WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=27162)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Ratings - TartanRug - 10-15-2022

BTA although needing to be a bit better on the ball at times never gives the opposition defence a minutes peace, working so hard to close them down I think it helps the rest of the team puts the opposition on edge and makes them make more mistakes. You notice the difference when Grant comes on.


RE: Ratings - Johnnykayeengland - 10-15-2022

(10-15-2022, 05:06 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: Thought Kelly was excellent today. 
Grant “looks interested”? Not from where I was sat, usual pretending to jump for the ball, easily snuffed out for his chance at the end
I really don't know how we tell a player's mindset. Not being able to outjump a 6 foot 5 centre half is hardly a reasonable criticism.

Give him credit for his strengths. Which include putting the ball in the net more than anyone else at the club. 

And I noticed that Grant was the first on to the pitch delighted at Phillips' goal.  An excellent sign of team spirit, which has perhaps been lacking lately. That pleased me almost as much as the goal.


RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 10-16-2022

Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:Thought Kelly was excellent today. 
Grant “looks interested”? Not from where I was sat, usual pretending to jump for the ball, easily snuffed out for his chance at the end
I really don't know how we tell a player's mindset. Not being able to outjump a 6 foot 5 centre half is hardly a reasonable criticism.

Give him credit for his strengths. Which include putting the ball in the net more than anyone else at the club. 

And I noticed that Grant was the first on to the pitch delighted at Phillips' goal.  An excellent sign of team spirit, which has perhaps been lacking lately. That pleased me almost as much as the goal.

I've never bought into the "Grant isn't interested" mantra. He is very limited, but does try and is arguably making the best of what he has. Grant is nowhere near the top of our list of problems.


RE: Ratings - Fido - 10-16-2022

(10-16-2022, 08:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:Thought Kelly was excellent today. 
Grant “looks interested”? Not from where I was sat, usual pretending to jump for the ball, easily snuffed out for his chance at the end
I really don't know how we tell a player's mindset. Not being able to outjump a 6 foot 5 centre half is hardly a reasonable criticism.

Give him credit for his strengths. Which include putting the ball in the net more than anyone else at the club. 

And I noticed that Grant was the first on to the pitch delighted at Phillips' goal.  An excellent sign of team spirit, which has perhaps been lacking lately. That pleased me almost as much as the goal.

I've never bought into the "Grant isn't interested" mantra. He is very limited, but does try and is arguably making the best of what he has. Grant is nowhere near the top of our list of problems.

Could not disagree more, Tom.


RE: Ratings - Cuzer - 10-16-2022

(10-15-2022, 06:02 PM)Fido Wrote:
(10-15-2022, 05:57 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: 6 for Kelly harsh. I thought he was excellent

+1

(10-15-2022, 05:52 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: My onions.

Really chuffed for Palmer. A few dodgy moments in the first half were forgotten after the half dozen saves he made later. I'm convinced at least one would have beaten Button.

Defenders defended.

If anyone ever suggests TGH's best position is wide right or RB, they will get serious shoe. Great work rate, great tenacity, great goal. Must be a wonderful feeling to score for the team you support.

I thought our overall performance wasn't that great tbh. First 15 were certainly better than what we've been used to, but it was no better than we've seen this season. In fact, possibly the first game where we've had fewer shots than the opposition.

No matter, delighted with 3 points and looking forward to next match.

Is roysh re TGH. Couldn’t believe one of the central midfielders wasn’t hooked for him v Luton.

Didn’t even make the bench did he?

Cuzer


RE: Ratings - Cheshire East Baggie - 10-16-2022

(10-16-2022, 09:06 AM)Fido Wrote:
(10-16-2022, 08:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:Thought Kelly was excellent today. 
Grant “looks interested”? Not from where I was sat, usual pretending to jump for the ball, easily snuffed out for his chance at the end
I really don't know how we tell a player's mindset. Not being able to outjump a 6 foot 5 centre half is hardly a reasonable criticism.

Give him credit for his strengths. Which include putting the ball in the net more than anyone else at the club. 

And I noticed that Grant was the first on to the pitch delighted at Phillips' goal.  An excellent sign of team spirit, which has perhaps been lacking lately. That pleased me almost as much as the goal.

I've never bought into the "Grant isn't interested" mantra. He is very limited, but does try and is arguably making the best of what he has. Grant is nowhere near the top of our list of problems.

Could not disagree more, Tom.

I find it completely feckin' remarkable that with the club poised on the brink of the abyss for multiple reasons, some posters keep on banging the drum about their personal prejudices against individual players. It's very rare for one player to make "the difference" to a team's overall performance. One thing you can say about Grant is that he's scored the goals for us while nobody much else was doing. If Beale and/or the new manager thinks he has nothing to offer, he'll drop out of the squad. Otherwise, why assassinate him every week, even when we've had that rare thing, a win?


RE: Ratings - Psalm23 - 10-16-2022

The only real thing I see wrong with Grant, is the amount of money some fucking idiot paid for him, if we'd paid about £3-4 million for him, he wouldn't look bad value for money.
Having said that, compared to the amount spunked on Kenneth fucking Zohore, Grant actually looks value for money.   Rolleyes


RE: Ratings - Fido - 10-16-2022

(10-16-2022, 09:35 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(10-16-2022, 09:06 AM)Fido Wrote:
(10-16-2022, 08:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:Thought Kelly was excellent today. 
Grant “looks interested”? Not from where I was sat, usual pretending to jump for the ball, easily snuffed out for his chance at the end
I really don't know how we tell a player's mindset. Not being able to outjump a 6 foot 5 centre half is hardly a reasonable criticism.

Give him credit for his strengths. Which include putting the ball in the net more than anyone else at the club. 

And I noticed that Grant was the first on to the pitch delighted at Phillips' goal.  An excellent sign of team spirit, which has perhaps been lacking lately. That pleased me almost as much as the goal.

I've never bought into the "Grant isn't interested" mantra. He is very limited, but does try and is arguably making the best of what he has. Grant is nowhere near the top of our list of problems.

Could not disagree more, Tom.

I find it completely feckin' remarkable that with the club poised on the brink of the abyss for multiple reasons, some posters keep on banging the drum about their personal prejudices against individual players. It's very rare for one player to make "the difference" to a team's overall performance. One thing you can say about Grant is that he's scored the goals for us while nobody much else was doing. If Beale and/or the new manager thinks he has nothing to offer, he'll drop out of the squad. Otherwise, why assassinate him every week, even when we've had that rare thing, a win?

A prejudice comes from a state whereby a decision is made prior to something happening. I did hope that by not starting Grant when he came on he might close down defenders and put the back line under pressure by winning the ball higher up the pitch as BTA tried to do while he was on. He didn’t and that’s why I posted what I did.


RE: Ratings - Bilic's Beard - 10-16-2022

My thoughts on yesterday's individual performances are Palmer show great reflexes and growing in confidence ,Pieters Kelly Oshea very good keeping the airiel threat I thought might be a problem to a minimum. Phillips Townsend best games for a long time and Jake had a steady game as for TGH ,mom for me showing what he e showed in the few appearances he played there last season .Jed always a threat and BTA worked hard and the goals will come for him soon ,as for Grady ,opposition again trying to kick him AOTS but showing he's back and always likely to produce some magic to win games .No complaints with the subs of Clearly n Grant but thought both Yok n Molumby were off the pace but with 15 mins to go it must be difficult to pick the pace of the up .Overall a very good win I didn't expect and the players seemed to have played with the weight off the shoulders .


RE: Ratings - Woodman scoreboard - 10-16-2022

I thought yok didn't do to bad broke the play up gave away some silly tackles but it give the midfield and defence to reset I really think nobody was under a 7