RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - throstle - 08-05-2022
Absolutely they are asking the right questions not just about all the loans, but also about the introduction of a new holding company based in Jersey, where transparency and accountability will be much harder.
RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - Baggybenny - 08-05-2022
KRO might be able to offer some advice.
RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - Tom Joad - 08-05-2022
Another thing S4A are drawing attention to is The Hawthorns. Selling the ground is generally the beginning of a long, dark period for any club that tries it. Making it known widely that supporters do not approve will hopefully pre-empt anything happening beyond the public eye.
RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - Kit Kat Chunky - 08-05-2022
I had the opportunity to join S4A when I was a shareholder but decided against it. They have always had an agenda against whoever was running the club. They are a throwback to our former constitution where a few people had a lot of power for investing very little.
They are asking the correct questions of the present regime, but the reality is they have been toothless since JRP had majority control, and that isn't going to change. By actually forcing the issue on the inter-company loan, they are going to cost the club income by forcing a dividend to be declared
RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - Fulham Fallout - 08-05-2022
(08-05-2022, 01:32 PM)SophLad Wrote: Anyone provide me with a 3 line summary?
The club lent one of Lai’s companies £5m
Lai will declare a dividend to repay the said £5m
Lai will repay the loan using the money from the
said dividend and wba will be
£5m shorter in the bank at the end of the day
How’s that Soph? Hope you managed to grasp that as most Albion fans seem to struggle with it. Along with getting in to their new XXXL replica top
RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - Malcolm Tucker - 08-05-2022
(08-05-2022, 03:27 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: A couple of things spring to mind from a quick skim :-
1. Why aren't S4A asking who made the decision to make the loan? It's hardly a case of Directors acting in accordance with their Fiduciary Duty if the monies are being lent to a company in financial distress?
2. The Jersey Holding Company looks like a move to bring the ownership vehicle nearer the UK. The individuals named are likely to be Corporate Trustees, and have nothing to do with any takeover - or otherwise.
3. For all the whinging of S4A (and that's what it is) they represent Minority Shareholders, who in the main would have dearly loved to have been paid out at the same rate as JRP. The Company beleive it is complying with Company Law, and the reality is there is very little they can do about it.
“We are keen to establish which directors acted in March 2021 to facilitate and approve the loan of £4.95m Loan from Group to Wisdom Smart Corporation Ltd”
RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - Kit Kat Chunky - 08-05-2022
(08-05-2022, 07:45 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: (08-05-2022, 03:27 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: A couple of things spring to mind from a quick skim :-
1. Why aren't S4A asking who made the decision to make the loan? It's hardly a case of Directors acting in accordance with their Fiduciary Duty if the monies are being lent to a company in financial distress?
2. The Jersey Holding Company looks like a move to bring the ownership vehicle nearer the UK. The individuals named are likely to be Corporate Trustees, and have nothing to do with any takeover - or otherwise.
3. For all the whinging of S4A (and that's what it is) they represent Minority Shareholders, who in the main would have dearly loved to have been paid out at the same rate as JRP. The Company beleive it is complying with Company Law, and the reality is there is very little they can do about it.
“We are keen to establish which directors acted in March 2021 to facilitate and approve the loan of £4.95m Loan from Group to Wisdom Smart Corporation Ltd”
Missed that Malc. Point being that even if they establish who did, there is very little they can do about it.
RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - Malcolm Tucker - 08-05-2022
(08-05-2022, 08:23 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (08-05-2022, 07:45 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: (08-05-2022, 03:27 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: A couple of things spring to mind from a quick skim :-
1. Why aren't S4A asking who made the decision to make the loan? It's hardly a case of Directors acting in accordance with their Fiduciary Duty if the monies are being lent to a company in financial distress?
2. The Jersey Holding Company looks like a move to bring the ownership vehicle nearer the UK. The individuals named are likely to be Corporate Trustees, and have nothing to do with any takeover - or otherwise.
3. For all the whinging of S4A (and that's what it is) they represent Minority Shareholders, who in the main would have dearly loved to have been paid out at the same rate as JRP. The Company beleive it is complying with Company Law, and the reality is there is very little they can do about it.
“We are keen to establish which directors acted in March 2021 to facilitate and approve the loan of £4.95m Loan from Group to Wisdom Smart Corporation Ltd”
Missed that Malc. Point being that even if they establish who did, there is very little they can do about it.
Possibly not but if the company were to somehow go under then whoever signed off on that loan would likely find themselves in a degree of trouble under the Companies Act.
RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - Kit Kat Chunky - 08-05-2022
(08-05-2022, 08:33 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: (08-05-2022, 08:23 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (08-05-2022, 07:45 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: (08-05-2022, 03:27 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: A couple of things spring to mind from a quick skim :-
1. Why aren't S4A asking who made the decision to make the loan? It's hardly a case of Directors acting in accordance with their Fiduciary Duty if the monies are being lent to a company in financial distress?
2. The Jersey Holding Company looks like a move to bring the ownership vehicle nearer the UK. The individuals named are likely to be Corporate Trustees, and have nothing to do with any takeover - or otherwise.
3. For all the whinging of S4A (and that's what it is) they represent Minority Shareholders, who in the main would have dearly loved to have been paid out at the same rate as JRP. The Company beleive it is complying with Company Law, and the reality is there is very little they can do about it.
“We are keen to establish which directors acted in March 2021 to facilitate and approve the loan of £4.95m Loan from Group to Wisdom Smart Corporation Ltd”
Missed that Malc. Point being that even if they establish who did, there is very little they can do about it.
Possibly not but if the company were to somehow go under then whoever signed off on that loan would likely find themselves in a degree of trouble under the Companies Act.
I was going to say similar I think it would need an Insolvency Practitioner to be appointed before there could be any recourse
RE: S4A information - FAO fan base - SophLad - 08-06-2022
(08-05-2022, 07:29 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (08-05-2022, 01:32 PM)SophLad Wrote: Anyone provide me with a 3 line summary?
The club lent one of Lai’s companies £5m
Lai will declare a dividend to repay the said £5m
Lai will repay the loan using the money from the
said dividend and wba will be
£5m shorter in the bank at the end of the day
How’s that Soph? Hope you managed to grasp that as most Albion fans seem to struggle with it. Along with getting in to their new XXXL replica top
Wasn't that hard was it? The 3 line summary that is, not fitting into a XXXL shirt.
(08-05-2022, 08:23 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (08-05-2022, 07:45 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: (08-05-2022, 03:27 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: A couple of things spring to mind from a quick skim :-
1. Why aren't S4A asking who made the decision to make the loan? It's hardly a case of Directors acting in accordance with their Fiduciary Duty if the monies are being lent to a company in financial distress?
2. The Jersey Holding Company looks like a move to bring the ownership vehicle nearer the UK. The individuals named are likely to be Corporate Trustees, and have nothing to do with any takeover - or otherwise.
3. For all the whinging of S4A (and that's what it is) they represent Minority Shareholders, who in the main would have dearly loved to have been paid out at the same rate as JRP. The Company beleive it is complying with Company Law, and the reality is there is very little they can do about it.
“We are keen to establish which directors acted in March 2021 to facilitate and approve the loan of £4.95m Loan from Group to Wisdom Smart Corporation Ltd”
Missed that Malc. Point being that even if they establish who did, there is very little they can do about it.
Tbf, it was buried in 3 pages on waffle. For a bunch of 'highly qualified professionals' they should know how to write a letter.
|