
It has to be Dyche or Bielsa.
No other candidate brings the discipline and organisation needed to improve the whole of the club.
Can you imagine Bartley, Kelly and Pieters playing Bielsa's murderball? Not a chance. I love Bielsa but I'm not sure the current make up of the squad lends itself to his style.
Dych would be the best fit but no chance he wants us. I personally wish Roy would come out of retirement for this season with a No2 he can groom for next season. Roy then moves upstairs for the DOF role. Perfect.
Your correct the current squad couldn't cope with the a rigid disciplined tactical game, full of running and pressing. Most of them wouldn't even try and that's exactly why we are in the bottom 3. Lazy unfit players who constantly under perform. We need to be brutally honest here and not just bench players but bin them completely.
Absolutely spot on.
|