WBAUnofficial
Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor (/showthread.php?tid=25230)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - MrFizz - 05-10-2022

(05-10-2022, 05:38 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Don't blame them. If you can't get game time above the absolute shower of shite that is our squad, then they never will.

Poor from the club.

The academy needs shutting down. It doesn't serve a purpose,  which is a shame.

3 of the back4 that finished the game on Sat were from our academy.........


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Tom Joad - 05-10-2022

Cornflake Wrote:Its not worth gambling £20k/week on a kid unless they are clearly (not Cleary!) gonna make it. Good luck to someone else taking that risk. Most don't make it.

From his perspective he gets an early payday so he can lose all motivation and piss it up the wall. Modern football.

£20K a week is a pipedream. We pay them about £1K/week, I believe Iragbonum (whatever the spelling) doubled that at VP. It's hard to knock the club re Cleary. They were damned if they do, damned if they don't. As someone said though, with the shitshower of unprofessionalism we've seen from the 1st team squad, I'd have hoped we tried everything to get Cleary in. If that is the case then so be it.


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Cunninghamismagic - 05-10-2022

(05-10-2022, 06:38 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(05-10-2022, 05:38 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Don't blame them. If you can't get game time above the absolute shower of shite that is our squad, then they never will.

Poor from the club.

The academy needs shutting down. It doesn't serve a purpose,  which is a shame.

3 of the back4 that finished the game on Sat were from our academy.........

Don't let facts get in the way of a bit of Albion bashing


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Hopalong - 05-10-2022

(05-10-2022, 05:38 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Don't blame them. If you can't get game time above the absolute shower of shite that is our squad, then they never will.

Poor from the club.

The academy needs shutting down. It doesn't serve a purpose,  which is a shame.

Cleary is nowhere near ready for the first team. 

Last two seasons - O'Shea, Ferguson, TGH -  Taylor/Fellows/Ashworth (coming through?) 

Recently - Roberts, Rogers, Forss 

The Academy is doing an amazing job and washing its face many times over.


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - SW4Baggie - 05-10-2022

(05-10-2022, 06:36 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-10-2022, 05:38 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Don't blame them. If you can't get game time above the absolute shower of shite that is our squad, then they never will.

Poor from the club.

The academy needs shutting down. It doesn't serve a purpose,  which is a shame.

I really do believe Cleary would have seen plenty of minutes from the bench had he signed his contract. He didn't so we didn't play him.

Theres an argument to say that was petulant from the club given our paucity in front of goal but I can understand it too. 

That said on the flip side if we had played him and he scored a few then surely we could argue higher compo in the event of a tribunal fee.

Lets see what happens with him but like I said earlier it wouldn't surprise me one bit if he's not announced at Villa by the end of the week.

Tribunals mean nothing Peachy, only have to look at the absolute peanuts we received for Ferguson 2 years after he left, and if there was a chance of us getting more, he’d just have a couple months in Spain only for them not to pay what’s due.

Cleary wanted a massive payday and has put that ahead of his career. I think the club are blameless here, had he wanted 2-3k a week, it was a risk worth taking but to tie up what could be several million quid on the wages he wants would be ridiculous and rewarding the kind of egotism that we need to stamp out of our kids.

Playing first team football for this club should be a great reward and the result of your hard work and commitment, and we need players that believe it. Regardless if talent, if they don’t feel that way they’re better off elsewhere.


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - KRO - 05-10-2022

(05-10-2022, 05:38 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Don't blame them. If you can't get game time above the absolute shower of shite that is our squad, then they never will.

Poor from the club.

The academy needs shutting down. It doesn't serve a purpose,  which is a shame.

Morgan Rogers has paid for it for a few seasons


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - SW4Baggie - 05-10-2022

(05-10-2022, 09:22 PM)KRO Wrote:
(05-10-2022, 05:38 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Don't blame them. If you can't get game time above the absolute shower of shite that is our squad, then they never will.

Poor from the club.

The academy needs shutting down. It doesn't serve a purpose,  which is a shame.

Morgan Rogers has paid for it for a few seasons

And he’s currently warming Bournemouth’s bench… think they have to pay City a good £10m now they’re promoted… will be interesting if they try and wriggle out of that deal, as it’s certainly not in his interests to move there and end up out on loan again.


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Bob Fossil - 05-11-2022

(05-10-2022, 07:18 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(05-10-2022, 05:38 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Don't blame them. If you can't get game time above the absolute shower of shite that is our squad, then they never will.

Poor from the club.

The academy needs shutting down. It doesn't serve a purpose,  which is a shame.

Cleary is nowhere near ready for the first team. 

Last two seasons - O'Shea, Ferguson, TGH -  Taylor/Fellows/Ashworth (coming through?) 

Recently - Roberts, Rogers, Forss 

The Academy is doing an amazing job and washing its face many times over.
If the whole Academy system wasn't rigged in favour of the rich, as is everything else in the modern game, we would have one of the most competitive Academies in the League.
As it is they can just poach them, by flashing the cash, which is peanuts to them but life changing to a 17year old, whilst the club that brings them through gets fuck all.
You can't blame the kids and you can't blame the club, as always, it's the wretched game itself that is our biggest enemy.


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Peachy - 05-11-2022

(05-11-2022, 07:59 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(05-10-2022, 07:18 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(05-10-2022, 05:38 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Don't blame them. If you can't get game time above the absolute shower of shite that is our squad, then they never will.

Poor from the club.

The academy needs shutting down. It doesn't serve a purpose,  which is a shame.

Cleary is nowhere near ready for the first team. 

Last two seasons - O'Shea, Ferguson, TGH -  Taylor/Fellows/Ashworth (coming through?) 

Recently - Roberts, Rogers, Forss 

The Academy is doing an amazing job and washing its face many times over.
If the whole Academy system wasn't rigged in favour of the rich, as is everything else in the modern game, we would have one of the most competitive Academies in the League.
As it is they can just poach them, by flashing the cash, which is peanuts to them but life changing to a 17year old, whilst the club that brings them through gets fuck all.
You can't blame the kids and you can't blame the club, as always, it's the wretched game itself that is our biggest enemy.

I've banged on about this a lot on here but it can be so easily solved imo. 

Compensation fee's haven't changed for over a decade and that just allows top clubs to stockpile players for peanuts. The solution is quite simple for me.

First things first all players at 14 sign a 4 year contract. If a young player then moves from an A CAT academy club to another A CAT academy they are not moving for anything other than money. The academy structure means all A CAT clubs are equal and offer the same training structure otherwise they wouldn't have been granted that status. So with that in mind the FA need to put in place a simple payment structure if a player leaves one academy for another. Any player moving between A CAT academies against the will of a club should be subject of a flat £2m fee + a 25% sell on clause and 25% of any futuree loan fees.

Its that simple. It won't stop the best players going but it will focus the minds of the poaching club as to wether they really want to take that risk and investment.

If a club releases a kid then its fair game and they can go wherever they want.


RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Ted Maul - 05-11-2022

Surely the frustration is that when we do have an opportunity to play the kids, we never seem to take it. This is poles apart from suggesting we throw completely untried 17 year old kids into the team on a whim. Unless you're a generational talent (Rooney, Bellingham), it doesn't work.

We would have lost nothing by giving Palmer (not even a youngster anymore, but "one of our own) a run of games up to the end of the season but instead we went for the steady option. Sunderland have gone through the POs with an untried 21 year old in goal, Wolves were forced years back into giving Hennessey a game because of injuries. We always seem to take the safe option.

If money is as tight as predicted then the likes of Taylor, Ashworth, Ingram should be in and around the team from the off next season. If there's an injury or suspension, give them their chance. It's the only way they'll learn and despite what is said fans are always more patient with academy graduates. It'll be a huge disappointment, if we don't see more minutes from the youngsters next season.