![]() |
|
Here you go Proth - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Here you go Proth (/showthread.php?tid=26993) |
RE: Here you go Proth - Borin' Baggie - 10-07-2022 (10-07-2022, 03:27 PM)Ossian Wrote: It's time for a fundamental reset; one which would require a political leadership sufficiently focussed not to be deflected by a sneering print media. It's a shame that the Lib Dem conference was cancelled due to the Queen's funeral. The major platforms were about social care reform and planning/house building. Might have pressured Labour into talking about it at their conference. RE: Here you go Proth - Protheroe - 10-07-2022 (10-07-2022, 03:09 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(10-07-2022, 03:00 PM)baggy1 Wrote:(10-07-2022, 02:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: That's a very sad story and one replicated thousands of times up and down the country. I will and it is. The difference however, is that social insurance separated from the State can't be cancelled or vired by a government for political purposes - and is exactly why we should fund healthcare in the same manner. When people see they are paying directly for this they'll become more demanding, and providers (public, private & third) will become more responsive. All far far preferable to the continual short term politicisation of health and social care, or Baggy1's ludicrous trickle-up approach ensuring that the poorest taxpayers subsidise my children's inheritance (truly barmy and immoral imo). RE: Here you go Proth - baggy1 - 10-07-2022 Barmy and immoral from someone who didn't read the post - you'll have to explain where i mentioned taking money out of the poorest pockets. Trickle down has proven to be a car crash policy and unworkable and I only talked about corporation tax, you seem to have got confused when I tried to explain why getting people to pay for healthcare with their houses is a one off tax and can't be repeated - when it's gone it's gone, what do you do then? You need to take that 'what you will do then' and bring it forward. RE: Here you go Proth - Borin' Baggie - 10-07-2022 I'm more realistic, it's a measure to hide the true level of tax people are paying a la student loan repayments being functionally a graduate tax but not a graduate tax so people on £30k a year don't realise they have a higher marginal rate than someone on £125k a year. Also, I think you'll find in Germany, and actually every country with a Bismarck system that I've looked at, that healthcare is funded out of general taxation as the statutory contribution and private providers don't cover the operation of healthcare. It's all an accounting trick. The state funding too much healthcare was literally a campaign issue of the FDP (Lib Dems sister party) two elections ago to fund the policy of bringing income tax down. The statistics are out there already, the UK doesn't fund health and social care to anywhere near the degree that it should as a percentage of GDP. That's the root cause of why it's shit, and unfortunately people don't give a shit so why would they magically care if they paid via statutory contributions? Need I remind you that one of the reasons the Beveridge model came into being was because of politicisation of healthcare funding when we had a statutory contribution system pre WW2? Meaning there were huge gaps in the provision of care? Why would things suddenly be different this time around? RE: Here you go Proth - Protheroe - 10-07-2022 How often do I have to spell it out? If you use taxpayers money to underwrite the inheritance of better off families' kids you are inevitably picking the pockets of poorer / asset poor taxpayers. It's fucking outrageous coming from a Socialist that. RE: Here you go Proth - baggy1 - 10-07-2022 You probably need to shoehorn something about benefits recipients into that fabrication of a line. Do you think that the bloke in the OP should sell his house in his late 60s to pay for his wife's care? RE: Here you go Proth - Protheroe - 10-07-2022 (10-07-2022, 03:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: unfortunately people don't give a shit People don't give a shit because, by and large, they think the NHS is "Free". Moving to a social insurance-led system will mean many people will pay more. But at least they will see what they are paying for, and the value they receive (or not) from their chosen provider - which of course need not be the NHS. RE: Here you go Proth - Ossian - 10-07-2022 (10-07-2022, 03:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(10-07-2022, 03:27 PM)Ossian Wrote: We need to build homes - 200,000 a year, year on year (like the Attlee government did) providing employment in the process. Again, our young workforce needs to be skilled up to benefit from the opportunity to work and then afford these homes. Add in roads, railways, infrastructure in all of its many guises... No, not right now I can't - that's the point. It's a medium/long-term programme and we might have to accept that some of the labour in the early years is provided by migrants, as it has been in the past. And I'm not revisiting Brexit - that ship has sailed. Or we could kick multiple cans down the road for a few more years then revisit the same conversations again. RE: Here you go Proth - Protheroe - 10-07-2022 (10-07-2022, 03:53 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You probably need to shoehorn something about benefits recipients into that fabrication of a line. Do you think that the bloke in the OP should sell his house in his late 60s to pay for his wife's care? I don't see why a young person on a modest income, paying a higher marginal tax rate due to a student loan, renting an expensive poky 1-bed flat and unable in the medium term to even contemplate buying a home ought to subsidise Jo and her husband if they have wholly unearned slug of equity in their property. That is the very definition of trickle-up economics. Taking from the asset poor to subsidise the asset rich. Just as Gordon Brown did in 2008. At least you Labour lot are consistent in your contempt for the low paid / asset poor. RE: Here you go Proth - Borin' Baggie - 10-07-2022 (10-07-2022, 03:57 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(10-07-2022, 03:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: unfortunately people don't give a shit Standard Proth, read what he wants and ignore the point. How do you square your assertion that people don't give a shit in Germany and didn't give a shit pre-WW2 in the UK? If your argument made sense that wouldn't the case, would it? |