WBAUnofficial
Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad (/showthread.php?tid=26643)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad - Spandaubaggie - 09-15-2022

(09-15-2022, 03:34 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Alan Miller in my top 3 without a doubt    rip
Had forgot Miller- a fine keeper certainly in the top 6.


RE: Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad - Birdman1811 - 09-15-2022

Johnstone was a better shot stopper than Foster or Hoult, in every other metric he falls behind though.

Ultimately, all far better than Button, Palmer deserves a go.


RE: Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad - MancBaggie - 09-15-2022

Top 6 in my watching lifetime (first game 1986)

Foster
Hoult
Kirkland
PIG
Miller
Naylor


RE: Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad - Birdman1811 - 09-15-2022

For me

Foster
Hoult
Johnstone
Miller
Kirkland
PiG

The final 4 is pretty much interchangable.


RE: Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad - rsbaggy2 - 09-15-2022

Foster announces retirement ... scrub any potential move there


RE: Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad - Tom Joad - 09-15-2022

Spandaubaggie Wrote:I think as someone who has supported the club 47 years I've seen a good few and being honest our recent 21st century history has given the best 3. Foster, Hoult and Johnstone in that order.

Guys like Godden, Osborne, Naylor and Kiely were all worthy custodians of the shirt.

However, we have had some gash too. Crichton was appalling and what was it with Zuberhowler and his pedigree?

Trying not to get too downbeat but we now have one of the most uninspiring keepers in many moons. Button just isn't going to make those once every couple of matches saves that wins you points. 

I think his inclusion is a major reason why we are shipping in soft goals. I maintain Sam Johnstone in normal form would have meant we'd be 3-4 points better off already.

We've overlooked this vital position criminally for this season and its neglect is a major reason we are in a pickle.
Godden wasn't that good. In fact Shankly said we would have won the league that year (78-9) if we'd had a better keeper.
Osborne was a firm favourite but hand on heart, I can't remember if he was any good as I was only a kid.
Foster, best by a country mile.
Hoult.
Miller.
Johnston. (Although he didn't excel until we we made it to the Prem).
PIG.
Not fair to single out the bad ones but I guess I agree with those mentioned.


RE: Goalkeepers and the Albion- some good some v bad - Baggie in Valley - 09-16-2022

(09-15-2022, 03:37 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 03:34 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Alan Miller in my top 3 without a doubt    rip

I would rate him third behind Hoult - purely because of Hoult's clean sheet record. I would definitely rate him higher than Johnstone. 

I would put Naylor and Johnstone level. Not bad keepers, good reactions, but neither commanded their area/defence well, and both had a mistake in them.

Johnstone is much much better than Naylor ever was.