WBAUnofficial
Player Marks - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Player Marks (/showthread.php?tid=26016)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Player Marks - Cornflake - 08-09-2022

Harsh on Button and Livermore imo. Give them an extra point each.


RE: Player Marks - wbamitch - 08-09-2022

You can’t blame him directly for the goal but it’s another example of why he shouldn’t be in the team, there was no need to boot the ball into the sky. Yokuslu shown in the first 2 minutes why he’s head and shoulders above him, took a difficult ball down, flicked it over someone and kept possession. No contest.

Jakes a good option to have to bring on towards the end of a game we’re winning in but that’s about it for me.


RE: Player Marks - Moore Than - 08-09-2022

Button 6 - solid, easy pen save.
Furlong 8 - still prone to abandoning defence but didn't cost us today.
Townsend 7 - point off for almost undoing our performance with the penalty incident.
Ajayi 8 - star man at the back despite half a point off for giving the penalty away.
DOS 8 - solid and uncompromising.
Livermore 6 - he's slowly declining. We've been complaining about him for years and here he is, still getting selected (mainly because our recruitment in this area has been so poor), still looking slow and making mistakes.
Molumby 8 - never really convinced me but much much better from him last night.
Swift 7 - didn't notice him much at all. Top 6, low 7.
Diangana 8 - excellent on the ball, superb pass. He feeds on confidence and he's heading in the right direction again at last.
Wallace 9 - superb first half, much quieter second but I love the variety of his crosses. He tries something different almost every time. Probably the most intelligent player I've seen for a long time.
Grant 7 - point off for missing so many chances but his hold up play was something I've not seen from him before. If we get a proper #9, he's not in my starting XI though.

A word on Yukuslu. There are some players that are smooth, like Rolls Royces. He's one of them. You can almost hear him purring when he's playing!


RE: Player Marks - Ted Maul - 08-09-2022

(08-09-2022, 08:14 AM)Moore Than Wrote: Button 6 - solid, easy pen save.
Furlong 8 - still prone to abandoning defence but didn't cost us today.
Townsend 7 - point off for almost undoing our performance with the penalty incident.
Ajayi 8 - star man at the back despite half a point off for giving the penalty away.
DOS 8 - solid and uncompromising.
Livermore 6 - he's slowly declining. We've been complaining about him for years and here he is, still getting selected (mainly because our recruitment in this area has been so poor), still looking slow and making mistakes.
Molumby 8 - never really convinced me but much much better from him last night.
Swift 7 - didn't notice him much at all. Top 6, low 7.
Diangana 8 - excellent on the ball, superb pass. He feeds on confidence and he's heading in the right direction again at last.
Wallace 9 - superb first half, much quieter second but I love the variety of his crosses. He tries something different almost every time. Probably the most intelligent player I've seen for a long time.
Grant 7 - point off for missing so many chances but his hold up play was something I've not seen from him before. If we get a proper #9, he's not in my starting XI though.

A word on Yukuslu. There are some players that are smooth, like Rolls Royces. He's one of them. You can almost hear him purring when he's playing!

That's a big call especially whilst Diangana is still trying to rediscover his best form. a #9 and Grant plays wide left where he is most effective. The option to rotate Diangana, Grant, Wallace in this league is great depth.


RE: Player Marks - Moore Than - 08-09-2022

I don't think Grant has been particularly effective there. He scored a few for us last season but he had to. Robinson is shot shy and Zohore a waste of space. I thought one reason we looked so good last night was because we had Diangana on the left giving us better balance.

We don't have that with Grant when he's there. He can't beat a player and instead looks to come in.


RE: Player Marks - Cuzer - 08-09-2022

(08-09-2022, 06:31 AM)aj21 Wrote: Was Livermore really at fault for the goal? It wasn’t great play from him but sometimes a goal is no one’s fault. He’s scored an absolute worldie,

If he doesn't give it away aimlessly Sarr doesn't have the ball, maybe harsh to blame him categorically but his sloppiiness played a part, whch I was alluding too

Cuzer


RE: Player Marks - SW4Baggie - 08-09-2022

I am "struggling" with some of the high marks being awarded for last night. I felt we played some really good football last night and I was impressed with how well coached we looked. We haven't looked as organized or played with such a clear identity and game-plan since the early days of Val. For me it was our most enjoyable performance since we shredded Sheff United 4-0 about a year ago.

But, despite an excellent performance, we didn't win the game, and we were only a crap penalty away from losing it. We simply didn't take our chances last night, we didn't make the most of set pieces (to have double figures of corners and not draw a save out of their 'keeper needs improvement).

Button 7 - Caught for their goal but his positiioning wasn't too far wrong - made up for it with the penalty save, and other than one smart stop had nothing to do.

Furlong 7 - Better than his usual performances, long throw pleasing to see again but another that had a couple of opportunities that needed better composure
Ajayi - 7.5 - Got away with a lot of unorthodox defending but got punished for the penalty. He always seems to be wrong side of his man and reliant on his pace/strength to cover for mistakes in the basics and ultimately got caught for the pen. Loses marks for having a weird shaped head, several chances in Watford's box which he needed to work the keeper with.
O'Shea - 8 - Very good again, wish he could get his head on some of the chances Ajayi spurned.
Townsend - 7 - Too many touches and dribbling into nowhere. Defended OK, but got caught and turned by a tricky forward line. Think Bruce pushed him and Furlong further forward than at Boro and he struggled with the balance IMO.

Livermore - 6 - Weakest performer on the night. Hoping Okay comes in for Blackburn, he's been a decent servant but his balls out from midfield are poor and arguably put us under pressure for the goal.
Molumby - 7 - Wish he had as much brains as he has energy. He just doesn't stop running but his positioning is sketchy for me, I thought he was out of position for the Sarr goal and he played a couple of high-risk balls across the midfield that led to Watford's best breaks following cheap tutnovers. There's certainly a player in him, just needs to get his head up more.

Diangana - 8 - What a transformation getting this lad back out on the left... Lovely ball for the goal and his confidence is returning.
Swift - 7.5 - Mades everything tick but really ought to have given us a dream start. Felt he faded moreso than most in the second half
Wallace - 9 * - What a player this lad is. Didn't realise he was THIS good, and has more pace than expected. Looks an absolute gem, we just need someone bigger and more clinical in the box.

Grant - 8 - Fantastic goal, refreshing to see him control it, beat his man and finish so clinically. Thought his all round play was better tonight but still lacks that finisher's instinct. Worked hard, capable of great goals, but I think plenty of teams in the division have a striker that would have converted a couple more of his chances last night and that's a problem.

---
Reach - 4 - Came on, mucked up a couple attacks, and fell on his arse. Poor, and we have far better options.
Yokuslu - Some classy touches when he came on. Really looking forward to seeing him start next week!!
Phillips - One block, one cross

Bruce - 9 - More of this Steve!!!!!!!


RE: Player Marks - Moore Than - 08-09-2022

Good point on Ajayi. He should be winning everything in the air on long throws or corners but he's awful at getting his head on the ball


RE: Player Marks - Fido - 08-09-2022

(08-09-2022, 09:04 AM)Moore Than Wrote: Good point on Ajayi. He should be winning everything in the air on long throws or corners but he's awful at getting his head on the ball

Agree to a certain extent but we have been spoilt with having McAuley and Dawson in recent years, two of the most attacking threats from corners in the top leagues.


RE: Player Marks - Hopalong - 08-09-2022

(08-08-2022, 11:17 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Not too much to add to what’s been already said on the performance which was excellent from start to finish

Such a shame re Dike as we need that different type of striker as our delivery into the box was generally excellent tonight from both flanks. Really surprised to hear Bruce say he wasn’t looking for a striker before Dikes injury as surely we needed another option? 

Button 7 Must take a big portion of the blame for their goal, made up for it with the penalty save

Furlong 8 As good as he’s been for a long time, excellent delivery, a threat in the box and dangerous throw ins, much more like it

Townsend 8 Not as dynamic as DF but not far behind, always getting forward mixed delivery but a lot more like he was when at best, unlucky with penalty challenge running into Watford players path

O’Shea  8 Excellent no nonsense defending as come to expect, a threat in their box too, looking more comfortable on the left side now

Semi 9 Rolls Royce of a performance, great passing too from the back, his pace is such an asset and solid in the air all night

Livermore 6 At fault for their goal when aimlessly cleared the ball, always works hard and puts in a shift but now looking like a player 2 yards slower than his team mates, surely Okay to start their sooner rather than later

Molumby 8 Great engine and endeavor all over the pitch, also his distribution has improved, growing on me with every game and 900k given his age looks a potential steal

Swift 7 Ironically thought he struggled a bit tonight, was often wasteful but can clearly see the quality is there, another one that should have scored

Wallace 9*. What a player we have on our hands here, especially in this system so direct, always a threat and linked superbly with Furlong, great crosser of the ball and works tirelessly without it, pray to god he stays fit

Grady 8  Direct and always a threat, I’ve banged on for over a year he could play in the hole, his weight of pass is so under rated  and that showed for our goal, beautiful vision. Good to see him back to the Grady we all want to see, let’s hope the hamstring was just tightness

Grant 8 We’ll documented he’s got to do more for me out of the 18 yard box but credit to him tonight,  thought his movement and work rate was impressive, his hold up play was improved and yes he missed 3-4 borderline sitters but I’d rather have my striker missing them than not getting in the positions. Shown tonight he can play that loan striker role with intelligent players behind him

Subs

Okay 7 Slipped in seamlessly when he came on, an hour on Thursday and start Sunday for me

Phillips 6 Little impact and seems to be the next cab off the rank at RB ahead of TGH

Reach 5 Came on, cocked up 2 crossing opportunities and fell over

Hope we can be this positive away from home Sunday, what we all want to see

Cuzer

Is Swift carrying an injury?  Not at the races last night but you could see his class with one or two passes our other players are incapable of.  

Thought Furlong was excellent.  I'm sure he's been told no more horror performances like Boro or you're out.