WBAUnofficial
Rupa Huq MP - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Rupa Huq MP (/showthread.php?tid=26802)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Rupa Huq MP - Ournextstriker - 09-27-2022

(09-27-2022, 02:54 PM)Ossian Wrote:
(09-27-2022, 02:51 PM)Ournextstriker Wrote: Do you think this will be enough to deflect from Kwasi's economic incompetance?

No, but why concede such a soft own goal at any time, but particularly this week?

Edit: Particularly bearing mind the Tories' never-ending propensity for thin-skinned righteous indignation.

oh yeah, i forgot how sensitive they are


RE: Rupa Huq MP - CaptainFantastico - 09-27-2022

She basically said, in much cruder terms, what a lot of people would have already alluded to in interviews that i've seen with him. Idiotic comment and she has rightly been suspended. Good to see a leader who leads decisively and deals with the kind of stuff that crops up from time to time and needs such action.

(09-27-2022, 02:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Essentially calls Kwasi Kwarteng "a coconut".

I can't fathom what possesses these people to articulate their rancid beliefs when they should know far better.

https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/rupa-huq-kwasi-kwarteng-superficially-black_uk_6332eaa3e4b0281645228da0

Tomorrow I expect Wes Streeting will accuse Gary Sambrook of being "superficially gay".

From the party that wouldn't elect Rishi because....ermmmm....Liz Truss is so appealing....


RE: Rupa Huq MP - Protheroe - 09-27-2022

(09-27-2022, 02:47 PM)Sliced Wrote: Looks like she’s been suspended.

That’s the problem with identity politics. You get yourself tangled in a mess. She said “Just because someone is black doesn’t make them progressive” after basically saying Kwasi “isn’t really black because he isn’t progressive”.

Precisely.


RE: Rupa Huq MP - Spandaubaggie - 09-27-2022

Identity politics is the utter scourge of modern life. People can be many things, but when they lose perspective of every other facet of their identity in favour of one overarching label that dominates their thoughts they create terrible division.
It's particularly rife with race. As I've said before a black kid from the ghetto and a white kid from the ghetto have far more in common than the black kid does with a fellow black person who is born into privilege, like Kwarteng.
I suppose Huq thought Kwarteng has to turn up to the commons wearing a tracksuit and blasting out Fight the Power to fit into her stereotype of what he should be.


RE: Rupa Huq MP - CaptainFantastico - 09-27-2022

(09-27-2022, 07:50 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Identity politics is the utter scourge of modern life. People can be many things, but when they lose perspective of every other facet of their identity in favour of one overarching label that dominates their thoughts they create terrible division.
It's particularly rife with race. As I've said before a black kid from the ghetto and a white kid from the ghetto have far more in common than the black kid does with a fellow black person who is born into privilege, like Kwarteng.
I suppose Huq thought Kwarteng has to turn up to the commons wearing a tracksuit and blasting out Fight the Power to fit into her stereotype of what he should be.

Always a lot of time for your views but I don’t think that’s remotely where it was coming from. I watched an interview with Kwarteng only a week or so ago where a black man who lived in what was clearly a working class part of London said more or less the same thing directly to Kwarteng. The difference was, understandably to some degree, was that saying it as a black man to a black man is seen as far less contentious. I don’t for one minute think he was referring to clothing or the like.


RE: Rupa Huq MP - Spandaubaggie - 09-27-2022

(09-27-2022, 08:09 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(09-27-2022, 07:50 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Identity politics is the utter scourge of modern life. People can be many things, but when they lose perspective of every other facet of their identity in favour of one overarching label that dominates their thoughts they create terrible division.
It's particularly rife with race. As I've said before a black kid from the ghetto and a white kid from the ghetto have far more in common than the black kid does with a fellow black person who is born into privilege, like Kwarteng.
I suppose Huq thought Kwarteng has to turn up to the commons wearing a tracksuit and blasting out Fight the Power to fit into her stereotype of what he should be.

Always a lot of time for your views but I don’t think that’s remotely where it was coming from. I watched an interview with Kwarteng only a week or so ago where a black man who lived in what was clearly a working class part of London said more or less the same thing directly to Kwarteng. The difference was, understandably to some degree, was that saying it as a black man to a black man is seen as far less contentious. I don’t for one minute think he was referring to clothing or the like.
See your point chap, and my tracksuit quip is purely jokingly reinforcing the fact that crude general labels especially around race and gender ostracises those who don't act the way they are supposed to.

I've just read her comments as I wasn''t completely au fait with the tale..

It's touchy times we live in but I think suspending someone for this is OTT. It's ignorant what she said, but if it opens a more deep and meaningful conversation on race then that's a good thing.


RE: Rupa Huq MP - CaptainFantastico - 09-27-2022

(09-27-2022, 08:17 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-27-2022, 08:09 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(09-27-2022, 07:50 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Identity politics is the utter scourge of modern life. People can be many things, but when they lose perspective of every other facet of their identity in favour of one overarching label that dominates their thoughts they create terrible division.
It's particularly rife with race. As I've said before a black kid from the ghetto and a white kid from the ghetto have far more in common than the black kid does with a fellow black person who is born into privilege, like Kwarteng.
I suppose Huq thought Kwarteng has to turn up to the commons wearing a tracksuit and blasting out Fight the Power to fit into her stereotype of what he should be.

Always a lot of time for your views but I don’t think that’s remotely where it was coming from. I watched an interview with Kwarteng only a week or so ago where a black man who lived in what was clearly a working class part of London said more or less the same thing directly to Kwarteng. The difference was, understandably to some degree, was that saying it as a black man to a black man is seen as far less contentious. I don’t for one minute think he was referring to clothing or the like.
See your point chap, and my tracksuit quip is purely jokingly reinforcing the fact that crude general labels especially around race and gender ostracises those who don't act the way they are supposed to.

It's touchy times we live in but I think suspending someone for this is OTT. It's ignorant what she said, but if it opens a more deep and meaningful conversation on race then that's a good thing.

Thing is regardless of her intentions, if you are going to say something in that sphere you better make damn sure you aren’t lazy with your language. It’s no surprise that with the legacy of Corbyn in his own party and Johnson having all the grip on this kind of thing of a wet sponge, Starmer knows it’s essential to act fast and set boundaries. In the last few months he’s gone from a bit wishy washy to someone I think the public are starting to believe is a PM in waiting. Someone has definitely also done a far better job of managing how perception is projected and received. He won’t risk that now.


RE: Rupa Huq MP - Fido - 09-28-2022

This is the lass from Blue Peter, right?


RE: Rupa Huq MP - Ted Maul - 09-28-2022

(09-28-2022, 07:29 AM)Fido Wrote: This is the lass from Blue Peter, right?

Nope, it's her sister.


RE: Rupa Huq MP - rsbaggy2 - 09-28-2022

(09-27-2022, 02:51 PM)Ournextstriker Wrote: Do you think this will be enough to deflect from Kwasi's economic incompetance?

And his disgraceful actions at the Queen's funeral?