![]() |
|
Understudies - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Understudies (/showthread.php?tid=26259) |
RE: Understudies - halasbaggie - 08-24-2022 Agree, we are paying for the incompetence of our former head of recruitment. We have to ship players out before we make new signings RE: Understudies - Bob Fossil - 08-24-2022 We need a run without Livermore in the starting 11, he is too slow and cumbersome, he just saps our creativity. Now we have Yokuslu, this should be a given. As for Bartley and Phillips, we are stuck with them simply because we gave them silly contracts and no-one else wants them, that shouldn't mean we have to play them though. We need to suck it up and only consider them in a real emergency. Reach is the only one that should really be involved but, even then, it should be as a sub and only when the circumstances are right. Not coming on when we are trying to win a game like Cardiff. Furlong and Townsend are still suspect and need competition, at the very least, if not replacing completely. Other than that, we have the bones of a decent starting 11, but are desperate for a striker or 2. I think we'll get them, whether they'll be any good time will tell. Strength in depth, however, is not going to be our thing this season, so we are going to need our share of luck with injuries / suspensions. RE: Understudies - Shabby Russian - 08-24-2022 Whilst I don't particularly disagree with anything in the op, it is easier for a younger player to be introduced into the first 11 surrounded by first team players, rather than in a team comprised of other youngsters and bench warmers. That said, over the last decade we seem to have a growing number of very promising 16 to 17 year old, whose careers stall when they get their first professional contract. Probably the same at every club, but seems to happen a lot with us. We neither seem to get players who become first team regulars or cash in with big transfer fees received. Data OShea and Saido Berahino being the exceptions. RE: Understudies - WorcsWBA - 08-24-2022 I didn't see the game, but the main thrust of this thread seems to be that our young players aren't good enough to play against Derby Reserves, given that Derby made 7 changes themselves (thanks for confirming Lightnin)? If so, it doesn't bode very well really. RE: Understudies - Sliced - 08-24-2022 (08-24-2022, 09:09 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: I didn't see the game, but the main thrust of this thread seems to be that our young players aren't good enough to play against Derby Reserves, given that Derby made 7 changes themselves (thanks for confirming Lightnin)? If so, it doesn't bode very well really. I would say we were second best but the youngsters (for the most part) were no worse than the senior players that played. RE: Understudies - SW4Baggie - 08-24-2022 (08-24-2022, 09:09 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: I didn't see the game, but the main thrust of this thread seems to be that our young players aren't good enough to play against Derby Reserves, given that Derby made 7 changes themselves (thanks for confirming Lightnin)? If so, it doesn't bode very well really. I think SR has nailed it on the post above. We had too many kids in the team and the senior heads were either not good enough, not motivated enough or both to carry them through. RE: Understudies - Dumbo - 08-24-2022 Yep. Feel somewhat sorry for Cleary. When Matt Phillips, Jake Livermore and Adam Reach are your supply line, it’s going to be a tough night. Would he have done any better with Wallace, Swift and Grady supplying him? Most definitely. That said, he’s still raw and ultimately not ready. Bartley, Phillips and Livermore were pathetic last night. Jake just can’t do it anymore. Bartley just ins t interested and Matt Phillips must have won a dressing room competition to have earned that new contract. RE: Understudies - wbamitch - 08-24-2022 I didn’t watch the game but I find it strange that 1 poor game from TGH and he’s branded not good enough, yet Furlong/Livermore/Phillis/Reach and whoever else can have multiple bad games in a row and continue to get picked. I don’t think anybody thinks he’s perfect, but he’s shown he is good enough to play a part in multiple positions at championship level, and all I expect is if those ahead of him don’t perform that they get dropped. RE: Understudies - RonnieWallwork - 08-24-2022 (08-24-2022, 08:29 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Whilst I don't particularly disagree with anything in the op, it is easier for a younger player to be introduced into the first 11 surrounded by first team players, rather than in a team comprised of other youngsters and bench warmers. (08-24-2022, 09:30 AM)wbamitch Wrote: I didn’t watch the game but I find it strange that 1 poor game from TGH and he’s branded not good enough, yet Furlong/Livermore/Phillis/Reach and whoever else can have multiple bad games in a row and continue to get picked. I don’t think anybody thinks he’s perfect, but he’s shown he is good enough to play a part in multiple positions at championship level, and all I expect is if those ahead of him don’t perform that they get dropped. Haven’t said not good enough but clearly not up to the standard yet consistently to push Furlong out. RE: Understudies - SW4Baggie - 08-24-2022 (08-24-2022, 09:46 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:(08-24-2022, 08:29 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Whilst I don't particularly disagree with anything in the op, it is easier for a younger player to be introduced into the first 11 surrounded by first team players, rather than in a team comprised of other youngsters and bench warmers. Bit harsh to judge Cleary at right back Ron |